The Absolute Best Haunted Houses in Long Island [Updated 2024]

With a total of 12 haunted houses reviewed, Long Island offers a diverse range of spooky experiences for thrill-seekers and horror enthusiasts alike. From chilling narratives to spine-tingling scares, these haunted houses are guaranteed to send shivers down your spine.

As a Long Island native, I have had the pleasure of exploring these haunted attractions firsthand, allowing me to provide you with an accurate and comprehensive breakdown of each one. Whether you're seeking a classic haunted house experience or something uniquely terrifying, Long Island has got you covered.

So, strap in and prepare yourself for a hair-raising journey through the best haunted houses that this remarkable island has to offer.

Gateway's Haunted Playhouse

Highlights
Guest services
Great set up
Impressive actors
Amazing experience
Good scare

Upon arriving at Gateway's Haunted Playhouse, I was immediately impressed with their excellent guest services. The staff was friendly and efficient, ensuring a smooth and enjoyable experience right from the start.

The set up of the haunted house was truly remarkable. From the moment I entered, I was transported into a world of terror and suspense. The attention to detail in each room and corridor was evident, creating an immersive and spooky atmosphere that kept me on edge throughout the entire experience.

What truly set Gateway's Haunted Playhouse apart were the actors. Their performances were nothing short of impressive. Each actor fully embraced their character, delivering spine-chilling performances that added an extra layer of intensity to the haunted house. They were skilled at timing their scares perfectly, making my heart race with every unexpected encounter.

My visit to Gateway's Haunted Playhouse was an amazing experience overall. The combination of the top-notch set design, talented actors, and excellent guest services created the perfect recipe for a memorable haunted house adventure.

I have to admit, I'm a self-proclaimed horror aficionado, but Gateway's Haunted Playhouse managed to give me quite a good scare. The unexpected twists and turns, combined with the overwhelming sense of anticipation, made for a truly exhilarating experience.

If you're in search of an unforgettable haunted house experience in Long Island, I highly recommend checking out Gateway's Haunted Playhouse. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best views in NYC.

Darkside Haunted House Darkside Productions Inc

Highlights
Amazing time
Attention to detail
Best haunted house
Split between outside and inside

Walking through the doors of Darkside Haunted House, I knew I was in for an amazing time. From the moment I entered, I was engulfed in a world of fright and excitement.

What sets Darkside apart is their impeccable attention to detail. Every corner I turned, I was greeted with terrifying scenes and intricate displays. The set design was so realistic that at times I found it hard to distinguish between what was real and what was part of the haunted house.

The scares at Darkside were unlike anything I have experienced before. They managed to strike the perfect balance between thrilling and terrifying, keeping me on my toes throughout the entire journey. The actors were top-notch, fully committing to their roles and creating an atmosphere of fear that was palpable.

One of the things that impressed me the most about Darkside is the way they seamlessly transition between the indoor and outdoor sections. Just when I thought I had reached the safety of the indoors, I was jolted back to terror as I stepped outside into the chilling night air.

In conclusion, Darkside Haunted House is undoubtedly the best haunted house in Long Island. The attention to detail, the amazing scares, and the perfect blend of indoor and outdoor experiences solidified its position as a must-visit for any thrill-seeker. I highly recommend Darkside for a heart-pounding, unforgettable Halloween experience.

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in NYC.

Halloween House Long Island

Highlights
Fun and interactive
Great for all ages
Family-friendly
Memorable

Let me start by saying, wow! Halloween House Long Island has truly exceeded my expectations. From the moment I stepped foot inside, I knew I was in for an unforgettable experience.

One of the highlights of this haunted house is how fun and interactive it is. The actors were fully committed to their roles, delivering bone-chilling scares around every corner. But what really set this haunted house apart was the way they engaged with the visitors. It was like being a part of a horror film, where you get to interact with the characters and play a role in the scare. I found myself on the edge of my seat, eagerly awaiting the next terrifying encounter.

What I loved most about Halloween House Long Island is that it caters to all ages. It strikes the perfect balance between being spooky enough to satisfy thrill-seekers while remaining family-friendly. It's a great option for families with children who want to participate in the Halloween festivities without being too scared.

This haunted house delivered a memorable experience that I won't soon forget. The attention to detail in the set design, the realistic costumes, and the immersive storyline created an atmosphere that truly felt like stepping into another world.

