NYC's Best Calamari [Updated 2025]

As I dove into the vibrant culinary scene of this city, I found myself on a delicious quest that took me to 12 standout spots, each serving up their own spin on this beloved dish. Trust me, I’ve tasted everything from crispy rings to tender, succulent bites that transport your taste buds straight to the coast.

Calamari isn’t just a dish; it’s an experience, and I’ve made it my mission to sift through the crowded streets and hidden gems to bring you only the best. Whether you’re a die-hard fan or a curious newbie, I promise you’ll find a new favorite in this roundup that showcases the creativity and passion of NYC’s chefs. Let’s dive in!

Il Corallo Trattoria

Highlights
Cozy and warm atmosphere
Delicious and flavorful food
Quick and accommodating service
Great for large parties
Solid Italian cuisine

Il Corallo Trattoria is a true gem nestled among the bustling streets of NYC. As soon as I entered, the cozy and warm atmosphere enveloped me like a comforting embrace. I could hardly contain my excitement as I anticipated the star of my culinary adventure: the calamari!

When it arrived, I was instantly captivated. The calamari were perfectly fried—golden and crispy, yet tender enough to practically melt in your mouth. The delicious and flavorful take on this classic dish was enhanced by a delightful marinara sauce that had just the right amount of zing. Each bite was a harmonious blend of textures and tastes, making it a standout dish on the menu.

The quick and accommodating service only added to the pleasurable experience. It’s worth mentioning that this spot is great for large parties, ensuring that everyone can partake in this heavenly calamari together.

If you're a calamari connoisseur like me, Il Corallo Trattoria should absolutely be on your list. This Italian delight truly elevates a simple dish into a mouthwatering experience that has cemented its place among the best calamari in NYC. Buon Appetito!

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Brooklyn.

Osteria al Doge

Highlights
Pre-Broadway dining experience
Good food in a tough area
Fresh bread basket included
Reservation recommended
Limited restroom availability

When I stepped into Osteria al Doge, I was immediately enveloped by the warm ambiance—a perfect pre-Broadway dining spot. As I settled in, I couldn't help but appreciate the freshness of the bread basket that accompanied my meal. It’s the little touches that set the stage for a delightful evening. Now, let’s get to the star of the show: the calamari.

Served perfectly fried to a golden crisp, each tender piece of calamari was accompanied by a gently spicy marinara that played harmoniously with the dish's subtle flavors. The seasoning was on point, elevating the texture of the squid while providing just the right kick. It’s refreshing to find a restaurant in this tough area that manages to serve such delicious food.

Don’t forget to make reservations ahead of time; this gem can fill up quickly! With limited restroom availability, a bit of planning is advisable. Overall, Osteria al Doge not only serves stellar calamari, but also ensures your visit is a perfect blend of flavor and atmosphere. I left with a smile, already anticipating my next visit!

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Long Island.

Bigoi Venezia

Highlights
Homemade fresh pasta
_Quick service
Charming ambiance
Engaging owner
Simple and complex sauces

Visiting Bigoi Venezia was an experience that tantalized both my taste buds and my imagination. As I stepped inside, the charming ambiance enveloped me, transporting me to a cozy Italian trattoria right out of a film set. The warm smiles of the staff mirrored the inviting decor, instantly making me feel at home.

When it came to their calamari, I was thrilled to discover a delightful twist on a classic. The dish boasted homemade fresh pasta, which paired excellently with the tender calamari. Each bite was a beautiful interplay of texture, with the squid not too chewy and the batter perfectly crisped.

What struck me most was the effortless balance of simple and complex sauces that accompanied the dish. A drizzle of tangy marinara brought a refreshing zest, while a hint of something secretive—perhaps a pinch of herbs—lingered pleasantly on my palate.

To cap it off, the owner’s passion for food was infectious; his engaging personality added an extra layer of warmth to the dining experience. For calamari enthusiasts seeking something special in NYC, Bigoi Venezia is undoubtedly a spot you shouldn’t miss!

You might also want to check out the best asian food in Brooklyn.

Gelso & Grand

Highlights
Gorgeous rustic decor
Attentive and friendly service
Creative and delicious cocktails
Reasonable prices for location
Fun photo booth available

Gelso & Grand is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of NYC, where I recently indulged in their calamari, and let me tell you, it was an adventure for the taste buds! The gorgeous rustic decor immediately set the stage for a cozy evening, drawing me in like a moth to a flame. I was welcomed by attentive and friendly service, which made me feel right at home as I prepared to dive into the menu.

Now, let’s talk calamari. The dish arrived piping hot, perfectly textured, and accompanied by a vibrant marinara that was bursting with flavor. The lightly breaded rings were crisp yet tender, showcasing a beautiful balance that many strive for but few achieve. I found myself mesmerized, savoring each bite as I paired it with one of the creative and delicious cocktails they offer.

