The Absolute Best Seafood Restaurants in Harlem [Updated 2025]

Each bite tells a story, and trust me, I’ve savored plenty of them! After diving deep into the vibrant culinary landscape of Harlem, I’ve reviewed 12 standout seafood spots that truly capture the essence of this neighborhood. From cozy eateries that feel like home to upscale dining experiences that celebrate the bounty of the sea, there’s something here for everyone.

You can trust my insights because I’ve not only tasted the dishes but also soaked in the atmosphere, chatting with chefs and locals alike. So whether you’re a seafood aficionado or just looking to explore, let’s embark on this delicious journey together. You won’t want to miss these hidden gems!

A Taste of Seafood

Highlights
Fast and friendly service
Tasty fish special
Cozy lunch spot
Inconsistent food quality
Limited seasoning

During my recent culinary adventure at A Taste of Seafood, I was in for a treat with their fast and friendly service. The moment I stepped inside, the cozy atmosphere welcomed me, making it an ideal lunch spot for seafood lovers. I decided to try their fish special, and let me tell you, it was a delightful explosion of flavor.

However, as with many gems, there were a few gems in the rough. While the fish was beautifully cooked, I couldn’t help but notice a touch of inconsistent food quality in some other dishes at the table. The limited seasoning on some items left my taste buds longing for a bit more zest. But hey, what’s a little room for improvement in a charming spot so committed to serving the community?

If you're in the mood for a relaxed atmosphere and a tasty meal, A Taste of Seafood is certainly worth a visit. Despite minor slip-ups, their seafood definitely leaves a lasting impression, making it a worthwhile stop on your Harlem seafood tour!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Queens.

Make My Fish

Highlights
Catfish cooked to perfection
Friendly and inviting staff
Fast food service
Delicious sides available
Long lines prove quality

Make My Fish in Harlem is a seafood gem that deserves a spot on your must-try list! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a warm and friendly staff that made me feel right at home—it's like being welcomed into a family seafood feast. The catfish here? Simply cooked to perfection! Crispy on the outside, yet tender and flavorful within, it was a delight that practically melted in my mouth.

The ambiance is casual and inviting, perfect for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner. Speaking of quick, the service is fast, which is great when you’re eager to satisfy your seafood cravings. I also indulged in their delicious sides, which complemented my meal beautifully and elevated the dining experience.

While the lines can be long, it's a testament to the quality and popularity of the food. Trust me, you're in for a treat once you finally place your order. Make My Fish is not just a meal; it's a flavorful celebration of seafood that will keep you coming back for more. If you’re seeking soulful seafood in Harlem, this stop is a must!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Long Island.

Lighthouse Fish Market

Highlights
Attentive and friendly staff
Seasoned and delicious fish
Generous portion sizes
Reasonable pricing
Great music playlist

Lighthouse Fish Market Review

Stepping into Lighthouse Fish Market felt like stumbling upon a hidden gem in the bustling heart of Harlem. The moment I entered, I was greeted by an attentive and friendly staff that immediately set the tone for a delightful dining experience. The vibe here is infused with a lively atmosphere, complemented by a great music playlist that makes you want to tap your feet while you wait for your food.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show—the fish! Each dish is seasoned to perfection, showcasing the quality of their seafood without overshadowing its inherent flavors. I was particularly impressed by the generous portion sizes; you definitely get your money's worth. Speaking of prices, I found them quite reasonable for the quality offered, making it a go-to spot for seafood lovers.

Every bite felt like a celebration of the ocean! If you're in the neighborhood, Lighthouse Fish Market is not just a meal; it’s an experience that’s both satisfying and memorable. Don’t miss out on this vibrant celebration of seafood—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best asian restaurants in Queens.

Sea To Soul Harlem

I had the pleasure of diving into the vibrant flavors at Sea To Soul Harlem. This gem is a delightful fusion of comfort and excitement. Their signature shrimp and grits instantly won me over, with a creamy, dreamy texture that harmonized perfectly with a zesty kick. The curried crab cakes are a joyful explosion of spice that dances on the palate. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make you feel right at home. Whether you're a seafood aficionado or just curious, Sea To Soul offers a heartfelt experience that captures the essence of Harlem. Don't miss this culinary treasure!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Manhattan.

The Shell Seafood Kitchen & Bar

At The Shell Seafood Kitchen & Bar, I was immediately captivated by the inviting atmosphere and ocean-inspired decor. The menu is a delightful treasure hunt for seafood lovers! I indulged in the mouthwatering lobster roll that was bursting with flavor—perfectly buttery and stuffed to the brim. The fresh oysters were equally impressive; each one was like a little oceanic adventure. What really sets this gem apart is its playful cocktails, which complement the dishes beautifully. If you're seeking a spot with both casual charm and delectable seafood, The Shell is definitely a must-visit in Harlem!