Overall, I highly recommend Halloween House Long Island to anyone looking for a top-notch haunted house experience. Whether you're an adrenaline junkie or simply want a scare your whole family can enjoy, this is the place to be.

You might also want to check out the best irish pubs in NYC.

Darkness Rising | Haunted House Long Island

Prepare to have your bones chilled and your screams echoed at Darkness Rising | Haunted House Long Island in Long Island. This terror-filled journey through labyrinthine corridors and sinister rooms will leave you breathless. Don't miss the spine-tingling scares that await at this top-notch haunted house. It's a must-visit for thrill-seekers in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.

Chambers Of Hell

Chambers Of Hell in Long Island is a haunting experience like no other! The moment you step foot inside, your heart pounds like a drum and your senses are on high alert. The chilling atmosphere combined with the terrifying actors creates a horror extravaganza that will leave you screaming for more. Be prepared to be pushed to your limits in this spine-chilling haunted house. Don't miss out on this bone-chilling adventure!

You might also want to check out the best law firms in NYC.

A Haunting In Hollis

I must say, A Haunting In Hollis is a spook-tacular haunted house that truly lives up to its frightful reputation. With bone-chilling scenes, heart-stopping scares and a cast of ghoulish characters, it's a paranormal playground like no other in Long Island. Brace yourself for a hair-raising adventure!

You might also want to check out the best libraries in NYC.

Haunted Hallways

Haunted Hallways in Long Island is the epitome of a bone-chilling haunted house. From the moment you step inside, the creepy ambiance sends shivers down your spine. The hair-raising costumes and realistic props create a stunning illusion of terror. Prepare to scream your heart out at Haunted Hallways!

You might also want to check out the best lawyers in NYC.

BAYVILLE SCREAM PARK

Buckle up, folks! I found myself immersed in a spine-chilling adventure at BAYVILLE SCREAM PARK, Long Island's hidden gem of terror. Nestled amongst eerie forests and foggy paths, this haunted house extravaganza is a scream-fest like no other. Be prepared to be frightened beyond belief as you navigate through the twisted corridors and encounter ghoulish creatures lurking in the shadows. With top-notch special effects and heart-pounding scares, BAYVILLE SCREAM PARK is a must-visit for all you horror aficionados out there.

You might also want to check out the best parks in Brooklyn.

Spooky Walk

Spooky Walk in Long Island is a spine-tingling delight! With its dark and mysterious atmosphere, it truly lives up to its name. The terrifying actors and realistic props make for an exhilarating and haunting experience. If you're looking for a hair-raising adventure, Spooky Walk is the place for you!

You might also want to check out the best bookstore in NYC.

Dark Night Halloween Trail - Long Island

Let me tell you, this place gave me chills in all the right ways! Dark Night Halloween Trail - Long Island is definitely a must-visit for thrill-seekers. From the spooky forest to the bone-chilling screams, every corner sent shivers down my spine. The attention to detail and the creepy characters lurking in the shadows were top-notch. I would highly recommend taking a trip to Dark Night Halloween Trail - Long Island if you're in for a frightfully good time!

You might also want to check out the best acai bowls in NYC.

Yaphank Trail of Terror

Oh boy, did Yaphank Trail of Terror tickle my horror-loving heart! 🎃 This haunted house in Long Island was a spine-chilling delight from start to finish. From the moment I stepped foot on the creepy trail, I knew I was in for a frightful treat. The attention to detail in the scares was absolutely hauntingly impressive. Make sure you don't wander in alone - bring a friend to hide behind. The actors were terrifyingly convincing, with their blood-curdling screams and eerie movements. The suspenseful ambiance in each scene had me jumping out of my skin, and the special effects were to die for. The engaging storyline made the experience even more immersive, leaving me on the edge of my seat. The Yaphank Trail of Terror definitely deserves a spot on the list of the best haunted houses in Long Island. If you're looking for a night of thrilling frights, this is the place to be.

Deepwells Farm Historical Society

Deepwells Farm Historical Society in Long Island was an unforgettable haunt! The atmosphere was electrifying, with eerie whispers echoing through the century-old halls. The actors were so convincing, I nearly jumped out of my skin! Get ready for a thrilling and historical scare at Deepwells Farm!