NYC's Best Lobster Roll [Updated 2024]

Having tasted and reviewed a whopping 12 lobster rolls across the city, I have embarked on a delicious journey to uncover the crème de la crème. From quaint seafood shacks in Red Hook to upscale restaurants in Midtown, my quest for perfection knows no bounds.

Get ready to sink your teeth into succulent chunks of lobster meat, tantalize your taste buds with the perfect balance of mayo and spices, and experience the unparalleled satisfaction of sinking your teeth into a buttery, toasted roll. Buckle up, my fellow lobster lovers, as we navigate the concrete jungle in search of the ultimate lobster roll.

Red Hook Lobster Pound

Highlights
Fresh Lobster
Tasty
Good and fast service
Delicious
Nice drink and beer list

Let me start by saying that the lobster at Red Hook Lobster Pound is as fresh as it gets. Each bite of their lobster roll is a testament to this. The succulent chunks of lobster meat are incredibly flavorful and tender, perfectly complemented by the warm, buttery roll it's served on.

I was pleasantly surprised by the tastiness of the lobster roll. The meat was not overpowered by excessive seasoning or unnecessary ingredients. Instead, it allowed the natural sweetness of the lobster to shine through. Every bite was a burst of oceanic delight.

What also impressed me was the good and fast service at Red Hook Lobster Pound. The staff was knowledgeable and friendly, making the dining experience even more enjoyable. It's worth mentioning that they have a nice drink and beer list, adding an extra touch to the overall experience.

The lobster roll itself is beyond delicious. The lobster chunks come in generous amounts, providing a satisfying and filling meal. The buttery roll adds the perfect amount of richness to each bite. It's an indulgent treat that leaves you wanting more.

Overall, Red Hook Lobster Pound provides a top-notch lobster roll that is a strong contender for the title of the best lobster roll in NYC. If you're a lobster lover like me, be sure to give it a try.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Long Island.

The Clam

Highlights
Cute, small place
Amazing rolls
Best burger
Fresh oysters
Excellent cuisine

Upon entering this cute, small place, I knew I was in for a treat. The atmosphere was lively and inviting, and I couldn't wait to taste their famous lobster rolls. The Clam did not disappoint!

First off, let's talk about the lobster rolls. They were amazing. The rolls were perfectly toasted, and the lobster meat was succulent and full of flavor. Each bite was a heavenly experience, and I couldn't help but appreciate the generous portions of lobster meat nestled within the buttery roll.

But here's the twist - The Clam is not just known for their lobster rolls. Believe it or not, they also serve the best burger in town! Made with high-quality ingredients and cooked to perfection, the burger is a must-try for those who appreciate a good ole' beef patty.

If you're a fan of seafood, The Clam has got you covered. Their fresh oysters were undeniably fresh, and each shell held a creamy, briny treasure. It was the perfect addition to my lobster roll feast.

The overall dining experience at The Clam was a delight. The friendly staff ensured that every aspect of our meal was taken care of, and the attention to detail in the cuisine was evident. It's safe to say that The Clam offers an excellent menu that goes beyond just lobster rolls.

So, if you find yourself searching for the best lobster roll in NYC, make sure to pay a visit to The Clam. With their amazing rolls, best burger, and fresh oysters, this gem of a restaurant will leave you craving for more. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Manhattan.

Oceans

Highlights
Quiet atmosphere
Fantastic service
Quality seafood
Luxe vibe
Large entrees

Upon walking into Oceans, I was immediately drawn to its quiet atmosphere, creating the perfect setting for a relaxing dining experience. The staff at Oceans provided me with fantastic service, catering to my every need and ensuring that I was comfortable throughout my visit.

Now let's talk about the main attraction – the lobster roll. Oceans certainly did not disappoint. The lobster meat was exceptionally fresh and tender, making each bite an absolute delight. The roll itself was perfectly buttered and toasted, adding an extra layer of flavor to an already mouthwatering dish.

