The Absolute Best Calamari in Brooklyn [Updated 2025]

Each bite of tender calamari is a delightful adventure, and Brooklyn has become my favorite playground for this culinary treasure. After diving into twelve top-notch spots, I can confidently say that the borough’s take on this classic dish is nothing short of spectacular.

With my taste buds finely tuned from years of exploring flavors, I’ve navigated the bustling streets and hidden gems to bring you the crème de la crème of calamari. Whether you're a seasoned seafood lover or just curious to try something new, you’ll find a dish that will make your taste buds dance. Let’s dive into this delicious journey together!

Barbalu Bklyn

Highlights
Perfect for dinner gatherings
Delicious squid ink pasta
Quality service under pressure
Crowd-approved dining
Tasty dessert options

At Barbalu Bklyn, calamari transforms into a culinary delight that tantalizes your taste buds. The moment I walked in, the lively atmosphere set the stage for a delightful evening. The calamari here is nothing short of an invitation to indulge; it’s tender, lightly fried, and beautifully seasoned.

I especially enjoyed how it was paired with tantalizing dips that amplify the flavors without overpowering the freshness of the squid. Sharing the dish with friends was an experience that ignited conversations about its exquisite preparation—perfect for a dinner gathering with family and friends.

As I savored the meal, I couldn’t help but be impressed by the efficient yet personable service, even when the restaurant was buzzing with patrons. And let’s not forget their delicious dessert options that were the perfect sweet ending to a remarkable dining experience.

In short, Barbalu Bklyn has managed to serve a calamari dish that not only satisfies but also lingers in your memory, making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors alike. If you're craving a great calamari experience in Brooklyn, this place deserves a spot on your list!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Manhattan.

Locanda Vini & Olii

Highlights
Authentic Italian cuisine
Knowledgeable and friendly staff
Expansive yet manageable menu
Fantastic wines selection
Historic building ambiance

Locanda Vini & Olii in Brooklyn is a hidden gem that delivers a delightful culinary experience. As I sat in the charming, historic building, I was immediately enveloped by the ambiance—warm, inviting, and full of character. It was the perfect setting for my eagerly anticipated exploration of their calamari.

When the dish arrived, I admired the golden-brown hue and delicate presentation. Each squid ring was perfectly cooked, boasting an impressive tenderness that melted in my mouth. The accompanying sauce—a luscious blend of garlic, chili, and a hint of citrus—was nothing short of magical, enhancing the flavors without overwhelming them. This dish was a true testament to the authentic Italian cuisine that Locanda is known for.

What truly set the experience apart was the knowledgeable staff, who guided me through the expansive wine selection, perfectly pairing my calamari with a light, crisp white that complemented the dish splendidly. Dining at Locanda Vini & Olii was a feast for the senses, and their calamari is indeed one of the best I've had in Brooklyn. I left with a full belly and a smile on my face, eager to return for another round!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Brooklyn.

Montesacro Brooklyn

Highlights
Nice backyard garden
Good food overall
Long wait for service
Friendly servers
Unbearable brunch options

Calamari Review: Montesacro Brooklyn

Nestled in Brooklyn, Montesacro has a delightful backyard garden that beckons you to unwind and savor good food. I recently popped in with high hopes for their calamari, intrigued by the buzz surrounding this dish. From the moment I arrived, the friendly servers made me feel right at home, chatting amiably as I awaited my meal.

Now, let's talk about the calamari! While the wait for service felt a tad long, patience is a virtue when it comes to good food. When the dish finally arrived, I was met with a plate of golden, crispy delights. The calamari was tender and beautifully seasoned, with a subtle hint of spice. Each bite was perfectly accompanied by a zesty dipping sauce that added a refreshing zing, elevating the mood of the entire meal.

However, while the experience itself was enjoyable, I couldn't help but feel that the menu suffered from some unbearable brunch options that might cause a distraction from their stellar seafood. Despite that, I'd gladly return to Montesacro for another round of their delicious calamari, enjoying the atmosphere and the savory crunch that only this place can offer!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Brooklyn.

al di là Trattoria

Highlights
Quaint neighborhood staple
Great food and service
Perfectly cooked meat
Creamy polenta
Good vibes all around

Al di là Trattoria is a quaint neighborhood staple that feels like a warm embrace the moment you step inside. The charming ambiance sets the stage for what would become a delightful culinary journey. I ordered their calamari, and to say it was perfectly cooked would be an understatement. The squid was tender, yet had a crispiness that achieved that beautiful balance between texture and flavor.

What truly set this dish apart was how it harmonized with a creamy polenta that accompanied it. Each bite of calamari paired beautifully with the smooth texture of the polenta, elevating the dish to new heights. It’s clear that al di là doesn’t just serve food; they craft experiences. The service was attentive, yet relaxed—just the right vibe for a bustling Brooklyn night.