You might also want to check out the best takeout restaurants in Brooklyn.

Sea & Sea Fish Market Steamed Seafood

Nestled amid the vibrant streets of Harlem, Sea & Sea Fish Market Steamed Seafood is a hidden gem that showcases the ocean's bounty. The steamers here serve up a delightful array of fresh catch, with the crab legs stealing the spotlight—plump, juicy, and bursting with flavor. The casual yet inviting atmosphere makes it perfect for a quick meal or a leisurely feast. Don’t skip the signature garlic butter sauce—it’s an absolute game-changer! With impeccable service and an undeniable charm, this spot is a must-visit for seafood lovers in Harlem. Prepare to have your taste buds tantalized!

You might also want to check out the best family restaurants in NYC.

Famous Fish Market

Stepping into Famous Fish Market truly feels like a celebration of the ocean's bounty! The vibrant atmosphere welcomes you as the irresistible aroma of fresh seafood dances in the air. I indulged in their signature fish fry, and each bite was a delightful crunch that revealed tender, flaky goodness within. The staff exudes an energetic charm, eager to help you navigate their extensive menu. Don’t miss their mouth-watering shrimp tacos! Whether you're dining in or taking out, this gem is bound to hook you with flavor and authenticity. A definite must-visit for seafood lovers in Harlem!

You might also want to check out the best thai restaurants in NYC.

Cap't Loui Broadway

Cap't Loui Broadway is a delightful gem that brings the vibrant essence of New Orleans right to Harlem! The moment I stepped in, the lively atmosphere enveloped me, and I was immediately drawn to the mouthwatering aroma of seafood. I dove into their signature seafood boil, and it was an explosion of flavors - perfectly seasoned shrimp, crab, and crawfish, served with a side of buttery corn and potatoes. Every bite was a celebration! The friendly staff and engaging ambiance truly made my visit memorable. If you crave a taste of the bayou in the heart of Harlem, Cap't Loui is the place to be!

You might also want to check out the best vegan restaurants in Brooklyn.

Eso Pesco

Eso Pesco in Harlem is a hidden gem that serves up delicious seafood with a dash of flair. From the moment I walked in, the vibrant atmosphere enveloped me, setting the stage for a memorable meal. The attentive staff guided me through their fresh daily catches, and I ultimately indulged in the grilled octopus—tender, flavorful, and perfectly charred. The creamy seafood risotto was another highlight, bursting with rich flavors and generous portions. If you're craving a seafood extravaganza, Eso Pesco is a must-visit, redefining Harlem's seafood scene with its unique menu and inviting charm.

You might also want to check out the best new restaurants in Brooklyn.

Harlem Seafood Soul

Stepping into Harlem Seafood Soul feels like a warm hug from the neighborhood. The vibrant atmosphere is matched by the tantalizing aroma of freshly prepared dishes. I indulged in their succulent fried catfish, perfectly seasoned and crispy, alongside buttery grits that danced on my palate. The sides, especially the collard greens, added a delightful soul food twist that complemented the seafood beautifully. The friendly staff made me feel right at home, enhancing the entire experience. For anyone craving a heartfelt seafood meal, this spot is a must-visit! The blend of flavors and warmth is truly unforgettable.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Queens.

Harlem House of Seafood

On my recent culinary adventure, I had the pleasure of dining at the Harlem House of Seafood. This cozy gem serves up a delightful array of seafood that dances on your palate. I savored their blackened catfish, perfectly seasoned and cooked to flaky perfection. The shrimp and grits were a creamy, spicy masterpiece, transporting me straight to the South. The warm ambiance and friendly staff added to the experience, making me feel right at home. If you're hunting for fresh, flavorful seafood in Harlem, don't miss out on this charming spot—it's truly a catch!

You might also want to check out the best rooftop restaurant in NYC.

Sugar Hill Fish Place

Nestled in the heart of Sugar Hill, Sugar Hill Fish Place is a gem that dazzled my taste buds. The moment I stepped in, the aromatic scent of fresh seafood enveloped me. Their fried whiting is simply divine; crispy on the outside and flaky within. I also couldn’t resist the zingy shrimp po'boy, which was a delightful fusion of flavors. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff made me feel right at home. If you're hunting for a spot that combines quality with a dash of Harlem charm, look no further. This seafood haven is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Manhattan.