NYC's Best Milkshake [Updated 2024]

Having tasted and reviewed a whopping 12 milkshakes across the city, I can confidently say that I have narrowed down the ultimate contenders for the title of the best milkshake in NYC. From classic flavors to inventive creations, I have explored every nook and cranny of the city to bring you this comprehensive guide.

So, whether you're a milkshake aficionado or just looking for a refreshing treat on a hot summer day, fasten your seatbelts and get ready to embark on a milkshake journey like no other. Get your taste buds ready, because we're about to indulge in the creamiest, most delicious milkshakes NYC has to offer!

Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - SoHo

Highlights
Friendly staff
Delicious burgers
Mega shake
Amazing Oreo Crazy Shake

From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly staff. Their warm welcome immediately set the tone for a delightful milkshake adventure.

Before diving into the extraordinary milkshakes, I couldn't resist trying one of their delicious burgers. They were cooked to perfection, with juicy patties and mouthwatering toppings that left me craving for more.

Now, onto the main attraction - the mega shakes. These towering concoctions are a sight to behold. But it's not just about the appearance; the taste is equally impressive. I opted for the famous Oreo Crazy Shake, and boy, did it live up to its reputation. The velvety vanilla ice cream was beautifully blended with Oreo cookies and topped with whipped cream and even more Oreo goodness. With each sip, I was overwhelmed by the rich creamy texture and indulgent taste.

Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - SoHo truly knows how to create an amazing milkshake. The combination of flavors and textures is nothing short of a masterpiece. Their attention to detail and commitment to quality is evident in every sip.

So, if you're in search of the best milkshake in NYC, I highly recommend visiting Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - SoHo. From their friendly staff to their delicious burgers and show-stopping mega shakes, this place undoubtedly deserves a spot on your milkshake bucket list. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Soft Swerve Ice Cream

Highlights
great tasting flavors
friendly staff
nostalgic decor
generous serving size

Soft Swerve Ice Cream truly knows how to deliver a milkshake that will leave you craving for more. With its great tasting flavors and generous serving size, this place definitely lives up to its reputation as one of the best milkshake spots in NYC.

From the moment I walked in, I was warmly greeted by their friendly staff who made me feel right at home. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, with nostalgic decor that took me back to my childhood days of enjoying milkshakes at the local soda fountain.

Now, onto the milkshakes themselves. Soft Swerve offers a wide range of flavors to choose from, each one as delicious as the next. Whether you're a chocolate lover, a fan of fruity flavors, or even if you prefer a classic vanilla, you won't be disappointed. The milkshakes are not only flavorful but also incredibly creamy, providing that perfect balance of sweetness and richness.

But the true highlight of Soft Swerve's milkshakes is the excellent texture. They are perfectly blended, ensuring a smooth and velvety consistency that is pure bliss with every sip. Each shake is made with care and attention to detail, resulting in a truly indulgent treat.

Overall, Soft Swerve Ice Cream deserves its place among the top contenders for the best milkshake in NYC. With its amazing flavors, friendly staff, and nostalgic ambiance, this spot is a must-visit for any milkshake enthusiast. Don't miss out on the opportunity to sample their delectable creations.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Lexington Candy Shop

Highlights
Authentic soda
100 years of history
Best Cherry Coke
Friendly staff
Best sandwich

Walking into Lexington Candy Shop, I was immediately transported back in time. This authentic soda fountain has over 100 years of history, and it truly feels like stepping into a bygone era. I knew I was in for a treat.

One of the highlights of my visit was their Cherry Coke milkshake. Let me tell you, it was a game-changer. The perfect blend of creamy vanilla ice cream and the tangy sweetness of cherry syrup made for an unforgettable taste sensation. Each sip delivered a symphony of flavors that danced on my taste buds.

But the milkshake was just the beginning. The staff at Lexington Candy Shop was incredibly welcoming and friendly, adding to the overall charm of the place. They were more than happy to share their knowledge about the history of the establishment and offer recommendations.

While the milkshakes were the main attraction, it's worth noting that Lexington Candy Shop also serves up the best sandwiches in town. I couldn't resist trying their classic BLT, and it did not disappoint. The homemade bread, crispy bacon, and fresh lettuce and tomato combined to create a sandwich that was simply divine.

In conclusion, if you're a milkshake aficionado like me, Lexington Candy Shop is a must-visit. From their historical ambiance to their delicious drinks, this place has it all. Don't miss out on trying their signature Cherry Coke milkshake; it's a true gem in the world of milkshakes. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Milk Bar

Milk Bar in NYC is a playful paradise for milkshake enthusiasts! Their creatively crafted concoctions, like the Birthday Cake Shake, are a pure delight for the taste buds. With a perfect balance of creaminess and sweetness, Milk Bar earns its spot as a top contender for the best milkshake in NYC.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Creamline

Creamline in NYC is a milkshake lover's dream come true! With their creamy, decadent creations, this place has raised the milkshake bar to a new level. The smooth texture, bold flavors, and innovative combinations make Creamline a must-visit destination for any milkshake aficionado.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Ray's Candy Store

I have just returned from exploring the milkshake scene in NYC, and I must say, Ray's Candy Store left me with a befuddled taste bud symphony. Words cannot do justice to the magical concoctions they whip up. From traditional classics to inventive creations, Ray's has mastered the art of the milkshake.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

ShakeTop Milkshakes

To put it simply, ShakeTop Milkshakes just didn't shake my world. The milkshakes were decent, but lacked that wow factor. Presentation was on point, but the taste fell short. With so many other contenders, ShakeTop just didn't rise to the top.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Davey's Ice Cream

Davey's Ice Cream in NYC is a milkshake lover's paradise. With creamy and decadent options such as the vanilla bean dream and the chocolate overload, Davey's spoils you with their delicious creations. The velvety texture and rich flavors make it a top contender for the best milkshake in NYC.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Shake Shack Madison Square Park

I stepped into Shake Shack Madison Square Park in NYC with high hopes of finding the best milkshake in the city. As I took my first sip of their creamy concoction, I was instantly transported to milkshake heaven. The richness of the flavors and the velvety smoothness of the texture had me smitten. This milkshake was a true work of art, worthy of my quest for the best. Shake Shack Madison Square Park, you have nailed it!

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Tipsy Scoop

I have to say, Tipsy Scoop truly lives up to its name! This boozy ice cream parlor serves up amazing milkshakes with a twist. The combination of creamy ice cream and a splash of alcohol creates a flavor explosion in every sip. The funky flavors like "Cake Batter Vodka Martini" and "Mango Margarita" take milkshakes to a whole new level. The presentation is on point too, with colorful toppings and a generous swirl of whipped cream. So if you're looking for a shake that will make your taste buds sing and put a smile on your face, head on over to Tipsy Scoop. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

16 Handles

16 Handles in NYC was a delightful milkshake destination. They had a wide array of flavors to choose from, including classics and unique creations. The shakes were creamy and flavor-packed, making every sip a pleasurable experience. This spot is a must-visit for milkshake lovers in the city.

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

If I were writing a short 50-word summary review of Van Leeuwen Ice Cream for an article about the best milkshake in NYC, it might go something like this:

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream in NYC is a shake lover's paradise. Their milkshakes are rich, creamy, and packed with flavor. With unique options like honeycomb and matcha, Van Leeuwen is definitely a top contender for the best milkshake in the city.