The Absolute Best Paella in Brooklyn [Updated 2025]

Whether you're a seasoned paella enthusiast or just curious to taste this vibrant dish, you’re in for a treat! After diving into twelve of Brooklyn's top spots, I can confidently say that each place offers its own unique twist on this Spanish classic.

As someone who’s spent countless evenings savoring each flavorful bite and soaking up the lively atmosphere of our local eateries, I’ve become somewhat of a paella aficionado. Trust me, I’ve navigated the menus, chatted with the chefs, and tasted every morsel so you don’t have to. Get ready to embark on a delicious journey through Brooklyn’s best paella—your taste buds are in for a fantastic adventure!

El Born

Highlights
Delicious cocktails
Great octopus dish
Small bites available
Inconsistent portion sizes
Varied menu options

El Born in Brooklyn is a delightful culinary escape, where the vibrant flavors of Spain come alive in a cozy setting. As I stepped inside, I was greeted by the warm ambiance and the tantalizing aroma wafting from the kitchen. The menu boasts a variety of dishes, but I was there for the paella, of course!

The cocktails here are instant crowd-pleasers, perfectly crafted to complement the meal. I sipped on a refreshing sangria that danced on my palate like the flamenco dancers outside. I also indulged in their mouthwatering octopus dish to start—a dish that’s charred to perfection with just the right amount of seasoning. However, the paella itself dazzled, bursting with fresh ingredients and a robust depth of flavor; I could practically hear the Mediterranean waves crashing from my seat.

One thing to note is the inconsistent portion sizes. Some servings might satisfy an army, while others left me craving just a bit more. Despite this, the overall experience at El Born was wonderfully fulfilling, and I can whole-heartedly recommend it to anyone seeking a taste of Spain in Brooklyn. Bon appétit!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Manhattan.

Surfish Bistro

Highlights
Excellent ceviche
Impeccable presentation
Creative cuisine
Quality ingredients
Chef Miguel Aguilar's talent

Surfish Bistro in Brooklyn is a delightful gem that perfectly encapsulates what a fusion of flavors can achieve. As I settled into the vibrant ambiance, I couldn't help but notice the impeccable presentation of the dishes flowing around me. My taste buds were salivating in anticipation, especially after indulging in their excellent ceviche, which set the stage for the grand entrance of the paella.

When the paella arrived, it was visually stunning; the saffron-soaked rice created a gorgeous golden hue, speckled with succulent seafood and tender morsels of chicken. Chef Miguel Aguilar exhibits undeniable talent, crafting a dish that harmonizes rich flavors without overshadowing the freshness of each ingredient. The quality was evident, making each bite a joyous celebration of coastal cuisine.

What truly distinguishes Surfish Bistro is their creative cuisine that effortlessly blends traditional Spanish recipes with a modern twist. As I savored the last bites, I found myself enchanted by the complexity of flavors, leaving me eager to return for another culinary adventure. If you're searching for the best paella in Brooklyn, look no further than Surfish Bistro—where every dish is a work of art!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Brooklyn.

La Vara

At La Vara, the paella transports you straight to the sun-soaked coasts of Spain. The saffron-infused rice, perfectly cooked and adorned with an array of fresh seafood, is a culinary masterpiece. Each bite bursts with flavor, immersing you in a delightful medley of textures. The vibrant ambiance adds to the experience, making it more than just a meal—it's a celebration. The balance of spices is commendable, and the presentation? Simply stunning! If you're seeking a taste of authentic paella, look no further than La Vara—a true gem in Brooklyn's culinary scene!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Queens.

Olea

Olea is a hidden gem that transports you straight to Spain with its vibrant decor and warm ambiance. Their paella de mariscos is a seafood lover's dream—packed with tender shrimp, mussels, and clams, all swimming in a saffron-infused broth that’s both rich and aromatic. The rice is cooked to perfection, forming that elusive socarrat at the bottom—every bite is sheer bliss! What truly sets Olea apart is the lively atmosphere, perfect for celebrating a night out. Don’t skip dessert; their flan is the cherry on top of a delightful culinary journey. A must-visit for all paella enthusiasts!

You might also want to check out the best seafood tower in NYC.

