The Absolute Best Cheesecake in Brooklyn [Updated 2024]

I have personally tasted and reviewed a whopping 12 cheesecakes across the borough, leaving no crumb unturned in my quest for the perfect slice. And let me tell you, Brooklyn does not disappoint when it comes to this delectable dessert.

From traditional New York style to innovative and adventurous flavors, the cheesecake scene here is a tantalizing treat for your taste buds. So buckle up and get ready to embark on a cheesecake journey like no other.

Whether you're a local or visiting this vibrant city, this article will be your go-to resource for the creamy, indulgent goodness that is the best cheesecake in Brooklyn.

Aunt Butchie's Desserts

Highlights
Never a bad bite
Equally delicious
Fresh and tasty
Not crazy sweet
Authentic taste

Upon entering Aunt Butchie's Desserts, I was greeted by the delightful aroma of freshly baked treats. The display case was lined with an array of vibrant cheesecakes, each one enticing me with their creamy goodness. With so many options to choose from, I couldn't resist ordering a slice of their classic New York-style cheesecake.

As I took my first bite, I was immediately struck by the perfect balance of flavors. The creamy richness of the cheesecake was complemented by a subtle tanginess that danced on my taste buds. It was evident that Aunt Butchie's uses only the finest ingredients, as the cheesecake had a freshness that spoke volumes.

What truly impressed me about Aunt Butchie's Desserts was the consistency in quality. With each visit, I've found that their cheesecakes are never a bad bite. From the classic plain to the creatively flavored varieties, each cheesecake was equally delicious. Whether it was the delectable Chocolate Swirl or the refreshing Lemon Blueberry, I couldn't help but savor every mouthful.

One thing that sets Aunt Butchie's apart from other cheesecake establishments is that their cheesecakes are not crazy sweet. It's clear that they prioritize the authenticity of the flavors, letting the natural sweetness of the creamy cheesecake shine through. This made each bite a delightfully balanced experience, never overwhelming my taste buds.

In conclusion, Aunt Butchie's Desserts in Brooklyn consistently delivers fresh and tasty cheesecakes that are a true testament to their commitment to quality. Their cheesecakes have an authentic taste that is not overly sweet, making them a standout among the competition. Whether you're a cheesecake connoisseur or simply enjoy a good slice of dessert, Aunt Butchie's is a must-visit destination.

You might also want to check out the best cheesecake in Queens.

Circo's Pastry Shop

Highlights
Authentic Italian
Amazing service
Mouth-watering selection
Moist tricolor pastries

From the moment I stepped into Circo's Pastry Shop, I knew I was in for a treat. This cozy little bakery exuded an authentic Italian charm that was simply irresistible. The staff greeted me with warm smiles and provided amazing service that made me feel like a valued customer.

Now, let's talk about the cheesecake. Oh, the cheesecake! Circo's offers a mouth-watering selection that caters to every cheesecake lover's dream. From traditional New York style to innovative flavors like raspberry swirl and salted caramel, they have it all. Each slice was generously portioned, ensuring that every bite was a heavenly experience.

But what truly set Circo's apart was their tricolor pastries. I couldn't resist ordering one alongside my cheesecake, and I'm so glad I did. As I sank my teeth into the moist pastry, the flavors exploded in my mouth. The combination of chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry was a match made in dessert heaven.

Not only was the cheesecake and pastry exceptional, but the atmosphere of the bakery made the whole experience even more delightful. The gentle Italian music playing in the background coupled with the inviting aroma of baked goods created a truly enchanting ambiance.

In conclusion, Circo's Pastry Shop in Brooklyn is a must-visit for any cheesecake enthusiast. Their authentic Italian charm, amazing service, and mouth-watering selection of cheesecakes and tricolor pastries made my taste buds dance with joy. Don't miss the opportunity to indulge in their delectable creations - you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best cheesecake in Long Island.

Bay Ridge Bakery

Highlights
Friendly bakery
Great eats and sweets
Birthday cake vibes
Not too sweet chocolate cake
Perfect texture and filling

Walking into Bay Ridge Bakery, I was immediately greeted with friendly smiles from the staff. The cozy atmosphere gave me a feeling of comfort and warmth, like stepping into a beloved family kitchen.

As I approached the display case, my eyes were delighted by an array of great eats and sweets. But, let's get back to the cheesecake. After all, that's what I was here for.

I ordered a slice of their famous cheesecake, and let me tell you, this cake had birthday cake vibes. The presentation was Instagram-worthy, with a beautifully swirled design on top that teased my taste buds.

The first bite was a revelation. The flavor was spot-on, not overpoweringly sweet but still satisfyingly indulgent. The not too sweet chocolate cake base perfectly complemented the creamy filling.

