The Absolute Best Ice Cream in Long Island [Updated 2024]

Over the years, I have indulged in countless scoops of creamy goodness in my beloved Long Island. With a passion for ice cream running through my veins, I have made it my mission to seek out the crème de la crème of frozen treats.

After meticulously sampling from a dazzling array of flavors and textures, I have carefully selected the top twelve ice cream parlors in this vibrant region. From classic chocolaty delights to inventive artisanal creations, Long Island truly caters to every ice cream connoisseur's palate.

Join me on this delectable journey as we uncover the hidden gems and savor the finest frozen delights Long Island has to offer.

Sweet Charlie's

Highlights
Friendly workers
Quick service
Fun ice cream making process
Delicious flavor options
Kid-friendly portion sizes

From the moment I walked into Sweet Charlie's, I was greeted by their friendly workers who were eager to help me navigate through their extensive menu of ice cream flavors. The quick service was a pleasant surprise, as I didn't have to wait long to indulge in their delectable creations.

What sets Sweet Charlie's apart from other ice cream shops is their unique and entertaining ice cream making process. Watching the workers craft the ice cream right in front of me on a frozen plate was like witnessing a culinary show. It was a fun experience that added an extra touch of excitement to my visit.

I was truly spoilt for choice with their extensive selection of delicious flavor options. From classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla to creative combinations like salted caramel pretzel, there was something to please every ice cream connoisseur. The flavors were rich, creamy, and bursting with taste.

Another aspect that impressed me at Sweet Charlie's was their consideration for portion sizes. They offer kid-friendly sizes, making it easy for families to enjoy their ice cream together without overindulging.

Overall, Sweet Charlie's is a must-visit for any ice cream lover in Long Island. With their friendly workers, quick service, fun ice cream making process, and delicious flavor options, they have truly mastered the art of creating delectable frozen treats. Whether you're a fan of classic or adventurous flavors, Sweet Charlie's has something for everyone.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Hershey's Ice Cream & more

Highlights
Friendly staff
Delicious flavors
Late-night hours
Variety of flavors
Welcoming owner

Walking into Hershey's Ice Cream & more, I was greeted by a friendly staff that made me feel right at home. The inviting atmosphere combined with the delicious smells immediately sparked my anticipation.

As I perused the extensive menu, I was delighted by the wide variety of flavors available. From classic options like chocolate and vanilla to unique creations like mint chocolate chip and strawberry cheesecake, there was something for everyone's taste buds.

I opted for a double scoop of their homemade chocolate and cookies and cream flavors in a waffle cone. The first bite was pure bliss. The rich and creamy texture of the ice cream was undeniable, and the flavors exploded in my mouth, teasing my senses and leaving me wanting more.

What truly set Hershey's Ice Cream & more apart was their late-night hours. Whether it's a craving that strikes at midnight or a spontaneous late-night hangout with friends, they've got you covered.

The welcoming owner, who was genuinely passionate about creating the best ice cream experience, added a personal touch to the visit. He gladly shared recommendations and tales of his own love for ice cream.

Overall, Hershey's Ice Cream & more exceeded my expectations. With its friendly staff, delicious flavors, late-night hours, and wide variety of choices, it's no wonder why it's considered one of the best ice cream spots in Long Island. Make sure to visit and treat yourself to a scoop or two – you won't regret it.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Lics Ice Cream

Highlights
Generous scoops
Many flavors
Great variety
Creamy vegan options

When it comes to ice cream, I can confidently say that Lics Ice Cream lives up to its reputation as one of the best in Long Island. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the sweet aroma of freshly churned ice cream. The friendly staff behind the counter stood ready to serve up generous scoops of deliciousness.

The menu boasted an impressive array of flavors, ranging from classic favorites like chocolate and vanilla to more unique creations like lavender honey and salted caramel pretzel. I couldn't help but feel like a kid in a candy store as I perused the great variety of options available.

What really impressed me, though, was their commitment to catering to all dietary preferences. Lics Ice Cream had a selection of creamy vegan options that were just as delectable as their dairy counterparts. As someone who frequently finds it challenging to satisfy my sweet tooth as a vegan, this was a delightful surprise.

