Long Island's Best Italian Food [Updated 2024]

Having grown up on the Island, I have always had a deep appreciation for the rich and authentic flavors that Italian cuisine offers. Over the years, I have had the opportunity to explore numerous Italian restaurants, gathering insight into the unique culinary gems that Long Island has to offer.

In this comprehensive guide, I have meticulously reviewed twelve of the finest Italian establishments, each with their own distinct charm and mouthwatering dishes. From traditional pasta and pizza to heavenly desserts, my aim is to provide you with an insider's perspective on where to indulge in the best Italian food experience on Long Island.

So without further ado, let's dive in and satisfy those taste buds!

Maiella

Highlights
Beautiful decor
Top-notch service
Fresh pasta
Amazing views

Let me start by saying that Maiella exceeded all my expectations by delivering a playful and professional dining experience. As I entered the restaurant, the first thing that caught my eye was the beautiful decor. The modern yet rustic design created a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a memorable meal.

The top-notch service at Maiella was exceptional. The staff was attentive and knowledgeable, assisting us with our selections and making us feel like honored guests. Our glasses were never empty, and our needs were always anticipated.

Now, let's talk about the food. The fresh pasta at Maiella was simply outstanding. Each bite was a joyous explosion of flavors, leaving us yearning for more. From the perfectly cooked al dente texture to the rich and savory sauce, every element was expertly executed.

But what really set Maiella apart was the amazing views. As I sat at my table, I was greeted with breathtaking vistas of Long Island's coastline. It was an enchanting backdrop that elevated the dining experience to new heights.

In conclusion, Maiella is a gem among the sea of Italian restaurants in Long Island. It offers a culinary journey that pleases all the senses and leaves a lasting impression. So, if you're looking for a place that combines stunning views, fresh pasta, and top-notch service, Maiella should definitely be at the top of your list. Bon appétit!

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Brooklyn.

DiMaggio's Trattoria

Highlights
Familiar atmosphere
Fantastic appetizers
Delicious veal piccata
Awesome chicken franches
Best lemon drop cocktail

Upon entering the trattoria, I was warmly greeted by a familiar atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The cozy setting and friendly staff immediately put me at ease, setting the stage for what would be a delightful dining experience.

As an appetizer enthusiast, I couldn't help but be impressed by the selection at DiMaggio's. From the bruschetta bursting with fresh tomatoes and basil to the arancini filled with creamy risotto and gooey mozzarella, every bite was a flavor explosion.

Moving on to the main course, I was torn between trying their veal piccata and the chicken franches. Eventually, I settled on the veal, and boy, was I glad I did. The tender meat was perfectly cooked and bathed in a zesty lemon butter sauce that had just the right amount of tang.

However, it was their chicken franches that stole the show. The succulent chicken breast was breaded to perfection and topped with a velvety white wine and butter sauce that had me licking my lips in sheer delight. The combination of flavors was simply divine and left me craving for more.

To wash down the deliciousness, I indulged in their signature lemon drop cocktail. The tangy citrus taste paired perfectly with the meal, leaving a refreshing sensation with each sip.

Overall, DiMaggio's Trattoria is a hidden gem in Long Island that know how to deliver italian perfection. With their familiar atmosphere, fantastic appetizers, mouthwatering veal piccata, and awesome chicken franches, it's no wonder they made it to the top of my list for the best italian food in Long Island. Definitely a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Osteria Morini Long Island

Highlights
Excellent service
Delicious bread
Fresh pasta
Well thought out dishes
Friendly staff

Osteria Morini Long Island is a delightful establishment that truly demonstrates the art of Italian cuisine. As soon as I walked through the doors, I was greeted by an incredibly friendly staff. The service throughout my visit was nothing short of excellent, making me feel truly pampered as a guest.

Let's start with the bread - delizioso! The freshly baked bread that arrived at my table was warm, soft, and absolutely irresistible. It was the perfect appetizer to whet my appetite for the forthcoming culinary delights.

Next came the pasta, which was made with the freshest ingredients and cooked to perfection. Each forkful was a delightful experience of flavors and textures. From the classic carbonara to the rich and velvety bolognese, every bite transported me to the streets of Italy.