What sets Oceans apart from other establishments is the quality of their seafood. Each ingredient used in their lobster roll was top-notch, showcasing their commitment to sourcing the finest seafood available. The portion size was generous, ensuring that I truly got my money's worth.

The luxe vibe of Oceans added a touch of elegance to the overall dining experience. From the stylish decor to the chic plating of the lobster roll, every detail was thoughtfully considered.

Although the lobster roll stole the show, it is worth mentioning that Oceans also offers a range of other dishes on their menu, all of which are as impressive as their lobster roll. The variety of options and the large entrees ensure that there is something to suit every palate.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best lobster roll in NYC, Oceans is a must-visit. With its quiet atmosphere, fantastic service, and quality seafood, you are guaranteed to have a memorable dining experience. So go ahead, indulge in a taste of luxury at Oceans – you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side in NYC is a seafood delight that transported me straight to the coast. Their lobster roll was a stunning masterpiece of buttery goodness. The meat was tender, sweet, and perfectly balanced with a hint of mayo and a sprinkle of secret seasoning. If you want a taste of New England without leaving the city, this is the must-visit spot.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Ed's Lobster Bar

Ed's Lobster Bar in NYC is a seafood playground where lobster roll dreams come true. The crustacean is juicy and flavorful, nestled in a buttery toasted bun. The generous portion is both indulgent and satisfying. It's no wonder why Ed's reigns as a top contender in NYC's lobster roll scene.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Lobster Place

Lobster Place in NYC is a marvelous seafood haven that serves up one of the most sensational lobster rolls in the city. The buttery roll holds a generous bounty of tender, succulent lobster meat that will make your taste buds dance. Don't forget to pair it with their crispy fries for the ultimate lobster roll experience!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Lobster Joint

Lobster Joint in NYC is a playground for seafood lovers. Their lobster roll is a burst of fresh, succulent lobster meat nestled in a buttery bun. The perfect balance of flavors is achieved with a hint of lemon and a touch of mayo. This place is a must-visit for lobster roll aficionados.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Cull & Pistol

I must say, Cull & Pistol is truly a seafood haven. Their lobster roll had a perfect balance of succulent lobster meat and a light, buttery sauce. The brioche bun was toasted to perfection, adding a delightful crunch. This roll is definitely a winner in the quest for the best lobster roll in NYC!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Mary's Fish Camp

Mary's Fish Camp in NYC is the hidden pearl where lobster roll dreams come true. With its buttery, toasted top-split bun and generous, succulent lobster chunks, this roll is pure heaven. The ambiance is charming, making it the perfect spot for seafood enthusiasts. A must-try!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Luke's Lobster Grand Central

Hey there lobster lovers! As I continue my quest for the best lobster roll in NYC, I made a stop at Luke's Lobster Grand Central. And oh boy, did they roll out the red carpet for my taste buds! The fluffy bun hugged the succulent chunks of lobster, and the secret mayo-based sauce danced on the palate. Mmm, perfection!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Luke's Lobster FiDi

As a self-proclaimed lobster roll expert, I recently embarked on a mission to find the best one in NYC. One of my stops was Luke's Lobster FiDi, and boy, did it not disappoint! The creamy mayo mixed perfectly with the tender lobster meat, creating a flavor explosion in my mouth. It was like a culinary rollercoaster, and I didn't want the ride to end. The bread was toasty and buttery, adding an extra layer of indulgence to an already indulgent dish. Overall, Luke's Lobster FiDi gets my seal of approval for their impeccable lobster roll.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Luke's Lobster Midtown East

The buttery and succulent lobster roll at Luke's Lobster Midtown East is a mouthwatering masterpiece. The generous portion of sweet lobster meat is delicately nestled into a toasted split-top bun, creating a perfect balance of flavors. With its impeccable seafood quality and affordable price, this lobster roll is a shining star in the NYC lobster roll scene.

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.