But what truly set this cheesecake apart was its texture. It was a velvety masterpiece, striking that delicate balance between dense and airy. Each bite was a symphony of smoothness and richness.

I couldn't help but savor each mouthful, letting the creamy goodness melt on my tongue. It was like biting into a cloud in cheesecake form.

In conclusion, Bay Ridge Bakery's cheesecake is a perfect harmony of flavor, texture, and presentation. If you're looking for the best cheesecake in Brooklyn, this is definitely a place that should be on your radar.

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Manhattan.

Brooklyn Cupcake

Brooklyn Cupcake in Brooklyn is a delightful cheesecake destination. With their playful flavors and impeccable presentation, they take cheesecake to a whole new level. From the classic New York style to their exotic creations like Salted Caramel Pretzel, each bite is an explosion of flavor. Trust me, this spot is a must-visit for all cheesecake enthusiasts!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Junior's Restaurant & Bakery

I can confidently say that Junior's is a cheesecake wonderland. From the moment you step inside, the aromas tickle your taste buds, and the beautiful array of cheesecakes will make any dessert lover weak in the knees. The velvety smoothness of their classic New York cheesecake is absolutely divine, and their creative flavors like red velvet and cookies and cream are like a party in your mouth. The service is friendly and efficient, making the whole experience even more enjoyable. If you're on the hunt for the ultimate cheesecake in Brooklyn, look no further than Junior's Restaurant & Bakery.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Famous Desserts by The Cheesecake Factory

I visited Famous Desserts by The Cheesecake Factory in Brooklyn as part of my quest to find the best cheesecake in the borough. The experience was nothing short of delightful. The rich and creamy cheesecake melted in my mouth, while the crust provided the perfect amount of crunch. It was truly a cheesecake lover's dream.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Cheesecake Diva Dessert l Delicious Pastries, Freshly Made Coffee & Catering

Let me tell you, this place is a cheesecake paradise! The moment I stepped in, the aroma of freshly baked pastries seduced my senses. I tried their classic New York-style cheesecake and it was a divine experience. The creamy texture and rich flavor left me in cheesecake heaven. Pair it with their freshly brewed coffee for a perfect match made in dessert heaven. Cheesecake Diva definitely lives up to its name, offering a truly delicious and indulgent cheesecake experience.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Mia's Brooklyn Bakery

I'm here to dish out the scoop on the best cheesecake in Brooklyn. So naturally, I made my way to Mia's Brooklyn Bakery for a taste test. Let's just say they had me at the first heavenly bite. This place is the real cheesecake deal.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Martha's Country Bakery

With their irresistible selection of cheesecakes, Martha's Country Bakery takes the crown as the cheesecake connoisseur of Brooklyn. Each slice is a delicate balance of creamy heaven and a buttery crust, leaving you in a state of pure dessert bliss. Indulgence at its finest!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Patisserie Tomoko

In search of the ultimate cheesecake, my taste buds led me to the charming Patisserie Tomoko, nestled in the heart of Brooklyn. Wowzers! This cozy bakery boasts an array of traditional and innovative flavors. Their cheesecake, delicate yet rich, earns them a spot in Brooklyn's cheesecake hall of fame. Add Patisserie Tomoko to your must-try list pronto!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Pasticceria Monteleone BK

Pasticceria Monteleone BK in Brooklyn is a delightful little bakery that serves some of the most scrumptious cheesecakes I've ever tasted! The creamy texture and velvety-smooth consistency of their cheesecakes are simply to die for. Each bite is a divine experience that will transport you straight to cheesecake heaven. Take my word for it, this place is a must-visit for any cheesecake aficionado in Brooklyn!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Cousin John's Cafe & Bakery

Let me tell you, this place is a cheesecake lover's paradise! The moment I stepped in, the sweet aroma of freshly baked goods enveloped me. I knew I was in for a treat.

Their cheesecake selection is impressive! From classic New York style to unique flavors like salted caramel and raspberry swirl, Cousin John's has it all.

But let's talk about the taste. Oh boy! Each bite was pure heaven. The velvety smooth texture melted in my mouth, and the creamy richness of the cheesecake was absolutely divine.

The crust was perfectly crisp and added a delightful contrast to the luscious filling. It was obvious that Cousin John's takes pride in their craft, as each slice was beautifully presented.

The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, happily answering my cheesecake-related questions. The ambiance was cozy, making it the perfect spot to indulge in a slice of heaven.

Overall, Cousin John's Cafe & Bakery is a top contender for the best cheesecake in Brooklyn. So, if you're craving a slice of cheesecake perfection, head over to Cousin John's and treat yourself to a truly delightful experience. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.