NYC's Best Ice Cream [Updated 2025]

Trust me, I know ice cream like the back of my hand—especially in this city that’s a melting pot of flavors! After scouring the streets and sampling scoops from 12 of the top locations, I’ve discovered not just the classics, but also some hidden gems that will make your taste buds dance.

Whether you’re craving a rich, creamy gelato or a quirky vegan twist, I’ve got the scoop on where to find the most delectable treats. As someone who lives and breathes this city, I’m here to guide you through the sweet spots that will keep you coming back for more. Let’s dive into this delicious adventure together!

Soft Swerve Ice Cream - Allen

Highlights
Delicious Ube ice cream
Ideal for outdoor enjoyment
Small but cozy space
Mixed service experiences
Fun birthday cake flavor

After hearing the buzz about Soft Swerve Ice Cream - Allen, I simply had to drop by and see if their creations lived up to the hype. Stepping into this cozy spot, you instantly feel a vibrant energy; it's perfect for a sunny day spent indulging in delightful flavors. I couldn’t resist their famous Ube ice cream, a striking purple treat that didn't just look stunning, but also danced on my palate with its sweet, nutty notes—a truly unique flavor that sets them apart from the rest.

The selection is playful, with a variety of whimsical offerings, including the much-touted birthday cake flavor, which is a nostalgic nod to childhood celebrations. It's slightly lighter than your average cake, making it a perfect pair with the velvety Ube.

While I encountered mixed service experiences during my visit, the charming atmosphere and luscious ice cream made it worth the trip. Overall, I left with a smile and a satisfied heart, feeling that Soft Swerve truly deserves its place among the best ice creams in NYC. Don't miss this sweet gem on your next ice cream adventure!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Queens.

Bambina Blue Gelato Wonder Room

Highlights
Incredible passion fruit flavor
Cozy and welcoming ambiance
Massive scoop size
Extraordinary customer service
Delicious and unique offerings

Bambina Blue Gelato Wonder Room is undoubtedly a gem nestled in the heart of NYC, and my taste buds are still dancing from the delightful visit! As I stepped inside their cozy sanctuary, I was enveloped by an ambiance that felt both welcoming and whimsical. The real showstopper, however, was the incredible passion fruit flavor that I couldn’t resist. Each spoonful was a burst of tropical sunshine, perfectly balancing sweetness and tang.

Let’s talk about the scoop sizes—they're huge! I felt like a kid in an ice cream wonderland, excitedly diving into my generous serving. Not only did the flavor captivate me, but the extraordinary customer service made the experience all the more enjoyable. The staff is friendly, attentive, and eager to share their knowledge about their creations.

With their delicious and unique offerings, Bambina Blue Gelato Wonder Room isn’t just serving ice cream; they're crafting memories! Whether you're a local or just passing through, this spot deserves a place on your dessert checklist. Immerse yourself in the joy of gelato right here—it’s a sweet adventure you won’t forget!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Brooklyn.

Sugar Hill Creamery

Stepping into Sugar Hill Creamery is like entering a whimsical dreamscape of flavor. Their commitment to crafting small-batch ice creams shines through in every scoop. I savored the Sweet Corn and Black Raspberry, a delightfully unexpected pairing that dances on the palate. The creamy texture is impeccable, making it the perfect treat on a warm day. The vibrant vibe of this Harlem gem, coupled with friendly staff, adds to the charm. Don't miss out on their seasonal flavors; each visit promises something new and delicious. In a city overflowing with options, Sugar Hill truly stands out as a scoop above the rest!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Long Island.

Sundaes Best

Sundaes Best is truly a gem in the bustling streets of NYC. As soon as I stepped inside, the delightful aroma of freshly made waffle cones enveloped me. Their signature sundae is a harmonious blend of rich vanilla bean ice cream, warm fudge, and crunchy toppings that add the perfect texture. I was pleasantly surprised by their unique flavors, like lavender honey, which danced on my palate. The friendly staff made the experience even sweeter, providing recommendations with infectious enthusiasm. If you're on a quest for ice cream nirvana, Sundaes Best is a must-visit destination. Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Manhattan.

il laboratorio del gelato

Il Laboratorio del Gelato is a delightful haven for any ice cream enthusiast! Upon entering, I was immediately captivated by the handcrafted gelato bursting with unique flavors. I opted for their honey lavender, and it was a heavenly blend of floral notes and creamy goodness. Every scoop felt like an art piece, made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The vibrant atmosphere paired with the passionate staff made my visit truly enjoyable. If you’re seeking an extraordinary ice cream experience, don’t miss this gem; it's truly a sweet celebration of flavor right in the heart of NYC! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Harlem.

