The Absolute Best Toy Store in Brooklyn [Updated 2025]

As I wandered through the eclectic streets of Brooklyn, each corner revealing hidden gems, I couldn’t help but dive deep into the world of toys. After reviewing 12 top locations, I can confidently say that there’s something enchanting about a store that captures the imagination of both kids and adults alike.

Whether you’re hunting for that perfect birthday gift or just looking to relive your childhood, I’ve scoured every nook and cranny to bring you the inside scoop. Trust me—my passion for playtime has led me to some incredible finds, and I can’t wait to share them with you. Get ready to rediscover the joy of toys in the heart of Brooklyn!

FAO Schwarz

Highlights
World of wonder and nostalgia
Enchanting selection of toys
Friendly and enthusiastic staff
Iconic giant piano attraction
Great stop for travelers

Review of FAO Schwarz in Brooklyn

Walking into FAO Schwarz in Brooklyn felt like stepping into a magical realm where childhood dreams come to life. This store is a world of wonder and nostalgia, filled with an enchanting selection of toys that capture the imagination. From plush toys to intricate puzzles, there’s something for every little explorer.

What truly sets FAO Schwarz apart is its friendly and enthusiastic staff who seem to embody the spirit of playfulness. They’re always ready to help you find that perfect gift or engage in a lively conversation about the latest trends in toys. Their passion is infectious!

One of the highlights of my visit was the iconic giant piano that beckons children and adults alike to tap their toes and create joyful music. It's impossible not to smile while dancing on those keys!

Whether you're a local or just passing through, this shop is a great stop for travelers seeking a unique experience or a memorable gift. The magic of FAO Schwarz transcends generations, making it a must-visit destination for anyone looking to relive the joy of play. If you’re in Brooklyn, this toy wonderland is not to be missed!

You might also want to check out the best views in NYC.

Toys 2 Discover Boro Park

Walking into Toys 2 Discover Boro Park felt like stepping into a whimsical wonderland! The shelves are brimming with vibrant toys that ignite curiosity for all ages. I was particularly charmed by their unusual selection of educational games—perfect for sparking creativity in children. The staff are genuinely friendly, always ready with recommendations that make shopping a delightful experience. I also appreciated the inviting atmosphere, adorned with playful decor. Overall, this store is a gem for every parent and child alike, making it a top contender in Brooklyn's vibrant toy scene. A must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in NYC.

Double Play Toys

Double Play Toys instantly transported me to a world of wonder! Nestled in a charming corner of Brooklyn, this delightful store is a treasure trove of creativity and fun. With its vibrant displays of unique toys and games, both classic and contemporary, I felt like a kid again. The knowledgeable staff exuded warmth and enthusiasm, ready to help customers find the perfect gift. Their selection promotes imaginative play, making it a stellar destination for families. If you're looking for a place that ignites joy and engages minds, I wholeheartedly recommend Double Play Toys—it's nothing short of a playful paradise!

You might also want to check out the best irish pubs in NYC.

Toys 4 U

Walking into Toys 4 U feels like stepping into a wonderland of imagination! From the moment I entered, a delightful array of toys greeted me, sparking joy and nostalgia. The staff was incredibly knowledgeable and eager to help find the perfect gift. Their selection ranges from classic board games to the latest action figures, ensuring there’s something for every child—and kid at heart. The vibrant atmosphere, paired with cozy nooks for exploration, makes it a must-visit destination. If you’re searching for that special something, Toys 4 U is undoubtedly one of Brooklyn's best toy treasures!

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.

Mini Jake

Stepping into Mini Jake is like entering a whimsical wonderland! From the moment you walk through the door, you're greeted by vibrant displays of toys that spark nostalgia and excitement. This cozy shop is brimming with unique finds—from classic games to innovative gadgets. The knowledgeable staff was wonderfully helpful, guiding me to hidden gems perfect for any young adventurer. What truly sets Mini Jake apart is its commitment to quality and creativity, making it an essential stop for families. If you’re in search of something special, this is the place where playtime dreams come to life! 🎈

You might also want to check out the best shopping in Brooklyn.

