Long Island's Best Lobster [Updated 2024]

Through countless tastings and meticulous research, I have personally reviewed twelve exceptional lobster establishments across Long Island. From the charming seaside spots in Montauk to the quaint eateries in the North Fork, this guide will take you on a delectable journey to uncover the finest lobster dishes this region has to offer.

With each succulent bite, you will savor the freshness of the locally caught lobsters, expertly prepared by talented chefs who know how to elevate this delicacy. Whether you prefer your lobster grilled, steamed, or baked to perfection, this comprehensive guide will ensure you find the best lobster experience Long Island has to offer.

Popei's Clam Bar

Highlights
Fresh seafood
Reasonably priced
Excellent waitstaff
Attention to detail
4lb lobster

From the moment I walked through the door, I was greeted by the intoxicating aroma of fresh seafood. Popei's Clam Bar truly knows how to make an impression. The menu showcased an extensive selection of seafood dishes, but my heart was set on their renowned lobster.

What caught my attention right away was the reasonable pricing. It's not every day that you can find a place that offers quality seafood at a price that won't break the bank. And let me tell you, Popei's didn't disappoint. The lobster I ordered was not only affordable, but it was also enormous – a 4lb lobster that was practically begging to be devoured.

The waitstaff at Popei's Clam Bar deserves a special mention. Not only were they friendly and attentive, but they went above and beyond to ensure that my dining experience was nothing short of exceptional. They truly understand the importance of attention to detail and provided me with everything I needed, from extra napkins to a perfectly cracking tool for the lobster.

But let's get to the star of the show: the lobster! The moment I took my first bite, I knew I had found something special. The meat was succulent, tender, and bursting with flavor. Each bite was a delightful dance on my taste buds.

In conclusion, Popei's Clam Bar is a hidden gem that goes above and beyond to deliver a memorable lobster experience. From the fresh seafood selection to the friendly staff, this place has it all. I left with a full belly and a contented smile, eagerly looking forward to my next visit.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in NYC.

The Rex Burger & Lobster

Highlights
Excellent food
Friendly staff
Cool atmosphere
Delicious Lobster Burger

Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately captivated by the cool and lively atmosphere. The modern decor, vibrant lighting, and upbeat music set the stage for a truly enjoyable dining experience.

The friendly staff greeted me with warm smiles and promptly seated me. They were attentive throughout my visit, ensuring that I had everything I needed and offering helpful recommendations. Their knowledge about the menu was impressive, and they enthusiastically answered all of my lobster-related questions.

Now, onto the main event - the food. Let me tell you, the lobsters at The Rex Burger & Lobster are truly outstanding. I decided to try their famous Lobster Burger, and boy, was it a treat! The succulent lobster meat was perfectly cooked, and the combination of flavors was a true delight for my taste buds. Every bite was a burst of seafood bliss.

Aside from the lobster, this culinary gem offers a wide variety of other dishes to please any palate. From their juicy gourmet burgers to their fresh salads, there's something for everyone.

Overall, my visit to The Rex Burger & Lobster was a memorable one. The combination of excellent food, friendly staff, and cool atmosphere made it a standout experience. If you're in Long Island and craving a delicious lobster fix, I wholeheartedly recommend giving The Rex Burger & Lobster a try. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Long Island.

Psari

Highlights
Beautiful outdoor setup
Delicious Broiled Combo
Tender and juicy salmon
Homemade garlic bread
Delicious food for special occasions

Psari, nestled in Long Island, is a true gem when it comes to indulging in the best lobster in town. As I made my way to this seafood haven, I was immediately captivated by its stunning outdoor setup, offering a serene and picturesque atmosphere for my dining experience.

As I perused the menu, my eyes landed on the delicious Broiled Combo, a tantalizing combination of lobster and other fresh seafood delights. Curiosity piqued, I eagerly placed my order, excited to see if Psari would live up to its reputation.

When the dish arrived, it was a feast for both the eyes and the taste buds. The lobster was cooked to perfection - tender and juicy, a true testament to Psari's commitment to quality. Accompanying the seafood masterpiece was a side of homemade garlic bread, a delightful indulgence that added an extra pop of flavor to the meal.

It wasn't just the lobster that impressed me; Psari also excelled in other seafood offerings. The salmon was exquisitely prepared, showcasing the chef's expertise in bringing out the natural flavors of the fish.

Psari is undeniably a place where you can enjoy delicious food for special occasions, in a setting that invites you to linger and savor each bite. Whether you're a seafood aficionado or simply looking to indulge in a memorable lobster experience, this Long Island establishment will not disappoint. So, hop on over to Psari and let your taste buds embark on a captivating culinary journey!

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Manhattan.

Northport Fish & Lobster

Northport Fish & Lobster in Long Island brings the Lobster Game to a whole new level. Their succulent, melt-in-your-mouth delicacy left me in seafood ecstasy. With friendly service, cozy atmosphere, and lobsters that could rival Poseidon's feast, this place definitely deserves a spot on the list of Long Island's best lobster joints.

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Manhattan.

Claws Seafood Market

Claws Seafood Market in Long Island sure knows how to wield a mean crustacean. With its impeccable selection of lobsters, this place is a lobster lover's paradise. The freshness and flavor of their seafood is unmatched, making it a top contender for the best lobster in Long Island title. Don't forget to grab a bib – you'll need it at Claws Seafood Market!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Mill Pond House

I must say, Mill Pond House is a delightful seafood haven that left me speechless. Their lobster is a true culinary masterpiece that will transport your taste buds to seafood heaven. The succulent meat was perfectly cooked and bursting with flavor. This is undoubtedly a must-try for lobster lovers in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Red Lobster

Red Lobster in Long Island is a playful seafood haven! With succulent lobsters that melt in your mouth, this spot is a must-visit for lobster lovers. The service was top-notch, and the atmosphere was lively and fun. Plus, their butter-drenched biscuits are to die for!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Jordan Lobster Farms

Jordan Lobster Farms in Long Island is a treasure trove for seafood lovers like me. The playful atmosphere combined with their excellent selection of lobsters made my taste buds dance with joy. The friendly staff ensured that every bite was fresh and delicious. Jordan Lobster Farms is a must-visit for anyone seeking the best lobster in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Ayhan's Lobster and Fish House

Ayhan's Lobster and Fish House in Long Island is a hidden gem worth clawing your way to. Their lobster dishes are an oceanic adventure for your taste buds. The succulent lobster meat is cooked to perfection, exploding with flavor. Prepare to be shell-shocked by their unparalleled expertise in lobster cuisine.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Louie's Prime Steak & Seafood

Louie's Prime Steak & Seafood in Long Island is a lobster lover's dream. Their succulent lobster dishes are bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection. The combination of tender lobster meat with rich melted butter is irresistible. Don't miss out on this hidden gem for the best lobster in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

LIMANI

With its irresistible ocean view and impeccable service, LIMANI is a lobster lover's utopia. The succulent lobster is perfection, cooked to tender, juicy bliss. Don't forget to indulge in their mouthwatering sides. LIMANI is a seafood paradise that will leave you craving for more.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Peter's Clam Bar

Peter's Clam Bar in Long Island is a hidden gem when it comes to the best lobster. Their lobsters are the kings of the sea, with melt-in-your-mouth meat that is tender and juicy. Their seafood selection is impressive, but the lobster truly steals the show. A must-visit spot for any lobster enthusiast in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.