NYC's Best Oysters [Updated 2025]

Whether you’re a seasoned oyster aficionado or just curious to dive into the briny world of these delicious mollusks, I've scoured the city to uncover the top spots that serve up the freshest, most mouthwatering oysters around. After tasting my way through a dozen standout locations, I can confidently say there’s something for everyone, from cozy bars to upscale seafood havens.

With my passion for food and a nose for hidden gems, you can trust that my recommendations come from a place of genuine love for the city’s culinary scene. So, grab your slurping skills and let’s embark on this oyster adventure together! Your taste buds are in for a treat!

Cull & Pistol

Cull & Pistol is a delightful oyster haven tucked away in Chelsea Market. The moment I stepped in, the cozy yet breezy vibe set the perfect tone for an oyster adventure. Their selection is impressive, featuring fresh, briny specimens from both coasts. I savored the Luxurious Kumamotos—a sweet, buttery treat that slid effortlessly down my throat. The knowledgeable staff eagerly guided me through the menu, enhancing my experience with spot-on pairings of sauces. Overall, Cull & Pistol delivers a memorable oyster journey, making it a must-visit for any seafood lover in NYC. I left with a smile and a full belly!

You might also want to check out the best oysters in Manhattan.

Mermaid Oyster Bar

Mermaid Oyster Bar is a true gem nestled in the heart of the city. From the moment I stepped in, the nautical charm set the perfect ambiance for a delightful seafood experience. The oysters here are nothing short of spectacular! I savored a variety, each with a unique briny sweetness that danced on my palate. The signature mignonette added an extra zing, elevating the tasting experience to new heights. The staff was attentive and knowledgeable, making recommendations that perfectly complemented my choices. If you're seeking a delightful oyster escapade, Mermaid Oyster Bar is an absolute must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Queens.

Grand Banks

Nestled on a historic wooden schooner, Grand Banks offers an oyster experience that feels delightfully whimsical. As I savored their featured selection, each briny bite transported me to the sea—fresh, vibrant, and absolutely charming. The salty-sweet brine of the Kumamoto oysters paired perfectly with a crisp glass of bubbly. The ambiance, with stunning views of the Hudson, elevates the entire outing into an unforgettable soirée. If you're in search of a unique spot to indulge in oyster bliss, this floating paradise is an absolute must-visit. Treat yourself to an experience that’s both adventurous and delectable!

You might also want to check out the best seafood tower in NYC.

Flex Mussels

At Flex Mussels, the oyster selection dazzled me right from the start! I savored the East Coast beauties, known for their briny profiles, and they were a perfect accompaniment to the charming ambiance. The staff was attentive and eager to share their knowledge, enhancing my tasting adventure. I especially enjoyed their unique mignonette options, adding a delightful twist to the shellfish experience. Each oyster was fresh, plump, and bursting with flavor, solidifying Flex Mussels as a must-visit destination for any oyster enthusiast. If you’re hunting for a casual yet refined seafood outing, this place should definitely be on your list!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Manhattan.

Grand Central Oyster Bar

Nestled within the bustling Grand Central Terminal, the Grand Central Oyster Bar is a delightful oasis for oyster enthusiasts. The dazzling selection boasts fresh, briny delights from both coasts, with the Blue Points stealing the show—so creamy and perfectly chilled, they practically dance on your palate. The atmosphere buzzes with a charming mix of history and hustle as you savor each bite. The oyster stew is also a hidden gem, rich and velvety with a kick of spice. With its iconic bar and knowledgeable staff, this spot is an absolute must-visit for anyone serious about their shellfish!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Long Island.

Docks Oyster Bar - Midtown East, NYC

At Docks Oyster Bar, the moment I stepped inside, I was enveloped by the enticing aroma of the sea. Their oysters, sourced from both coasts, offer a delightful symphony of flavors—each slurp transports you straight to the Atlantic. I particularly enjoyed the briny Jersey Shore specimens, which danced on my palate with a refreshing zing. The ambiance is retro-chic, making it a perfect spot to indulge in seafood delights. Pair your oysters with their sublime mignonette for an elevated experience. If you're on the hunt for the best oysters in NYC, this charming spot is simply unmissable!

