NYC's Best Lobster [Updated 2025]

There’s something magical about biting into a perfectly cooked lobster—sweet, tender meat that practically dances on your taste buds. Over the last few weeks, I’ve ventured from bustling markets to cozy corners of the city, reviewing 12 top spots that claim to serve the ultimate lobster dish.

With years spent diving deep into New York’s culinary scene, I’ve developed a discerning palate and a knack for uncovering those hidden treasures that often go unnoticed. Whether you’re a lifelong seafood lover or a curious newcomer, I promise you’ll find a lobster experience here that’s worth every delicious bite. Let’s dive into the best of the best!

Lobster Place

At Lobster Place, the aroma of the ocean greets you as you step inside this bustling seafood market. The sweet aroma of fresh lobster fills the air, drawing you towards their vibrant counter. I indulged in the Maine Lobster Roll, which was an exquisite delight—succulent meat nestled in a buttery roll, balanced by a hint of chive. Each bite was a playful dance of flavors, with the freshness shining through. The cozy atmosphere and knowledgeable staff enhance the experience, making it an ideal spot for any lobster lover. Lobster Place has certainly earned its spot among the best in NYC!

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in NYC.

City Island Lobster House

Nestled in the charming enclave of City Island, City Island Lobster House is a seafood lover's paradise! As I stepped inside, the nautical decor set the perfect mood for my lobster feast. The succulent lobster roll, bursting with fresh meat and a hint of lemon, was a delight. Paired with crispy fries, it was pure bliss. The lobster bisque was another highlight—rich and velvety, a true comfort in a bowl. The vibrant atmosphere and friendly service completed my experience. If you’re in search of top-notch lobster in NYC, City Island Lobster House is a must-visit gem!

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Long Island.

Cull & Pistol

At Cull & Pistol, I was greeted with an inviting ambiance that perfectly complements their commitment to seafood excellence. The lobster roll I indulged in was a delightful treasure, boasting chunks of succulent meat nestled in a buttery, lightly toasted bun. Each bite was bursting with flavor, making it a true stand-out. Their lobster bisque, rich and creamy, offered a velvety embrace that I can't forget. With a knowledgeable staff to guide your selections, this spot shines as a must-visit for lobster aficionados. Cull & Pistol truly lives up to its reputation, delivering an unforgettable experience that keeps you coming back for more!

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Manhattan.

Luke's Lobster West Village

Tucked away in the charming West Village, Luke's Lobster is a quintessential seafood haven that delivers an exceptional taste of the ocean. Stepping inside, I was greeted by the cozy atmosphere filled with warm smiles. The lobster roll stole the show—a generous portion of tender, sweet lobster drizzled with just the right amount of melted butter and a sprinkle of lemon. Each bite felt like a coastal escape. For an authentic experience, pair it with their potato chips and a classic cream soda. If you’re looking for the best lobster in NYC, Luke's is truly a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best lobster in Long Island.

Crab House NYC

During my visit to Crab House NYC, I was immediately enchanted by the vibrant, nautical décor that sets the mood for a delightful seafood adventure. The lobster rolls here are truly a standout—succulent chunks of lobster meat, lightly dressed and nestled in a perfectly toasted bun. Each bite was a joyous explosion of flavor, reminiscent of coastal bliss. The sides, particularly the garlic butter corn, complemented the meal beautifully. Coupled with a cheerful staff, this spot offers an inviting atmosphere that’s hard to resist. If you’re craving lobster, don’t skip this gem in the heart of the city!

You might also want to check out the best lobster in Brooklyn.

Sea Fire Grill

Nestled in the heart of Manhattan, Sea Fire Grill is a haven for lobster lovers. Their Maine Lobster, served with decadent drawn butter, was a feast for the senses, perfectly seasoned with just a hint of citrus. The ambiance is elegant yet inviting, making it a great spot for both special occasions and casual dining. I adored the lobster bisque, rich and velvety, with chunks of succulent lobster that left me craving more. The attentive service only sweetened the experience, ensuring every bite was memorable. If you seek impeccable lobster in NYC, don’t miss this gem!

You might also want to check out the best lobster in Manhattan.

Red Hook Lobster Pound

At Red Hook Lobster Pound, I indulged in a delightful lobster roll that was nothing short of a seafood masterpiece. The succulent lobster—freshly caught and generously piled—was perfectly complemented by a hint of lemon and a touch of mayonnaise. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, blending the sweetness of the meat with a satisfying crunch from the roll. The casual, vibrant atmosphere made the experience even more enjoyable. If you're hunting for an authentic lobster experience in NYC, this spot is an absolute must-visit. Fast, flavorful, and fun—Red Hook has earned its place on my culinary map!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Queens.

The Shell Seafood Kitchen & Bar

At The Shell Seafood Kitchen & Bar, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of the ocean, setting the stage for a lobster-inspired feast. The lobster roll, bursting with succulent meat and kissed by a hint of lemon, stole the show. Served in a buttery brioche bun, it was perfection in every bite. The lobster bisque was equally divine, creamy and rich with a velvety finish that left me craving more. The inviting atmosphere and attentive staff made my visit truly memorable. If you're seeking NYC’s lobster nirvana, look no further than this gem! 🦞✨

You might also want to check out the best seafood tower in NYC.

Luke's Lobster FiDi

My trip to Luke's Lobster FiDi left my taste buds dancing with joy! The charming nautical vibe immediately set the mood, inviting me to indulge in their signature rolls. With chunks of succulent lobster nestled in buttery bread, each bite was a heavenly morsel. The quality was unquestionable, featuring fresh, sustainable seafood that left a positive impact. Don't miss their lobster bisque—creamy and rich, it's the perfect complement to the rolls. Overall, Luke’s is a delightful spot for lobster lovers looking for a casual yet memorable dining experience in the bustling heart of Financial District!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Manhattan.

Ocean Prime

At Ocean Prime, the lobster tail is truly a showstopper! This gem of a dish boasts a perfectly charred exterior paired with a succulent, buttery interior that practically dances on your palate. The ambiance is upscale yet inviting, making it ideal for a romantic dinner or a chic night out. Served with a delightful lemon-garlic butter sauce, it elevates the dish to new heights. The attentive staff and extensive wine list provide the perfect complement to your meal. If you're seeking the quintessential lobster experience in NYC, Ocean Prime is undeniably a top contender worth savoring.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Long Island.

Burger & Lobster Bryant Park

At Burger & Lobster Bryant Park, the fusion of flavors and atmosphere was simply captivating. Their signature lobster roll, bursting with succulent lobster meat, was a delight, dressed lightly with just the right hint of lemon and butter. The meat practically danced on my palate! Complementing the experience, the cozy yet vibrant ambiance made my visit extra special. And let’s not forget their crispy, golden fries—perfectly seasoned and irresistible! If you're on the quest for top-notch lobster in NYC, this spot is a must-visit. Indulge yourself, and your taste buds will thank you! 🦞✨

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurant in Brooklyn.

Oceans

I recently indulged in a lobster feast at Oceans in NYC, and let me tell you, it was nothing short of spectacular! The lobster roll was a symphony of flavors, featuring generous chunks of succulent lobster basking in a light, zesty mayo. The buttery, toasted bun was the perfect complement, adding a crunch that brought the dish to life. The ambiance was vibrant, coupled with attentive service, making it a total delight. If you’re hunting for a seafood paradise, Oceans is undeniably a treasure trove of delectable crustacean offerings that made my taste buds dance! 🦞✨

You might also want to check out the best fast food in Manhattan.