Long Island's Best Lobster Roll [Updated 2024]

Having grown up on Long Island and spent countless summers indulging in this quintessential coastal delicacy, I have made it my mission to discover the most mouthwatering lobster rolls this island has to offer. After tirelessly researching and reviewing a whopping 12 different establishments, I can confidently say that I have tasted the cream of the crop.

From the perfectly toasted bun to the generous chunks of fresh lobster meat, these lobster rolls are truly a taste of seaside bliss. So get ready to embark on a culinary journey with me as I reveal the absolute best lobster roll in Long Island.

The Rex Burger & Lobster

Highlights
Excellent food
Pleasant staff
Cool atmosphere
Tasteful decor
Delicious lobster

First and foremost, the food at The Rex Burger & Lobster was nothing short of excellent. The lobster roll I had was truly a delightful treat for my taste buds. The succulent lobster was perfectly cooked and lightly coated in just the right amount of mayo, allowing the sweet flavor of the seafood to shine through. The roll itself was soft and buttery, complementing the lobster filling beautifully.

Not only was the food outstanding, but the staff at The Rex Burger & Lobster were also pleasant and attentive. They greeted me warmly upon arrival and provided prompt and friendly service throughout my meal. It was evident that they take pride in their work and genuinely care about providing a top-notch dining experience.

The atmosphere of the restaurant was cool and laid-back, with modern and tasteful decor. The stylish interior created a comfortable and inviting ambiance, adding to the overall enjoyment of the meal. It was evident that attention to detail had been paid to create an aesthetically pleasing environment for patrons to dine in.

All in all, The Rex Burger & Lobster exceeded my expectations and has secured a spot in the competition for the best lobster roll in Long Island. The combination of excellent food, pleasant staff, and a cool atmosphere makes it a definite contender. If you find yourself longing for a delicious lobster roll on Long Island, I highly recommend giving The Rex Burger & Lobster a try. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in NYC.

Psari

Highlights
Outdoor seating
Delicious Broiled Combo
Tender and juicy salmon
Homemade garlic bread
Yummi bread

Walking into Psari, I immediately noticed the charming outdoor seating area - the perfect spot to enjoy a lobster roll on a sunny day. As I perused the menu, my eyes were drawn to the Delicious Broiled Combo, which included a lobster roll, along with other seafood delights.

When the plate arrived, the first thing that caught my attention was the tender and juicy salmon, cooked to perfection. But let's not forget the main attraction! The lobster roll was a sight to behold, piled high with chunks of succulent lobster meat that were clearly freshly caught. The lobster was perfectly seasoned, allowing the natural flavors to shine through.

But what truly elevated this lobster roll experience was the homemade garlic bread. The bread was soft and fluffy on the inside, with a subtle garlic flavor that didn't overpower the delicate taste of the lobster. Each bite was a delight, with a perfect balance of textures and flavors.

To accompany my meal, I couldn't resist trying their Yummi bread, which had been recommended by the friendly staff. This warm, pillowy bread was the ideal way to mop up every last bit of lobster goodness.

The overall experience at Psari was delightful. The outdoor seating area provided a lovely atmosphere, the seafood was fresh and delicious, and the attention to detail - from the tender salmon to the homemade garlic bread - was impeccable. Whether you're a seafood lover or simply seeking the ultimate lobster roll in Long Island, Psari is certainly a place worth visiting.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Manhattan.

Nicky's Clam Bar

Highlights
Delicious seafood
Fresh ingredients
Outdoor seating

Let me start by saying that Nicky's Clam Bar is a little gem that truly understands the art of crafting a delectable lobster roll. As I sat at one of their outdoor tables, I felt a sense of anticipation that only an authentic seafood experience can deliver.

The lobster roll at Nicky's is a masterpiece. The delicious seafood is piled high on a perfectly toasted bun, showcasing their commitment to quality and flavor. The fresh ingredients shine through in every bite, with succulent lobster meat that practically melts in your mouth.

What truly sets Nicky's Clam Bar apart is its playful yet professional approach to its dishes. Each lobster roll is packed with generous portions of lobster meat, lightly dressed in a creamy, tangy sauce that doesn't overpower the natural sweetness of the seafood. The combination of flavors is sublime, leaving you wanting more with every bite.

