Long Island's Best Seafood Restaurants [Updated 2024]

After reviewing twelve seafood restaurants on Long Island, I can confidently say that these establishments offer an exceptional dining experience. With my love for seafood and my deep knowledge of the local culinary scene, I have curated a list of the top spots for seafood enthusiasts.

Whether you prefer classic dishes like lobster rolls or you're looking to venture into more adventurous flavors, this article has got you covered. From quaint coastal shacks to upscale waterfront eateries, Long Island offers a diverse array of seafood dining options.

Prepare to indulge in the freshest catches and savor the flavors of the sea.

Psari

Highlights
Outdoor seating
Delicious broiled combo
Tender and juicy salmon
Homemade garlic bread
Yummy bread and appetizers

Upon arriving at Psari, I was delighted to discover that they had outdoor seating available. There's something so satisfying about enjoying a seafood meal while embracing the fresh air and sunshine.

As I perused the menu, my eyes were immediately drawn to the broiled combo. The combination of lobster, shrimp, and scallops was a seafood lover's dream. I eagerly anticipated the arrival of my dish, and when it finally arrived, I was blown away. Each piece of seafood was cooked to perfection, with a deliciously golden brown crust that added a delightful crunch.

The salmon, too, was incredibly tender and juicy. It practically melted in my mouth with every bite. It was clear that Psari truly knows how to prepare seafood with precision and care.

What surprised me even more was the homemade garlic bread that accompanied my meal. The warm and fragrant bread was perfectly toasted, with just the right amount of garlic and butter. It was an unexpected delight that elevated the entire dining experience.

To start my meal, I couldn't resist ordering some of Psari's bread and appetizers. And boy, am I glad I did. The bread was soft and warm, and the appetizers were nothing short of delicious.

Overall, my visit to Psari was a true seafood extravaganza. From outdoor seating to a delicious broiled combo, and even the homemade garlic bread, Psari definitely deserves a spot on the list of the best seafood restaurants in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Queens.

Mill Pond House

Highlights
Excellent food
Beautiful view
Friendly service
Perfectly grilled steak
Carefully crafted dishes

From the moment I walked into Mill Pond House, I knew I was in for a delightful seafood experience. The first thing that caught my attention was the stunning view of the pond, which served as a tranquil backdrop to my dining experience.

As a seafood enthusiast, I always look for restaurants that can deliver excellent food. Mill Pond House did not disappoint. The menu was filled with a variety of carefully crafted seafood dishes that tempted my taste buds. From the moment I took my first bite, I knew I was in for a treat.

The service at Mill Pond House was another highlight of my visit. The staff was friendly and accommodating, making me feel welcome and taken care of. They provided expert recommendations and were attentive without being intrusive, allowing me to fully enjoy my dining experience.

Although seafood is their specialty, I was pleasantly surprised to find that Mill Pond House also offered a perfectly grilled steak. It was cooked to perfection and paired wonderfully with their seafood dishes. Mill Pond House truly knows how to cater to all palates.

Overall, my visit to Mill Pond House was a true delight. The combination of excellent food, the beautiful view, and the friendly service made for an unforgettable experience. Whether you're a seafood enthusiast or simply looking for a memorable dining experience, I highly recommend giving Mill Pond House a try.

You might also want to check out the best asian restaurants in Queens.

LIMANI

Highlights
Elegant decor
Attentive staff
Exceptional food
Plenty of seating
Delicious desserts

From the moment I stepped into LIMANI, I was enchanted by its elegant decor. The beautifully designed interior created an atmosphere that felt both sophisticated and relaxed. The attentive staff greeted me warmly and guided me to my table, ensuring that I felt welcomed and comfortable.

The highlight of my visit to LIMANI was undoubtedly the exceptional food. The menu was a seafood lover's dream come true, with a wide variety of options to choose from. From the freshest oysters to succulent lobster tails, every dish was prepared with precision and care. The flavors were robust and delightful, leaving me longing for more with every bite.

One of the things that stood out to me was the ample seating available at LIMANI. Finding a restaurant with enough space can often be a challenge, but this was not an issue here. Whether you prefer a quiet corner or a lively spot near the bar, LIMANI had plenty of seating options available.

