NYC's Best Italian Pastry Shops [Updated 2025]

Having grown up in the heart of the Big Apple, I've had the privilege of indulging in some of the most delectable Italian pastries this city has to offer. With countless hours spent exploring the narrow streets of Little Italy and savoring each mouthwatering bite, I can confidently say that I know a thing or two about the very best Italian pastry shops in this concrete jungle.

After meticulously reviewing a staggering twelve establishments, I am excited to share my expert recommendations with you, ensuring that your sweet tooth cravings are met with only the finest and most authentic Italian treats. So, join me as we embark on a delicious journey through the top Italian pastry shops in NYC!

Zeppieri & Sons Italian Bakery

Highlights
Freshly baked goods
Delectable pastries
Mouthwatering cakes
Staple in the neighborhood
Love and heart baked into every detail

Walking into Zeppieri & Sons Italian Bakery is like stepping into a little slice of heaven. The tantalizing smell of freshly baked goods greets you at the door, instantly making your taste buds dance with anticipation. This family-owned pastry shop is truly a hidden gem in the heart of NYC.

The moment I laid my eyes on their pastry display, I knew I was in for a treat. The selection of delectable pastries was simply mouthwatering. From the flaky cannoli to the luscious tiramisu, every bite was a taste bud symphony. The attention to detail and quality of ingredients was evident in every bite, leaving me wanting more.

But the goodness doesn't stop at pastries. Zeppieri & Sons also offers a variety of mouthwatering cakes that are impossible to resist. The velvety texture and the perfect balance of flavors in each slice were pure indulgence. It was like a little piece of Italy had been transported to NYC.

What sets Zeppieri & Sons apart from other Italian bakeries is not only their exceptional pastries and cakes but also the warm and welcoming atmosphere. This bakery is a staple in the neighborhood, and the love and heart that they put into every detail is apparent. The staff is friendly and eager to share their passion for their craft, making the experience all the more enjoyable.

If you're craving an authentic Italian pastry experience in NYC, Zeppieri & Sons Italian Bakery is a must-visit. Prepare to lose yourself in a world of heavenly treats and leave with a happy soul and a satisfied sweet tooth. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Brooklyn.

Fortunato Brothers

Highlights
Amazing pastries
Must-visit in Brooklyn
Variety of options
Delicious gelato
Nutella cannoli

Walking into Fortunato Brothers, I was greeted by the sweet aroma of freshly baked pastries that made my mouth water. Conveniently nestled in Brooklyn, this hidden gem is a must-visit for any pastry lover in the city.

The first thing that caught my eye was the amazing display of pastries that lined the counter. From delicate cannoli to mouthwatering sfogliatelle, there was a wide variety of options that catered to all taste buds. I couldn't resist trying their famous Nutella cannoli, and boy, was it a heavenly experience. The crispy shell filled with a rich and creamy Nutella filling was an absolute delight.

Aside from the delectable pastries, Fortunato Brothers also offers a selection of delicious gelato flavors. I indulged in a scoop of their creamy pistachio gelato, and it was like taking a trip to Italy with each spoonful.

What sets Fortunato Brothers apart from other pastry shops is the attention to detail and the quality of their ingredients. Each pastry is crafted with precision and love, ensuring a taste that is unparalleled. Whether you're craving a traditional Italian treat or something with a modern twist, this place has got you covered.

In conclusion, Fortunato Brothers is truly a hidden gem in Brooklyn. Their amazing pastries, wide variety of options, and delicious gelato make it one of the best Italian pastry shops in NYC. Don't miss out on this little piece of Italy right in the heart of the city.

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Long Island.

