Best Lobster Roll in Manhattan: Complete Guide (2025)

After tasting my way through 13 top spots in the city, I can confidently say that the quest for the perfect lobster roll is as thrilling as it is delicious. Each bite tells a story, whether it’s the sweet, succulent lobster meat or the buttery, toasted bun that cradles it all together.

Having spent countless hours indulging in these seaside treasures, I’ve honed my palate to know what truly makes a lobster roll shine. Trust me—my criteria are rigorous, so you can bet I’m bringing you only the best of the best. Get ready to dive into a culinary adventure that will have your taste buds dancing with delight!

Red Hook Lobster Pound

Highlights
Fresh lobster
Tasty lobster
Good service
Delicious food
Nice drink selection

Upon entering the restaurant, I immediately noticed the fresh aroma of seafood. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, with a nautical theme that made me feel like I was stepping into a dockside eatery.

The star of the show, of course, was the lobster roll. Let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The lobster meat was succulent and flavorful, providing a taste of the ocean in every bite. It was clear that they used only the freshest and highest-quality lobster.

The tasty lobster was complemented perfectly by the warm, buttery roll that held it all together. It was soft yet sturdy, allowing the lobster to shine without overpowering it. Each mouthful was a heavenly blend of textures and flavors.

What impressed me further was the service. The staff was knowledgeable, attentive, and genuinely passionate about their food. They were more than happy to answer any questions I had and even made suggestions on drink pairings.

Speaking of drinks, Red Hook Lobster Pound had a range of options to choose from. Whether you prefer a crisp white wine, a zesty craft beer, or a classic Maine soda, they had something to satisfy every palate.

In conclusion, my visit to Red Hook Lobster Pound in Manhattan was an absolute delight. From the fresh and tasty lobster to the friendly service and delicious drink selection, it's easy to see why this establishment has earned a spot on the list of the best lobster rolls in Manhattan. Don't miss out on this hidden gem!

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in NYC.

The Clam

Highlights
Amazing rolls
Best burger
Fresh oysters
Huge portions
Excellent cuisine

Let me start by saying, wow! The lobster roll at The Clam is nothing short of extraordinary. From the moment it was placed in front of me, I knew I was in for a treat.

The roll itself was perfection. The bread, slightly toasted, was a buttery delight, providing a perfect vessel for the amazing chunks of fresh lobster. Each bite was a balance between tender, succulent lobster meat and the delicate flavors of the accompanying herbs and spices. This lobster roll was a work of art.

But The Clam doesn't stop at just lobster rolls. The menu boasts an array of culinary delights. From their best burger in town to the wide selection of fresh oysters, there is something to please every palate.

One thing that truly stood out was the portion size. When they say "Huge portions," they mean it. You definitely won't leave this place hungry. It's like they know the golden rule of satisfying their customers: never hold back on deliciousness.

Not only were the rolls incredible, but the overall dining experience at The Clam was fantastic. The ambiance was cozy and chic, and the staff provided excellent service throughout my visit.

If you're on the hunt for the best lobster roll in Manhattan, look no further than The Clam. With their excellent cuisine and commitment to delivering top-notch dishes, they have truly earned their spot on my list of the finest lobster roll establishments in the city. Don't miss out on this seafood delight!

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Long Island.

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side

Highlights
Fresh lobster
Trio option
Spicy honey butter roll
Friendly staff
Recommended visit

Walking into Luke's Lobster Upper East Side, I was immediately captivated by the enticing aroma of fresh lobster that filled the air. It was a promising start to my quest to find the best lobster roll in Manhattan.

As I perused the menu, I was delighted to discover that Luke's Lobster offers a unique trio option. This allowed me to savor not just one, but three delectable rolls in a single visit. It was like a seafood lover's dream come true.

Of all the rolls I tried, the standout was undeniably the spicy honey butter roll. The combination of heat from the spices, the sweetness of the honey, and the richness of the butter created a delightful explosion of flavors that danced on my palate. It was pure culinary bliss.