You might also want to check out the best fast food in Manhattan.

upstate craft beer & oyster bar

Nestled in the heart of the city, upstate craft beer & oyster bar is a delightful haven for oyster lovers. The freshness of their catches is matched only by the entertaining atmosphere. I savored the delicately briny Wellfleet oysters, which offered a perfect balance of sweetness and salinity. Paired with a crisp local beer, each bite was an exploration of flavors that transported me to the coast. Their knowledgeable staff added a touch of charm, guiding my selections with enthusiasm. For an unforgettable oyster experience in NYC, this spot is a must-visit—an oceanic adventure right in the city!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Harlem.

Ama Raw Bar East Village

Nestled in the heart of the East Village, Ama Raw Bar is a delightful gem for oyster enthusiasts. The ambiance is both cozy and chic, inviting you to indulge in their exceptional selection. I savored the Tide Runners, which delivered a sweet brininess and a delicate finish that danced on my palate. The knowledgeable staff expertly curated pairings, enhancing the overall experience with their charming personalities. Don’t miss their inventive toppings that elevate each oyster to new heights. With friendly vibes and quality fare, Ama Raw Bar has earned its spot among NYC's finest oyster havens—it's a must-visit for any seafood lover!

You might also want to check out the best seafood market in Brooklyn.

Sagaponack

Tucked away in the lively East Hampton neighborhood, Sagaponack presents a delightful oyster journey. Their selection, featuring the plumpest Blue Points and briny Kumamotos, is a true testament to east coast excellence. Each bite bursts with freshness and pairs beautifully with their house-made mignonette, which adds a perfect zesty kick. The atmosphere is both inviting and vibrant, making it an ideal spot for oyster enthusiasts. Their knowledgeable staff is always ready to recommend the perfect pairing. If you're searching for a sublime oyster experience in NYC, make sure to swing by Sagaponack — you won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Brooklyn.

Mermaid Oyster Bar Times Square

Situated in the bustling heart of Times Square, Mermaid Oyster Bar offers a delightful retreat for seafood lovers. As I sampled their East Coast oysters, I was immediately captivated by their briny freshness and smooth texture. Each shuck was a burst of the ocean, perfectly complemented by their tangy mignonette. The atmosphere exudes a charming, nautical vibe that invites you to relax and savor every moment. If you're craving a playful twist on the classic oyster experience, this gem is not to be missed. Dive in, and let the flavors sweep you away!

You might also want to check out the best fast food in Brooklyn.

Maison Premiere

Nestled in the heart of Williamsburg, Maison Premiere offers a charming escape that transports you straight to New Orleans. The oyster selection is outstanding, featuring a rotating list from both coasts that ticks all the boxes for flavor and freshness. I particularly savored the briny, crisp Blue Points and the subtly sweet Kumamotos. The ambiance, aglow with vintage charm, invites you to linger while sipping a delightful absinthe cocktail. With its attentive staff and impeccable presentation, Maison Premiere stands out as a must-visit for oyster enthusiasts. Treat yourself to this delightful experience—you won’t regret it!

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in NYC.

Crave Fishbar

At Crave Fishbar, I was treated to an oyster lover's paradise. The selection was impressive, featuring fresh, briny delights from both coasts. The Montauk Pearl oysters, with their crisp finish, danced on my palate, while the Kumamoto brought a delightful sweetness that was hard to resist. The ambiance was cozy, and the knowledgeable staff guided me through the menu, making the experience feel even more personal. If you're searching for a spot where each oyster tells a story, Crave Fishbar is a must-visit. Don’t miss out on this shellfish haven!

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Long Island.