Il Forno Bakery (by Tarallucci e Vino)

Il Forno Bakery (by Tarallucci e Vino) in NYC is a delightful spot for Italian pastry lovers. Their decadent cannoli, filled with creamy ricotta and topped with crunchy pistachios, will transport your taste buds to the streets of Sicily. Don't miss their flaky sfogliatelle and rich tiramisu. A true Italian gem in the Big Apple.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

La Guli Pastry Shop

La Guli Pastry Shop in NYC was a delightful discovery in my search for the best Italian pastry shops. The atmosphere was inviting with mouth-watering aromas that drew me in. Their cannoli were heavenly, with a perfect balance of creamy filling and crispy shell. A must-visit for any pastry lover!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Circo's Pastry Shop

Hey there! As an expert in reviewing Italian pastry shops, let me tell you about my recent visit to Circo's Pastry Shop in NYC. This playful yet professional spot impressed me with their delectable treats. A must-visit for any dessert lover!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Veniero's Pasticceria & Caffe

In my quest to discover the best Italian pastry shops in NYC, I had the pleasure of visiting Veniero's Pasticceria & Caffe. As an expert reviewer, I can confidently say that Veniero's is a delightful haven for pastry lovers. The moment I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked treats enveloped me, transporting me to the streets of Rome. From their flaky cannoli to their decadent tiramisu, every bite was a heavenly experience. What truly impressed me was their attention to detail and commitment to preserving traditional Italian recipes. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, guiding me through their vast selection of pastries. It's a place where taste buds dance with joy. Veniero's Pasticceria & Caffe is a sweet escape in the heart of NYC and a must-visit for all lovers of Italian pastries.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Ferrara Bakery & Cafe

Ferrara Bakery & Cafe in NYC is a charming haven for pastry lovers. The moment I stepped inside, the intoxicating aroma of fresh baked goodies greeted me. With an extensive selection of traditional Italian pastries, from cannoli to sfogliatelle, each bite transported me to the streets of Rome. The delicate flakiness of their pastries combined with the decadent fillings is simply divine. The atmosphere is cozy yet lively, making it the perfect spot to indulge in a sweet treat. Don't miss the chance to savor this pastry paradise in the heart of NYC.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Pasticceria Rocco

Pasticceria Rocco in NYC was a delightful sugar-coated dreamland! Their pastries were a work of art - from the velvety cannoli to the flaky sfogliatelle, each bite transported me to Italy. The charming atmosphere added to the overall indulgent experience. It's safe to say, Pasticceria Rocco is a sweet haven for any dessert lover in the Big Apple.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Joe's Sicilian Bakery Inc.

Joe's Sicilian Bakery Inc. in NYC is an absolute delight! The aroma of freshly-baked pastries dances in the air, luring you into a world of culinary pleasure. Their cannoli are a divine treat, with a crispy shell and a velvety smooth filling that melts in your mouth. The espresso pairs perfectly with their delicate sfogliatelle, adding a caffeinated kick to the experience. The friendly staff adds to the warm atmosphere, making you feel like part of the Italian family. Bellissimo!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

La Bella Ferrara

La Bella Ferrara in NYC is like uncovering a treasure chest of authentic Italian pastries. The aroma of fresh cannoli and sfogliatelle wafts through the air, tempting even the strongest willpower. The delicate cream filling in their cannoli is simply divine, and their flaky sfogliatelle is a work of art. La Bella Ferrara is a hidden gem that perfectly captures the essence of Italian pastry. Treat yourself and indulge in their sweet creations – you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Zeppola Bakery

Zeppola Bakery in NYC is an eccentric little haven for Italian pastry enthusiasts. Their *unbelievably fluffy cannoli and decadent tiramisu are a party for your taste buds. Make sure to try their chocolate-dipped zeppole - it's pure bliss!

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

La Delice Pastry Shop

My visit to La Delice Pastry Shop in NYC was nothing short of a delicious adventure! From the moment I stepped inside, the aroma of freshly baked pastries filled the air, tempting me to sample everything in sight. The delectable cannoli and sfogliatelle were simply divine. With its charming ambiance and mouthwatering treats, La Delice truly lives up to its name. Don't miss out on this hidden gem in NYC's vibrant pastry scene.

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.