NYC's Best Italian Food [Updated 2025]

With my trusty fork in hand and a never-ending appetite for pasta, I've scoured this vibrant city to uncover twelve must-visit spots that showcase the soul of Italian cuisine. Each restaurant has been carefully chosen, not just for its mouth-watering dishes but for the unique stories and warm atmospheres that make them truly special.

I’ve dined, chatted with chefs, and indulged in countless plates of gnocchi and tiramisu, so you can trust that my picks represent the very best of what New York has to offer. Whether you’re a seasoned foodie or just looking for a cozy night out, you’re in for a delicious ride!

Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana

Highlights
Cozy and quaint atmosphere
Outstanding, friendly service
Delicious tiramisu and cheesecake
Generous, fresh pasta dishes
Great value for a quality meal

Visiting Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana felt like stepping into a warm embrace, with its cozy and quaint atmosphere enveloping me as soon as I entered. The friendly service was the cherry on top—a rarity in a bustling city like ours!

Now, let’s talk about the food! Their pasta dishes are nothing short of a culinary dream. Each plate was laden with generous helpings of fresh pasta, cooked to perfection, and dressed in sauces that sang of Sicily’s sun-kissed coast. I couldn’t resist finishing off my meal with a taste of their heavenly tiramisu and a slice of cheesecake that danced on my palate. It was the perfect balance of richness and creaminess, leaving me in a state of bliss.

What’s more? The value for such a delightful dining experience is impressive. Piccola Cucina strikes that perfect balance of affordable yet exquisite, ensuring that I’ll be returning before I know it. If you’re looking for that authentic Italian charm in NYC, I wholeheartedly recommend giving this gem a visit!

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Brooklyn.

Torrisi

Highlights
Michelin star restaurant
Excellent service
Grilled octopus perfection
Welcoming and attentive staff
Delicious tortellini pomodoro

Torrisi in NYC is a true gem that warrants its Michelin star status. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a welcoming ambiance and a staff that epitomized attentiveness. It’s not every day one finds such exceptional service paired with fabulous cuisine.

As I glanced through the menu, I couldn’t resist starting with the grilled octopus. Let me tell you, the preparation was nothing short of perfection—charred just right, with a tender texture that practically melted in my mouth. Following this, I dove into their tortellini pomodoro, a delightful dish that struck the perfect balance between sauce and pasta, showcasing the traditional Italian flavors that make this cuisine so irresistible.

Each bite was a reminder of why Italian food holds a special place in the heart of many. The entire dining experience was enhanced by the staff's personable approach, making me feel like more than just another patron. I'm certain that Torrisi is not just a restaurant; it's an experience, a celebration of Italian culture that leaves diners with a contagious smile. I can’t wait to return and uncover more of their incredible dishes!

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Long Island.

Osteria Carlina West Village

Highlights
Wonderful and romantic atmosphere
Attentive and friendly service
Divine angel hair pasta
Perfectly cooked veal milanese
Charming little spot

Osteria Carlina West Village is a hidden gem that truly embodies the heart and soul of Italian cuisine. As I stepped into this charming little spot, I was immediately enveloped by a wonderful and romantic atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The rustic decor and soft lighting set the perfect stage for what turned out to be a delightful culinary adventure.

From the moment I was greeted by the attentive and friendly service, I knew I was in good hands. It felt as though each staff member had been handpicked for their charm and knowledge of the menu. Now, let me tell you about the star of the show: the divine angel hair pasta. Cooked to perfection, the delicate strands danced on my palate and left me craving more with every bite.

Then came the perfectly cooked veal milanese, crisp yet succulent, it was as if my taste buds were celebrating. If you’re in the West Village and searching for an unforgettable Italian meal, look no further than Osteria Carlina. It's a love letter to Italian gastronomy, and I can’t wait to return!

You might also want to check out the best asian food in Brooklyn.

Monte's Trattoria

Highlights
Legacy NYC Italian Experience
Fantastic Osso Buco
Mixed Quality Dishes
Location Premium Pricing

Review of Monte's Trattoria

Nestled in the heart of New York City, Monte's Trattoria is a delightful throwback to classic Italian dining that instantly transports you to an authentic trattoria. As I walked through the charming entrance, I was greeted by warm, rustic decor that whispered stories of Italian heritage.

I couldn't resist trying their famed Osso Buco, a dish that seamlessly melted in my mouth. Each bite was a flavor explosion, perfectly seasoned and impeccably tender, leaving me craving more. The saffron-infused risotto that accompanied it was also a knockout, creamy and rich, harmonizing beautifully with the meat.

However, not every dish hit the mark. While the pasta dishes had their moments of brilliance, I found some mixed quality across the menu. Prices are on the higher side, which is expected given the locale. Yet, for the stunning ambiance and a taste of Italian legacy, I could overlook that slight hiccup.