Davey's Ice Cream

From the moment I stepped into Davey's Ice Cream, I was greeted by a delightful whirlwind of scents that tickled my senses. Their unique flavors, like Honeycomb and Matcha Green Tea, seduced my taste buds and took me on a delicious adventure. I indulged in a creamy scoop of their signature Brown Butter Almond Brittle, which was a perfect harmony of sweet and nutty. The staff was friendly, adding a personal touch that made my visit even more enjoyable. For anyone seeking a playful twist on classic ice cream, Davey's is a must-try gem in the heart of the city!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Brooklyn.

Anita La Mamma del Gelato

During my visit to Anita La Mamma del Gelato, I was whisked away into a world of vibrant flavors and creamy textures. The pistachio had a richness that danced on my palate, while the dark chocolate sorbet delivered an exhilarating punch without the heaviness. Each scoop felt like a celebration of quality ingredients and Italian artistry. The charming atmosphere added to the experience, inviting me to linger longer with every delightful lick. If you’re on the hunt for a taste of true gelato bliss, Anita is undoubtedly a must-visit for NYC ice cream lovers! 🍦

You might also want to check out the best brunch in NYC.

Figo il Gelato Italiano

At Figo il Gelato Italiano, every scoop is a delightful escape to Italy! This charming gelateria offers an array of flavors that dance on your palate—think pistachio so creamy it could make you weep! The rich textures and vibrant tastes reflect the authentic gelato-making craft. I savored the stracciatella, a heavenly mix of sweet cream with chocolate shards, perfectly balanced. The friendly staff adds to the experience, making you feel like family. If you're in search of a sweet treat that transports you across the ocean, Figo is an absolute must-visit! 🌟🍦 #GelatoGoals

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Sundaes and Cones

At Sundaes and Cones, the whimsical ambiance instantly transports you to a sweet paradise. Their unique flavors—from roasted coconut to green tea—are not just delicious; they’re an adventure for your taste buds! I savored a scoop of their salted caramel, which perfectly balanced rich creaminess with a delightful zing. The cones, freshly made and crisp, are the ideal vessel for their creamy creations. The payoff? A delightful treat that’s both classic and surprisingly innovative, making each visit unforgettable. If you're in the area, treat yourself to a scoop here—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Queens.

Gelatoville Gelataria & Coffee

Walking into Gelatoville Gelataria & Coffee is like stepping into a delicious fantasy! Their artisan gelato is a symphony of flavors, each scoop bursting with personality. I savored the salted caramel, which struck the perfect balance between sweet and savory, while the pistachio transported me to a sun-kissed Italian piazza. The creamy texture was exquisite, making every bite feel indulgent. The ambiance is cozy, ideal for a casual hangout or a quick escape from city life. If you're craving a unique treat, you must add Gelatoville to your ice cream itinerary—it’s a scoop of happiness in every cone!

You might also want to check out the best cakes in NYC.

Uncle Louie G

Uncle Louie G is a delightful gem, where nostalgia meets creamy indulgence. Their Italian ices are a refreshing twist on traditional treats, bursting with authentic flavors that evoke summer memories. I sampled the coconut and melon, both of which delivered a refreshing kick. The texture is flawless—smooth, yet satisfyingly icy. Their gelato, rich and velvety, is another highlight; I especially loved the pistachio, which was nutty and perfectly balanced. With its charming atmosphere and friendly service, Uncle Louie G stands out as a must-visit for anyone craving a sweet escape in the heart of NYC.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Morgenstern's BANANAS

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Morgenstern's BANANAS, and it was an absolute delight! This whimsical spot serves up a sumptuous array of banana-based creations that redefine what ice cream can be. I was particularly enchanted by their Banana Pudding Sundae; the balance of creaminess and sweetness was simply divine! The texture was velvety, with crunchy bits of cookie adding a delightful contrast. As I indulged, I couldn't help but appreciate the artful presentation—a feast for both the eyes and taste buds. If you’re a banana lover, this gem is a must-visit for an exquisite ice cream experience!

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurants in NYC.