The Absolute Best Irish Pubs in NYC [Updated 2024]

With a city as vibrant and diverse as New York, it's no surprise that the Irish pub scene is alive and thriving. As a proud native of this magnificent city, and someone who can't resist a good pint of Guinness, I have made it my mission to explore and review the plethora of Irish pubs that grace the streets of NYC.

After numerous visits and countless pints, I am excited to share with you the top 12 Irish pubs that have truly captured the essence of Ireland right here in the heart of the Big Apple. So sit back, grab a pint, and let's dive into the best Irish pubs that NYC has to offer!

Paddy Reilly's Music Bar

Highlights
Friendly staff
Live music
Affordable drinks
Pool & Darts
Excellent ambiance

Walking into Paddy Reilly's Music Bar, I instantly felt transported to the lively streets of Dublin. The warm and welcoming atmosphere immediately embraced me, as did the friendly staff who greeted me with smiles and Irish charm.

The sound of traditional Irish music filled the air as a live band took the stage, setting the perfect backdrop for a memorable night. The live music at Paddy Reilly's was top-notch, featuring talented musicians who flawlessly played traditional tunes that got everyone tapping their feet and dancing along.

But it wasn't just the music that impressed me. Paddy Reilly's also boasted an impressive selection of affordable drinks, making it a popular spot for both locals and visitors alike to unwind and have a great time. Whether you fancy a pint of Guinness or an Irish whiskey, their well-stocked bar had something to suit every taste.

For those looking for some entertainment beyond the music, Paddy Reilly's had a great surprise in store. With pool tables and dartboards scattered around, patrons could engage in friendly competition while enjoying their drinks. It added an extra layer of fun to the already vibrant atmosphere.

Speaking of the atmosphere, it was excellent. The cozy wooden interior, adorned with traditional Irish memorabilia, exuded an authentic Irish pub feel. It felt like stepping into a time capsule that preserved the spirit of a true Irish establishment.

Overall, my visit to Paddy Reilly's Music Bar was a delightful experience. From the lively music to the friendly staff and affordable drinks, it encapsulated everything that makes an Irish pub truly exceptional. Whether you're seeking a pint with friends or a taste of Ireland in the heart of NYC, Paddy Reilly's is a must-visit for anyone looking for an Irish pub experience done right.

You might also want to check out the best irish pubs in Manhattan.

Peter McManus Cafe

Highlights
Perfect Pub environment
Good chicken tenders
Quick meetups or long hangs
Good burger
Large bar area
Cooked how it was ordered
Nice and crispy tots
Guinness, grab a bite

Peter McManus Cafe is the epitome of what you would expect from an authentic Irish pub. As soon as I stepped through the door, I was transported to the streets of Dublin. From the perfect pub environment to the large bar area, this place screams Irish charm.

Upon sitting down, I couldn't resist ordering their highly recommended chicken tenders. Let me tell you, they did not disappoint. The tenders were cooked to perfection, tender on the inside and crispy on the outside. It was like biting into a piece of golden heaven.

If you're looking for a spot for quick meetups or long hangs, Peter McManus Cafe has got you covered. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, making it the ideal place to catch up with friends over a pint of Guinness or grab a bite to eat.

Speaking of bites, their burger was another highlight of my evening. Juicy and flavorful, it was cooked exactly how I ordered it. And what's a burger without some nice and crispy tots on the side? Trust me, they nailed it.

Whether you're in the mood for a Guinness and some classic pub grub, or just want to enjoy the company of friends in a lively atmosphere, Peter McManus Cafe has it all. It's safe to say that it definitely deserves a spot on the list of the best Irish pubs in NYC. Cheers!

You might also want to check out the best views in NYC.

Rosie Dunn's Victorian Pub

Highlights
Great Irish food
Friendly staff
Excellent cocktails
Lively crowd

Walking into Rosie Dunn's Victorian Pub, I was immediately transported to the Emerald Isle. The warm and cozy atmosphere, complete with dark wooden furniture and traditional Irish decor, set the perfect backdrop for a night of fun and revelry.

As a self-proclaimed foodie, I was pleased to discover that Rosie Dunn's offers a wide selection of great Irish food. From hearty shepherd's pie to perfectly cooked fish and chips, their menu had something to satisfy even the pickiest of taste buds. My taste buds were in heaven as I relished every bite of their delectable Irish fare.

To top off a fantastic culinary experience, the friendly staff at Rosie Dunn's were attentive and knowledgeable. They were more than happy to recommend their favorite dishes and pairings, ensuring that every customer had a truly personalized dining experience.

But Rosie Dunn's isn't just about the food - their excellent cocktails deserve a special mention. The bartenders here are true mixologists, crafting unique and flavorful drinks that perfectly complemented the Irish theme. I highly recommend trying their Irish coffee, a luscious combination of smooth whisky and rich, velvety coffee.