What truly elevated my experience was the friendly staff at Luke's Lobster. They were knowledgeable, attentive, and passionate about their craft. Their genuine enthusiasm was infectious, and it made me feel instantly welcomed and valued as a customer.

After my visit, I can confidently say that Luke's Lobster Upper East Side is a recommended spot for anyone in search of an exceptional lobster roll in Manhattan. With their commitment to sourcing the freshest ingredients, creative flavor combinations, and warm hospitality, Luke's Lobster has undoubtedly earned its place among the top contenders in the race for the best lobster roll in Manhattan.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Ed's Lobster Bar

Ed's Lobster Bar in Manhattan is a hidden gem for lobster roll fanatics like myself. The moment I took a bite of their buttery and succulent lobster meat tucked inside a perfectly toasted bun, I knew I struck gold. With impeccable service and a laid-back atmosphere, Ed's Lobster Bar is a must-visit for any lobster lover in Manhattan.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Lobster Place

Lobster Place in Manhattan is a lobster lover's paradise. With fresh and succulent lobster meat, their lobster roll is a flavor explosion. The perfectly toasted bun and generous portion of lobster make it a standout option. Definitely a must-try for any lobster aficionado.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Luke's Lobster Upper West Side

Luke's Lobster Upper West Side is an absolute delight for lobster roll enthusiasts like myself. The succulent chunks of fresh lobster are generously packed into a warm, buttery roll, creating a taste explosion in every bite. The flawless execution and unforgettable flavor make this a must-try for any seafood lover in Manhattan.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Luke's Lobster FiDi

Luke's Lobster FiDi in Manhattan is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. Fresh, succulent chunks of lobster, lightly seasoned and served on a toasted buttery bun, make for one heavenly delight. With a crunchy pickle on the side, this lobster roll is pure crustacean perfection!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Luke's Lobster Midtown East

Luke's Lobster Midtown East in Manhattan is a delightful hidden gem, serving up a tantalizing lobster roll that is simply perfection. The succulent pieces of lobster are overflowing from the buttery roll, creating a mouthwatering feast. The freshness of the seafood coupled with the perfectly seasoned mayo creates a flavor explosion in every bite. Don't miss out on this culinary delight.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Luke's Lobster Union Square

Luke's Lobster Union Square was a delightful surprise on my lobster roll journey! The succulent lobster, toasty buttered bun, and mouthwatering secret seasoning created a flavor explosion in every bite. The generous portion and affordable price make this a must-visit spot for lobster roll lovers in Manhattan.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Luke's Lobster Garment District

Luke's Lobster Garment District in Manhattan was an absolute delight! The buttery and succulent lobster meat perfectly nestled in a toasted roll was a taste sensation. The generous portion of lobster was impressive, and the classic seasoning allowed the freshness of the lobster to shine. Truly a must-visit spot for lobster roll enthusiasts.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Luke's Lobster Grand Central

Luke's Lobster Grand Central in Manhattan is a hidden gem when it comes to lobster rolls. The combination of succulent lobster meat, buttery bread, and a squeeze of lemon creates a flavor explosion in every bite. The ambiance is cozy, perfect for a quick lunch escape. Trust me, this is a lobster roll you don't want to miss.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Cull & Pistol

Cull & Pistol in Manhattan certainly makes a splash with their lobster roll. The creamy and succulent lobster is nestled in a toasted buttery bun that is simply divine. This place definitely deserves a spot on the list of the best lobster rolls in Manhattan.

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Lobster Joint

During my visit to Lobster Joint, I was instantly charmed by its casual yet vibrant vibe. The lobster roll was a sight to behold: packed generously with tender, sweet lobster meat, it was bathed in a velvety, secret sauce that danced on my palate. Served in a perfectly toasted bun, each bite was a delightful surprise of buttery goodness. The accompanying fries were crisp and addictive! If you're on the hunt for an exceptional lobster roll, Lobster Joint delivers not just a dish but a joyful experience that’s hard to forget. Don’t miss out on this coastal treasure in the heart of Manhattan!

You might also want to check out the best hot chocolate in NYC.