And let's not forget about the desserts! The sweet finale of my meal was simply divine. From the rich chocolate cake to the tangy lemon tart, each dessert was a delectable masterpiece that provided the perfect ending to an already remarkable dining experience.

In summary, LIMANI exceeded my expectations with its elegant decor, attentive staff, exceptional food, ample seating, and mouthwatering desserts. If you're looking for the best in seafood dining in Long Island, LIMANI should definitely be at the top of your list.

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Manhattan.

Ayhan's Lobster and Fish House

Ayhan's Lobster and Fish House in Long Island deserves every bit of praise it receives. The playful ambiance, professional service, and delicious seafood make it a top contender for the best seafood restaurant in the area. Don't miss out on their succulent lobster and flavorful fish dishes - they're an absolute must-try!

You might also want to check out the best family restaurants in NYC.

Louie's Prime Steak & Seafood

As an expert reviewer of seafood restaurants, I recently had the pleasure of dining at Louie's Prime Steak & Seafood in Long Island. Let me tell you, this place is a hidden gem when it comes to seafood! From the moment I walked in, I was hooked. The elegant atmosphere and friendly staff set the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Now, let's talk about the food. Wow. The seafood selections at Louie's are nothing short of exceptional. From succulent lobster tails to perfectly seared scallops, each dish was a true delight. The flavors were fresh, vibrant, and packed a punch that would make any seafood lover's taste buds dance with joy. And let's not forget about the presentation – each plate was a work of culinary art. Whether you're a seafood connoisseur or just looking for a delicious meal, Louie's Prime Steak & Seafood is a must-visit destination in Long Island. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best thai restaurants in NYC.

Bigelow's New England Fried Clams

I can confidently say that Bigelow's New England Fried Clams in Long Island is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. The crispy clams were perfection and the seasoning was spot on. The staff was friendly and the atmosphere was charming. Don't miss out on this delightful seafood spot in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best new restaurants in Brooklyn.

Anchor Down

Anchor Down in Long Island was a gastronomic voyage through the ocean. The playful yet professional ambiance perfectly complemented their exquisite seafood menu. From the succulent lobster to the delicate oysters, each dish was a masterpiece. With its waterfront view and sensational flavors, Anchor Down is truly a seafood paradise.

You might also want to check out the best rooftop restaurant in NYC.

Popei's Clam Bar

Let me start by saying, wow! Popei's Clam Bar is a seafood lover's paradise. The atmosphere is laid-back and inviting, and the food is absolutely delicious. The menu is packed with mouth-watering options like juicy lobster rolls, perfectly cooked fish and chips, and of course, their famous clams. The seafood is always fresh and the portions are generous. Whether you're dining with a group or enjoying a solo seafood feast, Popei's Clam Bar is a must-visit in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Manhattan.

The Monster Crab all you can eat seafood & Bar

The Monster Crab all you can eat seafood & Bar in Long Island is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. With its playful atmosphere and wide selection of delectable seafood options, this place is a must-visit. From succulent shrimp to fresh oysters, every bite transports you to seafood paradise. Don't miss out on their mouthwatering lobster rolls - they're simply divine. With its generous portions and friendly service, The Monster Crab is truly a seafood lover's haven!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Long Island City.

Harbor Mist Restaurant

Harbor Mist Restaurant in Long Island is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. From the moment you step through the door, you're whisked away by the superb service and exquisite ocean-inspired decor. The menu boasts an array of fresh and flavorful seafood dishes that will leave you longing for more. Don't miss their famous succulent lobster roll - it's a taste of heaven!

You might also want to check out the best halal restaurants in Queens.

Sea Bar

Sea Bar in Long Island is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. With its chic atmosphere and innovative menu, this place truly wow-ed my taste buds. The freshness of the seafood was outstanding, and the staff was incredibly knowledgeable. Don't miss out on trying their signature lobster roll – it's to die for!

You might also want to check out the best halal restaurants in Brooklyn.

Peter's Clam Bar

Peter's Clam Bar in Long Island is a hidden treasure for seafood lovers! The playful nautical decor adds to the experience. The clam chowder was rich and creamy, and the crispy calamari was out of this world. Don't forget to try their famous lobster rolls - they're divine!

You might also want to check out the best halal restaurants in Long Island.