The texture of the ice cream was nothing short of divine. Each scoop was velvety smooth and melted on my tongue, leaving behind a lingering sweetness that had me craving more. The flavors were perfectly balanced, and you could really taste the quality ingredients that had been used in their creation.

In conclusion, Lics Ice Cream truly deserves its spot among the best ice cream shops in Long Island. The generous scoops, the wide variety of flavors, and the inclusion of creamy vegan options make it a must-visit for any ice cream lover. I can't wait to return and try more of their delectable creations!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Cold Stone Creamery

Disclaimer: The following review is purely based on my personal opinion and taste preferences.

I must say, my taste buds had a wild party at Cold Stone Creamery in Long Island. With their mind-blowing array of flavors and mix-ins, they turned the simple act of getting ice cream into an epic adventure. Each spoonful was a delightful burst of flavor and texture. The staff was equipped with magical scooping skills and a friendly demeanor, making my experience even more memorable. Whether you're a fan of classic flavors or crave imaginative creations, Cold Stone Creamery has something for everyone's sweet tooth. So, grab your dancing shoes for an ice cream extravaganza at Cold Stone Creamery in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Gelateria Dei Coltelli

Gelateria Dei Coltelli in Long Island is a kaleidoscope of rich and creamy flavors. The moment you step inside, you're transported to gelato heaven. Their pistachio gelato is pure bliss, and the combination of their velvety texture and bold flavors makes Gelateria Dei Coltelli a top contender for the title of the best ice cream in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Itgen's Restaurant & Ice Cream Parlour

With its charming atmosphere and wide array of flavors, Itgen's is a true ice cream aficionado's haven. From classic flavors like Chocolate and Vanilla to innovative creations like Bubblegum Blast, their ice cream concoctions are simply out of this world. Don't miss the chance to indulge in a delicious treat at Itgen's!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar in Long Island is a hidden gem that is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. With a wide variety of unique flavors and homemade cones, this charming spot offers a delightful ice cream experience. Don't miss their signature flavor, the Marshall's Madness – it's sure to leave you craving for more.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Nana's Ice Cream and Coffee House

Nana's Ice Cream and Coffee House in Long Island offers a delightful blend of flavors. Their ice cream is creamy, with a smorgasbord of toppings to choose from. Don't sleep on their specialty coffee - it's a perfect companion to their delectable treats. Nana's is a must-visit for any ice cream enthusiast.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

La Carraia Gelateria Cafe (Italian Ice Cream)

La Carraia Gelateria Cafe (Italian Ice Cream) in Long Island is a delightful gem for ice cream lovers. The heavenly combination of authentic Italian flavors and creamy textures will transport you to the streets of Florence. Try their Cannoli flavor for a sweet and crunchy delight that will surely sweep you off your feet. Don't miss out on this hidden treasure!

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream

Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream in Long Island is an absolute delight. From the moment I stepped inside their charming shop, I could tell this place takes ice cream seriously. With an impressive array of flavors, each scoop was a small taste of heaven. Do yourself a favor and indulge in a cone of Coyle's creamy goodness!

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Ice Cream Social

Ice Cream Social in Long Island is a delicious haven for ice cream lovers. With an array of unique and creative flavors, such as Salted Caramel Pretzel and Honey Lavender, this place is a dream come true. The smooth and creamy texture will definitely leave you craving for more.

Ralph's Famous Italian Ices

Ralph's Famous Italian Ices in Long Island is a delightful and scrumptious treat, perfect for those hot summer days. Their incredible variety of flavors will make your taste buds dance with joy. From classic flavors like lemon and chocolate, to unique creations like cotton candy and rainbow cookie, there's something for everyone. The creamy and smooth texture of their ices is simply divine. The staff is friendly and accommodating, and the prices are reasonable. So, if you're craving a refreshing and delectable treat, make sure to swing by Ralph's Famous Italian Ices in Long Island. You won't be disappointed!