As I enjoyed my lobster roll, I couldn't help but appreciate the atmosphere at Nicky's Clam Bar. The outdoor seating adds to the experience, allowing you to savor the flavors while enjoying the fresh Long Island air.

If you're on the hunt for the best lobster roll in Long Island, look no further than Nicky's Clam Bar. Its combination of delicious seafood, fresh ingredients, and charming outdoor seating is a winning recipe that will leave your taste buds craving more. Make sure to add it to your must-visit list, and prepare yourself for a lobster roll experience unlike any other.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Smuggler Jack's

I must say, Smuggler Jack's lobster roll left me delighted. The succulent chunks of lobster meat were dressed in a light and creamy mayo, elevating the flavor to a whole new level. The buttery toasted bun added the perfect amount of crunch to each bite. Smuggler Jack's lobster roll truly deserves its spot as a top contender in the Long Island lobster roll scene. Don't miss out on this indulgent treat!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Harbor Crab Co

Harbor Crab Co in Long Island blew me away with their heavenly lobster roll. Bursting with succulent chunks of lobster, nestled in a pillowy roll, and perfectly dressed in just the right amount of mayo. The combination of flavors and textures had me doing a happy lobster dance. Definitely a top contender for the best lobster roll in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Jordan Lobster Farms

Jordan Lobster Farms in Long Island is a hidden gem for lobster roll enthusiasts. The perfectly toasted bun and generous portion of succulent lobster meat left me speechless. The juicy and flavorful lobster was practically dancing on my taste buds. Don't miss this seriously delightful lobster roll experience!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Peter's Clam Bar

Located in the heart of Long Island, Peter's Clam Bar is a hidden gem for lobster roll enthusiasts like myself. From the moment I walked in, the lively atmosphere and mouth-watering aroma captured my attention. The lobster roll at Peter's is an absolute delight; the succulent chunks of lobster meat are generously piled onto a perfectly toasted, buttery roll. Each bite delivers a burst of rich seafood flavor, making it a truly heavenly experience. The accompanying crispy fries and tangy coleslaw complemented the roll perfectly. The service was impeccable as the staff was friendly and provided prompt and attentive service. Overall, Peter's Clam Bar is a must-visit for anyone craving the best lobster roll in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Bigelow's New England Fried Clams

Bigelow's New England Fried Clams in Long Island is the go-to spot for seafood lovers. While I was on my quest for the best lobster roll, I couldn't resist trying their famous fried clams. The crispy coating and tender clams were perfectly paired with a side of tangy tartar sauce. A delightful appetizer to begin my lobster roll adventure.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

DJ's Clam Shack Wantagh

DJ's Clam Shack Wantagh in Long Island is a hidden gem for lobster roll fanatics like me. The moment I took my first bite of their delectable creation, I knew I had found the holy grail of lobster rolls. The succulent lobster meat was perfectly complemented by the buttery and toasted roll. This place is a must-visit for any seafood lover in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Point Lookout Clam Bar

Point Lookout Clam Bar in Long Island is a lobster lover's dream come true. The lobster roll here is a delectable masterpiece of juicy, succulent lobster meat nestled in a buttery, toasted roll. The flavor combination is pure perfection, with the lobster stealing the show with its fresh, sweet taste. The serving size is generous, making it worth every penny. If you're searching for the best lobster roll in Long Island, look no further than Point Lookout Clam Bar. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Louie's Prime Steak & Seafood

I decided to try Louie's Prime Steak & Seafood in Long Island for their renowned lobster roll. My taste buds were dancing with joy as I savored every mouthwatering bite. The lobster was succulent and tender, perfectly complemented by the buttery toasted bun. This lobster roll was a dream in edible form!

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Red Lobster

Okay, here is the review:

As an experienced lobster roll connoisseur, I boldly ventured into Red Lobster, nestled in the heart of Long Island. With anticipation in my taste buds, I eagerly ordered their famous lobster roll. However, my quest for the best lobster roll hit a roadblock as the roll lacked the wow factor I was hoping for. While the lobster was undeniably fresh, the roll itself was a bit underwhelming, lacking the craving-inducing taste I was searching for. Nonetheless, Red Lobster deserves credit for its friendly service and cozy atmosphere. But alas, my search for the ultimate lobster roll continues.

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.