The Absolute Best Cheesecake in Long Island [Updated 2024]

After reviewing 12 different cheesecake establishments across Long Island, I am confident in my ability to help you indulge in the most divine and delectable cheesecakes this island has to offer. From velvety smooth texture to mouthwatering flavors, this guide will navigate you through the hidden gems and well-known favorites, allowing you to savor every decadent bite.

Whether you prefer a classic New York-style cheesecake or crave adventurous and unique flavor combinations, my expertise will ensure that you find the perfect slice of cheesecake heaven. So sit back, relax, and let me be your trusted companion on this delicious journey through Long Island's cheesecake paradise.

Whistle Stop Desserts

Highlights
Large selection
Friendly service
Outstanding cake
Incredible service
Delicious cakes

As soon as I walked into Whistle Stop Desserts, I was greeted by a warm and friendly server with a smile that could light up a room. The large selection of cheesecakes immediately caught my eye, and I couldn't wait to dive into this cheesecake paradise.

After much contemplation, I finally settled on a slice of their classic New York-style cheesecake. And let me tell you, it was a slice of heaven on a plate. The texture was unbelievably creamy, with the perfect balance of richness and lightness. Each bite was like a velvety smooth embrace for my taste buds.

But it wasn't just the outstanding cake that impressed me – the incredible service added the cherry on top of the cheesecake. The attentive staff at Whistle Stop Desserts truly went above and beyond to ensure that I had the best dining experience possible. From their knowledgeable recommendations to their prompt and friendly service, they made me feel like a valued customer.

I can confidently say that Whistle Stop Desserts knows how to deliver on taste and customer satisfaction. This hidden gem in Long Island deserves its spot on the list of the best cheesecakes in town. If you're a cheesecake enthusiast like me, make sure to pay a visit to Whistle Stop Desserts for a slice of deliciousness that will leave you wanting more.

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Manhattan.

Saint Honore Pastry Shop

Highlights
Exceeded expectations
Delightful explosion of flavors
Beautifully crafted cakes
Fair pricing
Unique designs and custom cakes

Let me start by saying that Saint Honore Pastry Shop has truly exceeded my expectations when it comes to cheesecakes in Long Island. From the moment I walked into their charming shop, I could feel the anticipation building.

The first bite of their cheesecake was a delightful explosion of flavors dancing on my taste buds. The texture was smooth and creamy, just as a perfect cheesecake should be. The cheesecake was beautifully crafted, with each slice being a work of art in itself. The presentation alone made it difficult for me to take my first bite, as I didn't want to ruin such a masterpiece.

What sets Saint Honore Pastry Shop apart from other places is their commitment to fair pricing. For the quality of their cheesecakes, you would expect a hefty price tag, but that's not the case here. They offer cheesecakes that are affordable without compromising on taste or quality.

Moreover, their unique designs and option for custom cakes make Saint Honore Pastry Shop a go-to choice for any occasion. Whether you're looking for a classic New York-style cheesecake or a specialty flavor, they have something for everyone.

Overall, my visit to Saint Honore Pastry Shop was a true treat for my taste buds. Their cheesecakes are a must-try for any cheesecake enthusiast in Long Island. I highly recommend giving them a visit and experiencing their delightful creations for yourself.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Audrey's Fine Baked Goods

Highlights
Delicious wedding cake
Wide variety of flavors
Fluffy and moist cake
Easy to work with
Highly recommended by guests

I must say, Audrey's Fine Baked Goods truly takes the cake, or should I say, the cheesecake! This charming bakery exceeded my expectations, leaving me with a heavenly taste in my mouth.

First off, let's talk flavors. Audrey's offers a wide variety of cheesecake flavors that cater to every palate. From classic New York style cheesecake to innovative and indulgent options like salted caramel and raspberry swirl, there's something for everyone. It's like a cheesecake lover's dream come true!

Now, let me tell you about the texture. Their cheesecakes are exceptionally fluffy and moist, unlike any other I've tasted. Each bite is a melt-in-your-mouth sensation that sends your taste buds tingling with delight. You can tell that Audrey's takes great care in crafting their cheesecakes to perfection.