Casa Ora

At Casa Ora, the paella is a colorful feast for the senses! The saffron-infused rice dances harmoniously with a delightful medley of fresh seafood and succulent chicken, creating a symphony of flavors that serenades the palate. Each bite is an adventure, with perfectly cooked mussels and shrimp adding a touch of the ocean. The ambiance is vibrant, infused with warmth and a touch of Spanish flair—perfect for savoring this dish. Pair it with a robust sangria, and you’ve got a culinary escape that leaves you craving more. Simply put, Casa Ora serves up a paella that is not to be missed!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Long Island.

EZ Paella & Tapas

Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, EZ Paella & Tapas is a delightful gem that serves up an impressive take on this classic dish. The seafood paella bursts with flavor, featuring perfectly cooked rice and an abundance of tender shrimp and mussels. The saffron gives it a radiant hue, while the slight smokiness from the pan adds depth. I couldn't help but savor each bite! Their vibrant ambience complements the culinary experience, making it a perfect spot for both casual diners and special occasions. If you're in the mood for authentic Spanish flair, EZ Paella & Tapas is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Harlem.

La Ñapa

La Ñapa in Brooklyn is a hidden gem that truly impresses with its vibrant flavors and rich textures. My paella was a delightful symphony of saffron-infused rice, perfectly cooked seafood, and a pinch of smoked paprika that elevated every bite. The generous portions cater to the hearty appetite, while the cozy atmosphere invites you to linger. Their unique twists, like the inclusion of chorizo, are a delightful surprise. If you’re seeking an authentic Spanish experience, La Ñapa delivers with flair and gusto, making it a must-visit for any paella enthusiast in Brooklyn!

You might also want to check out the best seafood market in Brooklyn.

Bogota Latin Bistro

Bogota Latin Bistro is a vibrant gem that serves up an unforgettable paella experience. Tucked away in a lively corner of Brooklyn, the dish bursts with flavor, offering succulent shrimp, tender chicken, and mouthwatering chorizo, all dancing harmoniously atop perfectly cooked saffron rice. The aromatic spices elevate each bite, making it a delightful adventure for the senses. The lively atmosphere and friendly staff only add to the charm, making it a perfect spot for gatherings. My palate was delighted, and I left with a satisfied smile, already planning my next visit for more of that postcard-perfect paella!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Llama Inn

Nestled in Williamsburg, Llama Inn serves up a paella that ignites the senses. The aromatic saffron blends seamlessly with locally sourced seafood, creating a dish that feels both authentic and innovative. With perfectly cooked rice that boasts a delightful al dente texture, every bite dances with flavor. The vibrant presentation and the playful flair of their Peruvian twist elevate this classic dish into a culinary masterpiece. The lively atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a perfect spot for paella lovers. If you’re seeking a unique take on this Spanish favorite, Llama Inn is not to be missed!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Guarapo Latin Fusion

At Guarapo Latin Fusion, I was instantly enchanted by the vibrant atmosphere. Their seafood paella was a delightful whirlwind of flavors! Each bite was bursting with perfectly cooked shrimp, tender mussels, and a hint of saffron that tied everything together. The rice was delightfully al dente, soaking up the rich broth, while the fresh herbs added a delightful touch. Paired with a zesty salsa verde, this dish is a fiesta for the taste buds! If you’re searching for an authentic yet innovative paella experience in Brooklyn, look no further than Guarapo – it's a culinary adventure you won't want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Socarrat Paella Bar - Nolita

Visiting Socarrat Paella Bar - Nolita was a delightful culinary adventure! The moment I stepped in, the inviting aromas of saffron and simmering seafood engulfed my senses. I ordered the classic seafood paella, a vibrant tapestry of fresh squid, shrimp, and mussels, all simmered perfectly with that coveted socarrat crust. Each bite was a harmonious blend of flavors, and the rice had a beautiful al dente texture. The ambiance struck a balance between casual and chic, making it a perfect spot for both intimate dinners or lively gatherings. If you're seeking a culinary celebration, this gem is not to be missed!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Le Fatima

Nestled in the vibrant streets of Brooklyn, Le Fatima serves up a paella that dances between traditional roots and bold innovation. The saffron-infused rice bursts with flavor, while the tender seafood—think succulent shrimp and mussels—sings harmoniously with the carefully curated spices. Each bite feels like a sunny escape to the Mediterranean. The ambiance is as inviting as the dish itself, making it a perfect spot for gatherings. If you're on the hunt for an unforgettable paella experience, look no further than Le Fatima; it’s a delightful culinary journey that will tantalize your taste buds!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.