If you’re in the mood for good vibes and great food, make sure to stop by al di là Trattoria. Their calamari is not just a starter; it’s a celebration of flavors that leaves you wanting more. In my pursuit of the best calamari in Brooklyn, this spot has undoubtedly made its mark!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in NYC.

Macosa Trattoria

At Macosa Trattoria, I was greeted by a charming atmosphere that set the perfect stage for what would be a delightful culinary adventure. Their calamari, lightly fried to golden perfection, boasted an irresistible crunch, while the tender rings melted in my mouth. The accompanying zesty marinara elevated the dish, with herbs dancing playfully on the palate. Each bite felt like a warm embrace from the Mediterranean, making it hard to stop at just one serving. If you’re seeking a fantastic calamari experience in Brooklyn, Macosa Trattoria is a must-visit—a delightful catch!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Osteria Brooklyn

At Osteria Brooklyn, I discovered a delightful take on calamari that dances between tenderness and a perfectly crisp exterior. The secret? A light, seasoned batter that doesn't overshadow the fresh squid's flavor. Each bite is complemented by a zesty marinara that adds just the right kick. You can feel the Italian roots in every dish, making this calamari not just an appetizer, but a culinary experience. If you're looking for a place where tradition meets innovation, Osteria is a must-visit. Trust me, this calamari will have you coming back for more – it's simply irresistible!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Queens.

Michael’s

At Michael's, I was greeted with a plate of golden-brown calamari that immediately caught my eye. The crispy coating was light and flaky, perfectly balanced with a hint of spice. Each tender bite was complemented by a zesty marinara that danced on my palate, making it hard to resist going back for more. The portion was generous, ideal for sharing—or not! The ambiance was cozy, adding to the overall experience. If you're looking to indulge in exceptional calamari, Michael’s deserves a spot on your culinary journey through Brooklyn!

You might also want to check out the best cakes in NYC.

Mama Rao's

At Mama Rao's, the calamari is a delightful triumph! Crispy and golden, each bite bursts with flavor, thanks to a light, zesty coating. Served with a tangy marinara dipping sauce that perfectly complements the dish, this appetizer is a must-try. The texture strikes that perfect balance between tender and crispy, showcasing really top-notch preparation. The ambiance of the restaurant adds to the experience, making each visit feel special. Overall, Mama Rao's has earned its place among Brooklyn's finest for calamari lovers — a culinary gem worth savoring! The squid dreams are definitely made here!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Piccoli Trattoria

At Piccoli Trattoria, the calamari is a delightful masterpiece that dances on the palate. The tender rings are perfectly fried to a golden crisp, offering a textural contrast that delights. Each bite bursts with flavor, complemented by a zesty marinara that adds just the right kick. What sets this dish apart is the herb-infused batter, which elevates the dish from ordinary to extraordinary. Paired with a hint of lemon and fresh parsley, it's a dish that invites you to savor each moment. If you're searching for calamari that excites, Piccoli Trattoria is a must-try destination in Brooklyn!

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurants in NYC.

Camillo

At Camillo, my taste buds were in for a delightful surprise. The calamari arrived perfectly crispy, lightly breaded, and glistening with a tangy lemon aioli that made my mouth water. Each bite was pure bliss, tender yet satisfying, with just the right amount of seasoning to enhance its natural flavor. The accompanying marinara added a robust twist, elevating the dish to culinary stardom. Camillo's ambiance felt like a cozy Italian getaway, making it the perfect backdrop for such a lavish treat. If you're on the hunt for the best calamari in Brooklyn, this spot should definitely be on your list!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

LaRina Pastificio & Vino

At LaRina Pastificio & Vino, the calamari is a true delight! Tender and perfectly cooked, each piece boasts a golden-brown exterior that gives way to a juicy, flavorful bite. The accompanying marinara is a beautiful balance of tangy and savory, elevating each taste. I especially loved the touch of fresh herbs sprinkled on top, adding a burst of freshness that perfectly complements the dish. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it a fantastic spot to indulge in this classic appetizer. If you’re a calamari enthusiast, this spot is not to be missed in your Brooklyn culinary adventures!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Briscola Trattoria

Briscola Trattoria serves up calamari that's nothing short of a culinary fiesta! Their lightly fried rings arrive golden and crispy, perfectly paired with a zesty marinara that sings with flavor. Each bite bursts with freshness, likely sourced from local markets. I was particularly charmed by the addition of pepperoncini, which adds a delightful kick. The ambiance is inviting, making it an ideal spot for an evening of indulgence. If you find yourself in Brooklyn and craving calamari, Briscola Trattoria should be at the top of your list for a taste that dances on the palate!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in NYC.