Ultimately, Monte’s Trattoria is a spot worth visiting not just for the food but for the experience. It’s a celebration of Italian culture that warms both the heart and belly, making it a must-try on your NYC food adventure!

You might also want to check out the best asian food in Manhattan.

Osteria Barocca

Tucked away in the heart of NYC, Osteria Barocca had me at benvenuti! The moment I stepped inside, the warm ambiance wrapped around me like a cozy Italian hug. Their homemade pasta was a revelation—each bite bursting with freshness and bold flavors. I savored the truffle fettuccine, which danced delightfully on my palate. The wine list? An elegant selection that perfectly complemented my meal. Service was impeccable, making me feel like part of the family. Whether you’re a seasoned foodie or a curious traveler, Osteria Barocca is a must-visit for an unforgettable Italian feast in NYC! 🍷✨

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Queens.

Osteria Nonnino

Nestled in the heart of the city, Osteria Nonnino is a delightful Italian gem that whisked me away on a culinary adventure. As I savored their homemade gnocchi in a rich marinara sauce, I felt like I was plucked right from the concrete jungle and placed into a cozy Italian kitchen. The ambiance was perfectly rustic, while the staff’s genuine warmth made me feel like family. Don’t miss their tiramisu, which danced beautifully on my palate. For anyone in search of authentic flavors with a delightful twist, Osteria Nonnino is an unforgettable experience that deserves a spot on your must-try list!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Manhattan.

Via Carota

Nestled in the heart of the West Village, Via Carota is a delightful throwback to rustic Italian dining. The moment I entered, the warm ambiance embraced me, setting the stage for an unforgettable meal. Their Cacio e Pepe is a creamy, peppery masterpiece that dances on the palate, while the Sformato di Carciofi is an artful interpretation of artichokes that deserves applause. The wine list is an Italian dream, perfectly complementing each dish. Dining here feels like an intimate gathering with friends, where every bite tells a story. For authentic Italian comfort, Via Carota is a must-visit gem!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Long Island City.

Osteria La Baia

Nestled in the heart of the bustling city, Osteria La Baia is a delightful gem that enchants with its authentic charm. From the moment I stepped inside, the warm ambiance wrapped around me like a soft Italian embrace. The cacio e pepe was a creamy dream, perfectly balanced with just the right amount of kick. I couldn't resist diving into their homemade tagliatelle ragu, which transported me straight to the streets of Bologna. Each dish is a tribute to the culinary arts, making it clear that Osteria La Baia is a must-visit for any food lover in search of extraordinary Italian cuisine in NYC!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Harlem.

Don Angie

When I stepped into Don Angie, I was instantly captivated by its chic yet cozy atmosphere. Their unique take on classic dishes truly redefines Italian cuisine. I savored the Lasagna for Two—a delightful dish that beautifully layered flavors and textures, leaving me craving more. The Anolini in brodo was a soulful embrace of warmth on a chilly evening. Don't skip the Carrot Cake Tiramisu; it's a playful twist that concludes the meal on a sweet note. In this bustling city, Don Angie stands out as a must-visit gem for anyone seeking remarkable Italian fare!

You might also want to check out the best italian pastry shops in NYC.

L'Artusi

As I stepped into L'Artusi, I was immediately enveloped by a warm, inviting ambiance that perfectly complements their exquisite menu. The ricotta gnocchi practically danced on my palate, while the roasted chicken was a masterclass in flavor and tenderness. Their signature olive oil cake for dessert was a sweet finale that lingers in my memory like an enchanting melody. Each bite felt like a love letter to Italian cuisine. If you’re seeking a culinary escape in the heart of NYC, L'Artusi is an absolute must-visit—where every dish tells a delightful story!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Osteria 57

Osteria 57 in NYC is a delightful gem that truly captures the spirit of Italian cuisine. From the moment I stepped in, the cozy ambiance wrapped around me like a warm embrace. The pasta fresca is a must-try, perfectly al dente and dressed in a rich, savory sauce that sings in harmony with fresh herbs. My dish, the osso buco, was a tender masterpiece that melted away with each bite. The staff radiated warmth and genuine passion for their craft, making it feel like I was dining at a friend's home. For an authentic experience, Osteria 57 is absolutely unmissable!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Nonna Dora's

Stepping into Nonna Dora's is like being enveloped in a warm Italian embrace. The rustic decor and the aromatic symphony wafting from the kitchen instantly charm. I savored their homemade burata, which was decadently creamy, paired with crisp, heirloom tomatoes that sang of summer. The pasta al pomodoro was sheer perfection—each bite was a delightful dance of flavors, embodying la dolce vita. And don't get me started on their tiramisu—it was a cloud of espresso-soaked bliss! If you’re seeking a heartwarming slice of Italy, Nonna Dora's is an absolute must-visit in NYC! 🌟

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.