Long Island's Best Steak House [Updated 2024]

After carefully reviewing 12 steak houses across Long Island, I have narrowed down the top contender that surpasses all expectations. Prepare your taste buds for an unforgettable culinary journey as we delve into the world of juicy, tender steak.

Long Island boasts a remarkable dining scene, but only one establishment truly stood out from the rest. From the sizzling ambiance to the exceptional service, this hidden gem has undoubtedly earned its spot at the forefront.

So sit back, relax, and let me guide you to the best steak house in Long Island, where meat lovers' dreams come true.

Jake's Steakhouse

Highlights
Marinated skirt steak
Service
Covid safety
Cocktails

As soon as I walked through the doors of Jake's Steakhouse, I could instantly sense the inviting aroma of sizzling steaks on the grill. It was a promising start to my quest for the best steak house in Long Island.

The menu at Jake's featured a variety of delectable cuts, but one highlight truly stole the show – the marinated skirt steak. Tender, juicy, and bursting with flavor, it was a carnivore's dream come true. Each bite transported me to a steak paradise, where the meat melted in my mouth and left me craving for more.

Not only were the steaks exceptional, but the service at Jake's was top-notch. The staff was attentive and knowledgeable, offering expert recommendations and ensuring that every aspect of our dining experience was impeccable. Their passion for the art of steak cooking was evident in their genuine enthusiasm and dedication to customer satisfaction.

In these uncertain times, Jake's commitment to Covid safety was also commendable. The restaurant followed strict protocols, with spaced-out tables, hand sanitizing stations, and attentive staff wearing masks. I felt safe and comfortable throughout my visit, allowing me to fully indulge in the steakhouse experience.

To complete my meal, I couldn't resist sampling their cocktails. Each drink was expertly crafted, blending unique flavors that perfectly complemented the richness of the steaks. From classic favorites to inventive concoctions, the cocktail menu at Jake's had something to satisfy every palate.

Overall, Jake's Steakhouse in Long Island is a standout contender in the race for the title of the best steak house. With its unparalleled marinated skirt steak, outstanding service, commitment to Covid safety, and delightful cocktail selection, it truly exceeded my expectations. If you're craving a memorable steakhouse experience, make sure to visit Jake's – you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Tellers: An American Chophouse

Highlights
Pristine food
Excellent service
Beautiful restaurant
Regal ambiance
Lunch special is a great deal

Walking into Tellers, I immediately noticed the regal ambiance of the restaurant. The beautiful decor and upscale atmosphere set the stage for an extraordinary dining experience. As I sat down, I couldn't help but admire the sleek and stylish interior.

The moment I took my first bite, I knew I was in for a treat. The pristine food at Tellers left me speechless. Each bite of my perfectly cooked steak was bursting with flavor, and the quality of the ingredients was evident. The menu offered a wide variety of cuts and cooking styles, ensuring there's something to satisfy every palate.

The excellent service at Tellers further enhanced my dining experience. The staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and went the extra mile to ensure that each guest felt welcomed and comfortable. From the moment I walked in to the moment I left, their professionalism and genuine warmth made me feel like a valued customer.

Tellers not only excelled in its culinary offerings and service, but the restaurant itself was simply stunning. The spacious dining area, stylish furnishings, and dimly lit ambiance created a beautiful setting for a memorable meal. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for an upscale dining experience, Tellers delivers in both aesthetics and culinary expertise.

Finally, if you're looking for a great deal, don't miss out on their lunch special. It's a fantastic opportunity to indulge in their delicious steaks at a more affordable price.

In conclusion, Tellers: An American Chophouse is truly a gem in Long Island's steakhouse scene. With its combination of pristine food, excellent service, and beautiful restaurant, it stands out as one of the best steak houses in the area. If you're a steak lover seeking an unforgettable dining experience, this is the place to be.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Peter Luger Steak House

Highlights
No leftovers
Wonderful, iconic steakhouse
Perfectly prepared steak
Awesome Sundae
Cash or debit only

Walking into Peter Luger Steak House, I couldn't help but feel a sense of anticipation. This place is nothing short of iconic, and I had high hopes for a truly memorable steakhouse experience. Let me tell you, I was not disappointed.

From the moment I sat down, it was clear that this was not going to be your average dinner. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with dark wood paneling and cozy booths that exuded old-world charm. I knew I was in for something special.