What impressed me the most, however, was the exceptional customer service. The staff at Audrey's were a pleasure to work with – friendly, attentive, and happy to assist with any queries. They made the whole experience a breeze, delivering top-notch service from start to finish.

But don't just take my word for it. The guest consensus at Audrey's speaks for itself. It comes highly recommended by satisfied customers who couldn't stop raving about their cheesecakes. From weddings to casual get-togethers, Audrey's Fine Baked Goods has achieved a reputation for creating cheesecakes that are truly unforgettable.

If you find yourself in Long Island craving a slice of cheesecake heaven, don't hesitate to visit Audrey's Fine Baked Goods. With their delectable flavors, impeccable texture, and delightful customer service, it's no wonder they're a top contender for the title of the best cheesecake in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Sweet Surrender Bake House

At Sweet Surrender Bake House, I embarked on a sweet journey to cheesecake paradise. Each bite of their heavenly creation was like a buttery dream. The velvety smoothness and perfectly balanced flavors left me in a state of pure cheesecake bliss. It's safe to say, this place has earned its spot in the Long Island cheesecake hall of fame.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

The French Workshop

The French Workshop in Long Island is a hidden gem, crafting heavenly cheesecakes that will transport your taste buds to Paris. With a delicate balance of creaminess and tanginess, their cheesecakes are a work of art. The velvety smooth texture is perfectly complemented by the buttery graham cracker crust. It's a cheesecake fit for kings and queens!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

The Cheesecake Factory

The Cheesecake Factory in Long Island is a cheesecake haven bursting with decadent and mouthwatering options. From classic New York style to creative flavors like salted caramel and red velvet, their creamy and rich cheesecakes are the stuff of dreams. With a menu as extensive as their cheesecake selection, this delightful spot is a must-visit for any dessert lover in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

the cheesecake spot

Hey cheesecake enthusiasts! As a self-proclaimed cheesecake connoisseur, I recently embarked on a mouthwatering journey to find the best cheesecake spot in Long Island. Let me tell you, the search was worth every single calorie! One place that stood out as a showstopper was the cheesecake spot in Long Island. This delightful gem truly made me question if I had died and gone to cheesecake heaven. The creamy, velvety texture of the cheesecake was impeccable and to-die-for. Each heavenly bite left me craving for more, with flavors ranging from classic New York to innovative creations like salted caramel cookie and strawberry shortcake. The presentation was equally impressive, as each slice was a work of art. Whether you're a cheesecake aficionado or a casual dessert lover, the cheesecake spot will surely leave you in awe!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Cascon Cheesecake

Cascon Cheesecake in Long Island is a sensation for cheesecake lovers! Their divine creations are a melting delight that I can't resist. From the first bite, the creamy texture envelops your taste buds, while the flavors explode like a party in your mouth. Trust me, you won't regret indulging in this heavenly treat!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Buttercooky Bakery & Café

Buttercooky Bakery & Café in Long Island is a delightful spot for cheesecake lovers. With a vast selection of flavors and a creamy texture that melts in your mouth, their cheesecakes are a must-try. The service is exceptional too, making the experience all the more enjoyable. Don't miss out on this gem!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

La Cheesecake Bake Shop

I have to say, the cheesecake at La Cheesecake Bake Shop is like a fluffy cloud of pure delight. The crust is velvety and the filling is creamy and decadent. Each bite is a taste explosion that will make your taste buds dance with joy. Definitely a must-try for any cheesecake lover in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Jonathan Lord Cheesecakes & Desserts

Jonathan Lord Cheesecakes & Desserts in Long Island is a cheesecake haven that will make your taste buds jump with joy! The decadent flavors and creamy textures are out of this world. Make sure to try their signature options - each bite is a little slice of heaven.

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Sugar Bae Cafe

Sugar Bae Cafe in Long Island is a delightful little spot serving up some seriously divine cheesecake. Their slices are perfectly creamy, with just the right amount of sweetness. Each bite is like a little taste of cheesy heaven. Don't miss out on this sweet gem!