Another charm of Gelso & Grand? The prices are surprisingly reasonable for the location, making it an excellent choice for both special occasions and casual outings. And before you leave, don’t forget to snap a fun pic at their photo booth! It’s an experience that goes beyond just great food, and truly a must-visit for calamari enthusiasts.

You might also want to check out the best asian food in Manhattan.

Osteria La Baia

Osteria La Baia’s calamari is a delightful dive into crispy perfection! The tender rings are lightly dusted and fried to a golden hue, just right for that satisfying crunch. Each bite is bursting with flavor, perfectly complemented by a zesty lemon aioli that adds a delightful tang. The portion size is generous, making it ideal for sharing—or not! The cozy ambiance enhances your dining experience, inviting you to savor every moment. If you’re on the hunt for exceptional calamari in NYC, look no further than Osteria La Baia—where every forkful feels like a taste of the Mediterranean!

You might also want to check out the best cajun food in NYC.

Fish Cheeks

At Fish Cheeks, the calamari is a delightful revelation! Served lightly battered and perfectly fried, these tender morsels boast a crispiness that’s simply irresistible. Each bite bursts with flavor, enhanced by a drizzle of spicy dipping sauce that adds a playful kick. The presentation? Artful—served alongside fresh herbs, it’s almost too pretty to eat! The vibrant atmosphere complements the dish, making it a perfect spot for seafood lovers. If you’re on the hunt for calamari that dances on your palate, Fish Cheeks is an absolute must-visit. Deliciously memorable!

You might also want to check out the best japanese food in Brooklyn.

OLIO E PIÙ

At OLIO E PIÙ, the calamari is a delightful treat that stands out brilliantly in the bustling NYC dining scene. The calamari was perfectly crispy, adorned with a light dusting of seasoning that tantalized my taste buds. What truly set it apart was the accompanying homemade marinara, bursting with fresh herbs and a hint of spice, making every bite a flavorful journey. The dish is generous enough for sharing, though I found myself reluctant to part with it! If you’re hunting for delicious calamari in NYC, OLIO E PIÙ is a must-visit. Trust me—your palate will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Il Posto Accanto

At Il Posto Accanto, the calamari is a delightful revelation that dances on your palate. This dish is perfectly golden, boasting a light and crispy batter that leaves a tantalizing crunch with each bite. The marinara sauce served alongside is vibrant, with a hint of spice that enhances the tender squid. Each piece is cooked to perfection, showcasing the chefs’ skills and love for Italian cuisine. The atmosphere is charmingly quaint, making it an ideal spot for both casual diners and romantic evenings. If you’re on the hunt for calamari that sings, look no further than Il Posto Accanto!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Aqua Boil

At Aqua Boil, the calamari delivers a delightful crunch that dances on the palate. Served with a zesty citrus dipping sauce that elevates its subtle flavor, this dish combines freshness with a hint of excitement. Each tender ring is perfectly fried, showcasing the kitchen’s commitment to quality and technique. The casual atmosphere adds a vibrant touch to the experience, making it a perfect spot to indulge in this seafood delight. If you're searching for calamari that tantalizes while keeping things fun, look no further than Aqua Boil—a true gem in the seafood realm of New York City!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Flex Mussels

Flex Mussels is a delightful treasure tucked away in the bustling streets of NYC. Upon diving into their calamari, I was immediately enchanted by the crispy batter that embraced each ring perfectly. The dish is accompanied by a zesty marinara sauce that elevates the flavor profile to new heights. What truly sets it apart is the hint of spice that lingers, teasing the palate with every bite. The portion sizes are generous, making it a perfect starter to share—or not! For calamari lovers seeking a playful twist on a classic, Flex Mussels has certainly earned its place on my list of favorites.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Carmine's - Time Square

Carmine's - Times Square offers a delightful twist on traditional calamari that truly captivated my palate. Served with a zesty marinara sauce and perfectly seasoned, each bite was a harmonious blend of crispy and tender. I was especially impressed by the generous portion size, making it ideal for sharing—or indulging solo! The ambiance was vibrant, adding a fun touch to the overall experience. If you're on the hunt for calamari that’s both satisfying and flavorful, Carmine's is definitely a must-try spot in the heart of the city. Don’t miss it!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Bacaro

At Bacaro, calamari takes center stage with a delightful twist. The crispy, golden rings are perfectly seasoned and served with a zesty dipping sauce that elevates the dish. Each bite is a harmonious blend of texture and flavor, highlighting the freshness of the squid. The atmosphere is cozy, making it a great spot for a casual meal or a celebration. What truly shines is the chef’s passion for crafting these tender morsels, resulting in calamari that’s both indulgent and satisfying. If you’re seeking an unforgettable calamari experience in NYC, Bacaro deserves a top spot on your list!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.