And oh boy, was I right. The steak at Peter Luger is nothing short of perfection. Cooked to absolute perfection, each bite was a symphony of flavors. The meat was juicy, tender, and full of that mouthwatering charred crust that every steak lover dreams of. No leftovers here!

But it wasn't just the steak that stole the show. I simply had to indulge in one of their famous Sundaes. And let me tell you, it was absolutely awesome. From the creamy vanilla ice cream to the rich hot fudge and the crunchy nuts, it was a dessert fit for a carnivorous king.

Now, I must mention one important thing: cash or debit only. So make sure you come prepared if you want to indulge in this steakhouse extravaganza.

In the end, my experience at Peter Luger Steak House was everything I hoped for and more. A true gem among Long Island's steak houses. Its wonderful, iconic ambiance, perfectly prepared steaks, and that unforgettable sundae create a dining experience that is simply unmatched. It's safe to say that Peter Luger is a must-visit for steak enthusiasts looking for the best Long Island has to offer.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Ruth's Chris Steak House

Ruth's Chris Steak House in Long Island is a carnivore's paradise that tickled my taste buds with its succulent, juicy steaks. The warm ambiance added a touch of elegance to the experience. It's no wonder this gem is a strong contender for the title of the best steak house in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Blackstone Steakhouse

Blackstone Steakhouse in Long Island surpassed my wildest steak dreams. The succulent cuts were cooked to perfection and the atmosphere was simply divine. If you're looking for the best steak house in Long Island, look no further, Blackstone is where it's at!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Fogo de Chão Brazilian Steakhouse

Fogo de Chão Brazilian Steakhouse in Long Island truly knows how to grill some mouthwatering steaks. Their gauchos carve juicy cuts of meat right at your table, and the endless parade of sizzling skewers is enough to make any meat lover weak in the knees. It's a carnivore's dream come true!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

The Capital Grille

Hold on to your steak knives because The Capital Grille in Long Island takes the concept of a steakhouse to a whole new level. From the moment I walked through the door, I knew I was in for a culinary adventure. The elegant atmosphere combined with the impeccable service set the stage for a memorable dining experience. But let's get to the main event – the steak. Wow! This place knows how to grill a mean steak. The cuts were juicy, tender, and cooked to perfection. I opted for a ribeye and it was out of this world, melting in my mouth with every glorious bite. And the flavor...oh, the flavor! It was like a symphony of savory notes dancing on my taste buds. The menu at The Capital Grille offers a range of steak options to please any carnivore, and the sides were equally impressive. The lobster mac and cheese was a decadent delight, and the truffle fries were the crispy embodiment of pure indulgence. To top it all off, the dessert menu was a temptation I couldn't resist. The creme brulee was like a little slice of heaven. All in all, The Capital Grille gets my vote as one of the best steak houses in Long Island. It's a dining experience that will leave you savoring every bite and craving more. So go ahead, treat yourself to a tantalizing steak at The Capital Grille – you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Frank's Steaks

Frank's Steaks in Long Island is a diamond in the rough. With mouthwatering steaks cooked to perfection and top-notch service, it's clear why it's a contender for the best steak house in Long Island. Don't miss their succulent ribeye - it's a true delight.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Majors Steak House

Majors Steak House in Long Island is a carnivore's paradise! The perfectly charred exterior and melt-in-your-mouth texture of their steaks left me speechless. Juicy doesn't even begin to describe the explosion of flavors that burst in every bite. With impeccable service and a cozy ambience, this is definitely a steak lover's haven.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Texas Roadhouse

Texas Roadhouse in Long Island is a lively and down-home steak house that brings a touch of southern charm to the island. The service is friendly and the steaks are cooked to perfection. Be sure to try their famous fall-off-the-bone ribs for a finger-licking good time!

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Uncle Jack's

Uncle Jack's in Long Island is a steak lover's dream come true. From the moment I walked in, the aroma of perfectly seared beef filled the air. The succulent and tender cuts of meat were cooked to absolute perfection. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, with attentive and knowledgeable staff. This place definitely deserves a spot on the list of the best steak houses in Long Island!

Jimmy Hays Steak House

Jimmy Hays Steak House in Long Island is an absolute gem! The ambiance is cozy, the service is top-notch, and the steaks? Oh, my taste buds! Tender, juicy, and bursting with flavor. It's a carnivore's dream come true. Don't skip the creamy garlic mashed potatoes either. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!