The menu at Osteria Morini Long Island offers a well-thought-out selection of dishes that cater to all tastes. Whether you're a vegetarian or a dedicated carnivore, there is something for everyone. The chefs truly understand how to balance tradition with innovation, resulting in culinary creations that are both comforting and exciting.

What stands out about Osteria Morini Long Island is undoubtedly the friendly and attentive staff. Throughout my meal, they were knowledgeable about the menu, happy to provide recommendations, and genuinely interested in ensuring my dining experience was nothing short of extraordinary.

In conclusion, Osteria Morini Long Island is a charming restaurant that offers some of the best Italian food in Long Island. With its superb service, delicious bread, fresh pasta, and well-thought-out dishes, it is definitely a must-visit for any Italian food enthusiast. Buon appetito!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Manetta's

Manetta's in Long Island is a delightful discovery for any Italian food lover like myself. From the moment you step in, the playful yet professional ambiance sets the tone for an enjoyable dining experience. The menu boasts an array of authentic Italian dishes crafted with precision and expertise. The highlight for me was the truffle-infused pasta that transported my taste buds to culinary paradise. The attentive staff ensured that every need was met, making the whole experience even more memorable. Whether you're indulging in a romantic dinner or celebrating with friends, Manetta's caters to all occasions. It's truly one of the best Italian food destinations in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Levante

I must say, Levante truly elevates the Italian dining scene in Long Island with their mouthwatering dishes. From the decadent homemade pasta to the flavorful pizza, every bite tantalized my taste buds. The cozy yet elegant ambiance adds to the overall charm. A must-visit for all Italian food enthusiasts!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Felice Roslyn

Felice Roslyn in Long Island is a charming Italian eatery that wows with its authentic flavors and cozy atmosphere. From the first bite of their melt-in-your-mouth homemade pasta to the last sip of their perfectly paired wines, Felice Roslyn delivers a culinary journey through Italy. A must-visit for any Italian food enthusiast!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Filomena's

A feast for the senses, Filomena's in Long Island merges rustic charm with authentic Italian flavors. From the savory pasta dishes to the delectable tiramisu, each bite transports you straight to Sicily. Get yourself a reservation ASAP - this hidden gem is a must-try for any Italian cuisine enthusiast!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Uncle Bacala's

Uncle Bacala's in Long Island exceeded all my expectations! From the moment I walked in, the lively ambiance and friendly staff made me feel right at home. The menu was a delightful mix of traditional Italian dishes with a modern twist. The arancini were fried to perfection, and the pasta alla norma was a burst of flavors in every bite. The highlight of the meal was definitely the seafood platter, with succulent lobster, buttery scallops, and tender shrimp. And let's not forget about the decadent tiramisu for dessert! Uncle Bacala's is a true gem that deserves to be on the list of the best Italian food in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Vincent's Clam Bar

I strolled into Vincent's Clam Bar in Long Island, eager to savor the best Italian food. The playful ambiance instantly charmed me, while the professional staff won me over with their welcoming smiles. The fresh clams were a burst of oceanic delight, leaving me clamoring for more. It's a must-visit for seafood aficionados on the hunt for authentic Italian cuisine in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Luigi's Restaurant And Bar

I must say, buonissimo! Luigi's provides an authentic Italian dining experience with their mouthwatering dishes. From the savory pasta dishes to the delicate seafood options, every bite was a delightful explosion of flavors. The cozy ambiance and attentive staff further enhanced the overall experience. Luigi's is definitely a top contender for the best Italian food in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Cafe Baci

Cafe Baci in Long Island is a delicious hidden gem! The moment I stepped in, I was greeted with warm Italian hospitality. The menu boasts a variety of authentic dishes that are bursting with flavor. Don't miss the mouthwatering pasta and be sure to save room for their heavenly tiramisu. Bellissimo!

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Go Nonna

Go Nonna, the standout contender amongst Long Island's Italian food scene, will delight your taste buds like none other. The playful menu is a creative explosion of flavors, and their cozy ambiance sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Do yourself a favor and go indulge in some Nonna-approved goodness.