Of course, no Irish pub is complete without a lively crowd, and Rosie Dunn's certainly delivered on that front. Whether it was a rowdy group of friends celebrating a birthday or a couple enjoying a romantic night out, the atmosphere was always buzzing with energy. It's the kind of place where you can easily strike up a conversation with the person next to you at the bar, creating a sense of community and camaraderie.

In conclusion, Rosie Dunn's Victorian Pub truly stands out as one of the best Irish pubs in NYC. With its great Irish food, friendly staff, excellent cocktails, and lively crowd, it's a must-visit for anyone looking to experience the charm and spirit of an authentic Irish pub right here in the heart of the city.

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in NYC.

Connolly's

I must say, Connolly's is a hidden gem among the bustling streets of New York City. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with the warmest Irish hospitality that made me feel like I had been transported across the pond. The authentic Irish atmosphere was second to none, with cozy wooden interiors, traditional music playing in the background, and the constant flow of friendly conversations filling the air.

As I perused the menu, my taste buds danced with anticipation. Connolly's boasts an impressive array of classic Irish dishes, and I couldn't resist indulging in some shepherd's pie, which was a true delight for my palate. The Guinness flowed freely, and the bartenders poured the perfect pint with masterful precision.

One thing that truly stood out was the live music performances. Connolly's hosts talented local musicians who play traditional Irish tunes, creating an enchanting ambiance that is hard to find elsewhere. The energy in the room was electric, and I couldn't help but tap my foot along with the rhythms.

The staff at Connolly's were the epitome of Irish charm. Their friendly nature and attentive service truly enhanced my experience, making me feel like an old friend rather than just a guest. Their knowledge of Irish culture and their willingness to share stories only added to the overall magic of the place.

Overall, Connolly's is a must-visit for anyone searching for an authentic Irish pub experience in the heart of NYC. The combination of cozy atmosphere, delicious food, lively music, and welcoming staff is a recipe for an unforgettable night. Whether you're Irish or not, you'll leave Connolly's with a newfound appreciation for all things Irish.

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.

McGee's Pub

McGee's Pub in NYC is an overflowing pot of Irish charm. From the moment you step in, you're greeted with warm smiles and a lively atmosphere. The cozy space, adorned with Gaelic memorabilia, transports you to the Emerald Isle. Their hearty food and impressive beer selection complete the experience. Sláinte!

You might also want to check out the best law firms in NYC.

Playwright Celtic Pub

Playwright Celtic Pub in NYC is a delightful haven of Irish charm. Stepping inside feels like being transported to the Emerald Isle itself. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff immediately make you feel at home. The menu boasts classic Irish dishes with a modern twist, and the drink selection is truly impressive - from perfectly poured pints of Guinness to a wide variety of Irish whiskeys. The live music adds an extra layer of authenticity, making you want to raise your glass and join in the merriment. Don't miss a visit to this gem when searching for the best Irish pubs in NYC.

You might also want to check out the best libraries in NYC.

Gabby O'Haras

After spending an evening at Gabby O'Haras, I can confidently say that it's a true gem among NYC's Irish pubs. The lively atmosphere, friendly staff, and authentic Irish fare made me feel like I was transported straight to the Emerald Isle. Cheers to Gabby O'Haras!

You might also want to check out the best lawyers in NYC.

Malachy's Irish Pub

Malachy's Irish Pub in NYC is an absolutely delightful spot for anyone seeking an authentic Irish pub experience. The cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and diverse drink selection make it a top contender among the best Irish pubs in the city. Don't miss their mouthwatering fish and chips!

You might also want to check out the best parks in Brooklyn.

McCarthy's Pub NYC

McCarthy's Pub NYC is an authentic gem nestled in the heart of NYC. From its cosy atmosphere to the friendly staff, it's a perfect spot to unwind and relish in a pint of Guinness. Oh, the live Irish music will transport you straight to the Emerald Isle. A true Irish pub experience!

You might also want to check out the best bookstore in NYC.

St. James Gate

St. James Gate in NYC is a charming irish pub that will transport you straight to the Emerald Isle. From the friendly staff to the authentic decor, this pub is a delightful spot to grab a pint and mingle with fellow Irish enthusiasts. Don't miss their mouthwatering shepherd's pie, it's simply heavenly. Cheers!

You might also want to check out the best acai bowls in NYC.

Mulligan's Pub

Mulligan's Pub in NYC is a charming and cozy spot that captures the authentic spirit of Irish pubs. The atmosphere is lively, with friendly staff and an impressive selection of beers on tap. The traditional Irish fare, like the perfectly cooked fish and chips, will leave you wanting more. Sláinte!

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Manhattan.

The Landmark Tavern

The Landmark Tavern in NYC is a hidden gem that transports you to the heart of Ireland with its authentic decor and cozy atmosphere. The friendly staff and lively Irish spirit create the perfect setting for an unforgettable night of pints, laughter, and traditional Irish music. Sláinte!