Greenpoint Toys

Stepping into Greenpoint Toys felt like entering a magical wonderland! The vibrant displays are bursting with creativity, showcasing a delightful mix of classic and contemporary toys. I particularly loved their selection of handcrafted items, which added a unique touch to every corner. The staff is genuinely passionate and eager to help, making the shopping experience enjoyable for both kids and adults. With a cozy atmosphere and a focus on quality, this little gem truly stands out in Brooklyn's vibrant toy scene. If you're seeking a place where imagination thrives, Greenpoint Toys is a must-visit destination!

You might also want to check out the best law firms in NYC.

Mary Arnold Toys

Stepping into Mary Arnold Toys feels like entering a whimsical wonderland! Their carefully curated selection ranges from classic wooden toys to the latest must-have gadgets, ensuring hours of imaginative play. The knowledgeable staff is always ready to help, and their enthusiasm is infectious. I was particularly charmed by the unique, handcrafted items that add a special touch to any toy collection. The warm, inviting atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for parents and children alike. If you're looking for a toy store that balances nostalgia with innovation, Mary Arnold Toys is an absolute gem in Brooklyn!

You might also want to check out the best libraries in NYC.

myplasticheart

Stepping into myplasticheart is like diving into a vibrant world of whimsical wonders! This store is a delightful treasure trove, showcasing an impressive collection of designer toys and unique collectibles that instantly ignite nostalgia. The eclectic mix ranges from quirky plushies to stunning art figures, all thoughtfully curated. The staff is incredibly knowledgeable, ready to share stories behind the creations. It's not just a store; it’s an experience that sparks creativity and imagination. If you’re searching for that perfect gift or a unique addition to your collection, myplasticheart is a must-visit destination in Brooklyn!

You might also want to check out the best lawyers in NYC.

Toys 4 U Local

Toys 4 U Local is an absolute gem in the heart of Brooklyn! As soon as I stepped inside, I was delighted by the whimsical atmosphere, filled with every toy imaginable. Their selection ranges from classic board games to the latest high-tech gadgets, ensuring there's something for everyone. The knowledgeable staff were eager to help, offering personalized recommendations that made my visit even more enjoyable. I particularly loved their section dedicated to sustainable toys, showcasing eco-friendly options that parents can feel good about. If you're searching for a place where imagination meets quality, Toys 4 U Local is a must-visit destination!

You might also want to check out the best parks in Brooklyn.

Little Things Toy Store

Stepping into Little Things Toy Store is like diving into a treasure chest of childhood wonder! The delightful ambiance is filled with whimsical decor and shelves brimming with unique toys that spark imagination. From classic board games to eco-friendly crafts, there’s a little something for everyone. The staff are incredibly friendly, eager to assist and share recommendations. I especially loved their curated selection of educational toys that make learning fun. If you’re on the hunt for a memorable gift or just want to indulge your inner child, Little Things is the perfect destination in Brooklyn’s vibrant toy scene!

You might also want to check out the best bookstore in NYC.

INFINI1 STORE LLC

Stepping into INFINI1 STORE LLC felt like entering a whimsical wonderland! The vibrant displays of toys sparkled with joy and nostalgia. From classic board games to the latest action figures, their selection caters to every age and interest, making it a treasure trove for both kids and adults alike. The staff, knowledgeable and friendly, are eager to help find that perfect gift. I was particularly charmed by the unique, locally crafted items — a beautiful touch! If you're looking for a blend of fun and quality, INFINI1 STORE LLC is certainly a top contender in Brooklyn's toy scene!

You might also want to check out the best acai bowls in NYC.

Kingston Toys & Stationery

Stepping into Kingston Toys & Stationery felt like entering a whimsical wonderland! The vibrant displays were bursting with charm, showcasing an eclectic mix of classic games, STEM toys, and artsy supplies that spark imagination. The friendly staff were genuinely enthusiastic, ready to offer personalized recommendations. I adored their selection of unique, hard-to-find treasures that cater to all ages. Plus, the cozy atmosphere made it a delightful spot for both kids and parents. If you’re searching for a toy store that ignites creativity and joy, Kingston Toys is truly a gem in Brooklyn’s playful landscape!

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Manhattan.