Best Milkshakes in Brooklyn: Our Expert Picks for 2025

I’ve scoured the streets, indulged in countless creamy concoctions, and even made a few friends along the way—all in the name of finding the ultimate milkshake. After diving deep into the local scene, I’ve narrowed it down to 13 must-visit spots that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth and leave you craving more.

You can trust my taste buds; I’ve spent years perfecting my milkshake palate and navigating the vibrant flavors that Brooklyn has to offer. Whether you're a classic vanilla lover or someone who craves bold, unexpected twists, I promise there’s something in this guide that will make you swoon. So grab your straw, and let’s dive into the delicious world of Brooklyn milkshakes!

Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain

Highlights
Vintage decor and ambiance
Toasted marshmallow milkshake
Ample seating for cozy chats
Authentic vintage drinks
Unique experience with desserts

Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain is an absolute gem nestled in the heart of Brooklyn. Stepping through the doors feels like a delightful time warp, with its vintage decor that exudes charm and nostalgia. The atmosphere, filled with laughter and the gentle clinking of glasses, is perfect for cozy chats with friends or family.

Now, let’s talk milkshakes—their toasted marshmallow milkshake is a revelation! Imagine this: creamy vanilla goodness swirled with perfectly toasted marshmallow, creating a heavenly balance of flavors that transports you back to summer bonfires. With every sip, I felt like a kid again—pure bliss!

What I particularly enjoyed was the authentic vintage drinks menu available, offering an array of options that complement their desserts beautifully. The ample seating invites you to linger longer, indulging in the experience and savoring each moment.

Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain doesn’t just serve milkshakes; they deliver a unique experience that makes you wish you had a little more room for just one more! This delightful spot is certainly a top contender in the quest for the best milkshakes in Brooklyn. Trust me, you won’t want to miss it!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Manhattan.

Harlem Shake

Highlights
Cool atmosphere
Must-try peanut butter shake
Tasty vanilla custard shake
Small but flavorful burgers
Nice overall experience

Harlem Shake: A Milkshake Marvel in Brooklyn

During my delightful journey through the milkshake landscape of Brooklyn, I ventured into the vibrant Harlem Shake, where the atmosphere immediately drew me in. The lively decor and welcoming vibe set the stage for what was to become a memorable tasting experience.

As I scanned the menu, one item called out to me—the peanut butter shake. This creamy concoction was a revelation; each sip delivered a perfect balance of nutty boldness wrapped in a velvety texture that made me sigh with satisfaction. If you’re a peanut butter enthusiast, this shake is an absolute must-try!

Not to be overlooked, their vanilla custard shake was another highlight that epitomized simplicity and taste. It was rich and creamy, bursting with the ideal vanilla flavor that whisked me away to a nostalgic state.

While savoring my shakes, I couldn’t resist trying one of their small but mighty burgers. Paired with my shakes, the overall experience felt extraordinary. Harlem Shake effortlessly combines charming ambiance with indulgent flavors, solidifying its spot among the best milkshake destinations in Brooklyn. If you haven't been, you're undoubtedly missing out!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Brooklyn.

Ample Hills Creamery at The Social Brooklyn

The moment I stepped into Ample Hills Creamery at The Social Brooklyn, I was greeted by a whimsical vibe that perfectly matches their delightful milkshakes. I opted for the “Malted Milkshake”, a creamy blend of rich chocolate and velvety vanilla, topped with a crown of whipped cream and a dusting of chocolate shavings. Each sip was a rich adventure, with a texture that practically dances on your palate. Their attention to quality ingredients shines through, making every indulgent moment worth it. If you’re on the hunt for a masterpiece in a glass, this shake is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Ample Hills Creamery

Ample Hills Creamery is a delightful treasure tucked away in Brooklyn, where every sip feels like a joyful celebration of flavors. Their milkshakes are a heavenly blend of rich, creamy ice cream and whimsical toppings that elevate the classic into the extraordinary. I opted for the Malted Milkshake, a deliciously indulgent concoction that perfectly captured the nostalgia of childhood with a grown-up twist. The texture was luxuriously thick, inviting me to savor each luscious bite. If you’re searching for a milkshake that brings a smile to your face and warmth to your heart, look no further—Ample Hills is an absolute must-try!

You might also want to check out the best cakes in NYC.

Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream

At Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream, I was immediately enchanted by the cozy atmosphere and the delightful array of flavors. Their classic chocolate milkshake is an absolute standout, perfectly creamy with a rich, indulgent taste that makes every sip a moment of bliss. The whipped cream topping is generously fluffy, making it a delightful treat for both the eyes and the palate. Each milkshake is crafted with care, using only the highest-quality ingredients, and you can truly taste the love in every sip. If you’re hunting for a milkshake that feels like a hug in a cup, look no further than Mr P's!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Sugar Hill Creamery

Stepping into Sugar Hill Creamery feels like entering dessert heaven! Their milkshake, a glorious blend of rich and creamy ice cream, is an absolute delight. I savored the “Brownie Batter” shake, which was a tantalizing concoction, combining chunks of chewy brownie with a smooth, velvety base. The drizzle of chocolate syrup on top was the perfect finishing touch, making each sip a delightfully decadent experience. The ambiance is as vibrant as their flavors, inviting you to linger. If you're in the Brooklyn area, don't miss this gem—it's a sweet adventure that leaves your taste buds dancing!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Ice Cream House

At Ice Cream House, each sip of their milkshake feels like a mini-vacation! The chocolate-fudge delight was a heavenly concoction, blending rich chocolate ice cream with thick, creamy fudge—truly indulgent! Their use of real ingredients shines through, making each shake a delightful journey for your taste buds. The atmosphere is as inviting as the milkshakes themselves, with vibrant decor that adds to the fun. Don't skip the sprinkles; they add a perfect crunch! If you're on a quest for the ultimate milkshake in Brooklyn, you must stop by this gem—for a shake that feels like a sweet hug!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Shake Shack Downtown Brooklyn

At Shake Shack Downtown Brooklyn, my taste buds were treated to a delightful concoction of creamy goodness. I indulged in their famous Black & White Shake, expertly blending rich chocolate and velvety vanilla ice cream. The texture was silky and satisfying, making every sip feel like a luxurious reward. Topped with a generous swirl of whipped cream, this milkshake was not just a drink but an experience! The charming atmosphere and friendly staff added to the enjoyment, making it a perfect spot for milkshake lovers. If you’re in the mood for a classic treat, Shake Shack is definitely worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Manhattan.

Stack'd Burger

At Stack'd Burger, I encountered a milkshake that truly defines indulgence. Their Salted Caramel Pretzel Shake is a delightful whirlwind of flavors; the creamy base provides a rich backdrop for crunchy pretzel pieces and ribbons of lush caramel. Each sip balances sweetness and salty bursts, leaving you craving more with every slurp. The generous toppings of whipped cream and chocolate drizzle seal the deal. This is not just a drink—it's an experience! Whether you're transitioning from a burger binge or just treating yourself, Stack'd proves that a milkshake can be a satisfying pleasure right here in Brooklyn.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Long Island City.

Ray's Candy Store

Stepping into Ray's Candy Store is like entering a delightful time capsule of sweet nostalgia! Their milkshake, a velvety blend of rich ice cream and vibrant flavors, is nothing short of a revelation. I opted for the classic chocolate shake, topped with whipped cream and rainbow sprinkles—a whimsical touch that instantly transported me back to childhood. The thick, creamy texture was perfectly balanced, making each sip a euphoric experience. If you're craving a nostalgic treat that ignites your inner child, this is a must-try. For milkshake fans in Brooklyn, Ray's is an irresistible gem!

You might also want to check out the best italian food in NYC.

Caraotas

At Caraotas, I was greeted with a delightful atmosphere that perfectly complements their unique milkshake offerings. I indulged in their signature avocado milkshake, a refreshing blend that beautifully balances creamy richness with a hint of sweetness. The texture was luxuriously thick, while the avocado added a delightful twist. It's safe to say, this is not your average shake.

The staff’s enthusiasm was infectious, making the visit all the more enjoyable. If you’re on the hunt for a distinctive and refreshing treat, Caraotas should definitely be on your list of must-visit spots in Brooklyn!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Tipsy Scoop

At Tipsy Scoop, the moment I took a sip of their tantalizing boozy milkshake, I was whisked away to dessert paradise! Their unique concoctions, like the Cake Batter Vodka Milkshake, balance sweetness with the perfect kick. The creamy texture was divine, with every swirl inviting me to indulge. I especially adored the playful toppings—a delightful cherry on top of a magic moment! With its whimsical atmosphere and creative flavors, Tipsy Scoop stands out as a must-visit for any milkshake aficionado in Brooklyn. This spot proves that a touch of spirited fun can elevate a classic treat to new heights!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Thick

At Thick, the name says it all—this milkshake destination lives up to its reputation with shakes that are an indulgent celebration of flavor. I sampled the Salted Caramel Pretzel, and let me tell you, it was like a party on my taste buds. The smooth sweetness balanced perfectly with a rich, salty kick. Each sip was adorned with crunchy pretzel bits, adding a delightful texture. The atmosphere buzzed with energy, making it a perfect spot for both families and milkshake aficionados. If you're in the area, make Thick a must-try; it’s truly a creamy masterpiece you won't want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.