NYC's Best Shakes [Updated 2024]

After reviewing an impressive number of 12 shakes from various establishments across the vibrant city, I can confidently lead you on a mouthwatering journey through the top-notch shake scene that NYC has to offer. From classic chocolate to unconventional flavors that push the boundaries of taste, prepare to indulge in the most delectable concoctions that will leave you wanting more.

Whether you prefer a creamy, velvety consistency or crave a thick, icy texture, this comprehensive guide will ensure that you never settle for a mediocre shake experience again. So buckle up, shake enthusiasts, and get ready to discover the crème de la crème of NYC's liquid delights!

Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - SoHo

Highlights
Friendly staff
Delicious Greg Norman
Mega shake
Mind blowing food
Amazing Oreo Crazy Shake

Walking into Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - SoHo, I was immediately greeted by the friendly staff, who eagerly awaited to take my order. With my heart set on trying their famous shakes, I decided to go all out and order their mouthwatering Greg Norman shake. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint.

This mega shake was a towering masterpiece of creamy goodness. The blend of vanilla ice cream, milk, and sweet housemade whipped cream was a symphony for my taste buds. Topped with a slice of key lime pie and a generous dollop of whipped cream, every sip was a delight.

As I sipped on my shake, I couldn't help but notice the mind-blowing food being served to the surrounding tables. The burgers were thick and juicy, and the smell alone was enough to make my mouth water. The atmosphere was bustling, and the energy was infectious.

But let's not forget the star of the show, the Oreo Crazy Shake. As I watched it pass by me on its way to another lucky customer, I couldn't help but admire its sheer beauty. Garnished with a mountain of whipped cream, colorful sprinkles, and a whole Oreo cookie, this shake was a work of art.

In conclusion, my visit to Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - SoHo was a delightful experience. The friendly staff, delicious shakes, and mind-blowing food made it a memorable stop on my quest to find the best shakes in NYC. I highly recommend giving Black Tap a visit for an experience that will leave you wanting more.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Queens.

Harlem Shake

Highlights
Unique jerk fries
Jazz event
Delicious burger and fries
Well-cooked food
Satisfying meal

From the moment I walked into Harlem Shake, I was greeted with a vibrant atmosphere that perfectly captured the essence of this iconic neighborhood. The place was buzzing with energy, and I could feel a sense of community in the air.

But let's talk about the real star of the show - the shakes. Harlem Shake definitely lives up to its reputation as one of the top spots for milkshakes in NYC. The menu boasts an impressive range of flavors, from classic favorites like vanilla and chocolate to unique creations like Nutella Crunch and Red Velvet. Each shake is made with care and attention to detail, resulting in a rich and creamy concoction that is simply irresistible.

While the shakes are undeniably the main draw, Harlem Shake goes above and beyond to offer a complete dining experience. I couldn't resist trying their famous jerk fries, and boy, was I in for a treat. These fries were a perfect balance of spicy and savory, and the jerk seasoning added a unique twist that left me craving more.

To top it off, the restaurant often hosts live jazz events, adding a touch of sophistication to the lively atmosphere. It was a sheer delight to sip on my shake while tapping my foot to the smooth sounds of a live band.

I must also mention that the service was impeccable. The staff at Harlem Shake were friendly, efficient, and eager to make sure I had a memorable dining experience.

Overall, my visit to Harlem Shake was nothing short of delightful. The delicious burger, the well-cooked food, and the satisfying milkshakes made it well worth the trip. Whether you're in the mood for a quick shake or a full meal, Harlem Shake is a must-visit destination that will leave you wanting more.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Queens.

Creamline

Highlights
Sweet potato fries
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Expensive
Seasonal spiked Peppermint shake
Hospitable Owner/manager Nick

Let me start by saying that Creamline has some truly unique highlights. While their sweet potato fries and Buffalo Chicken Sandwich might not exactly fall under the category of shakes, they are worth mentioning for their exceptional taste. However, I must admit that the prices at Creamline can be quite expensive.

When it comes to their shakes, Creamline knows how to get creative with flavors. During my visit, I had the pleasure of trying their Seasonal spiked Peppermint shake. Let me just say, the combination of refreshing peppermint and a little kick of booze made for an incredibly delicious treat.

But what truly sets Creamline apart is their hospitable owner/manager Nick. He made sure everyone in the restaurant felt like a welcomed guest, going out of his way to answer questions and suggest menu items. His passion for creating the best dining experience showed and added a personal touch to the visit.

Creamline may not have an extensive shake menu, but they make up for it with their unique flavors and exceptional customer service. It's the kind of place where you can indulge yourself and enjoy a delightful shake while enjoying a warm, friendly atmosphere. Just keep in mind that it might be a bit hard on the wallet. So, if you're in NYC and looking to treat yourself to a playful and flavorful shake experience, Creamline is definitely worth a visit.

You might also want to check out the best seafood tower in NYC.

Ray's Candy Store

Ray's Candy Store was an absolute delight! From the moment I stepped inside, the funky atmosphere and mouthwatering aroma overwhelmed me. Their shakes are out of this world, rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor. Ray's Candy Store is a must-visit for any shake enthusiast in NYC.

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Manhattan.

ShakeTop Milkshakes

Hey there shake enthusiasts! You won't believe the incredible milkshakes I discovered at ShakeTop Milkshakes in the heart of NYC. These magical concoctions take shake-making to a whole new level. From classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla to mind-blowing creations topped with marshmallows, cookies, and even glitter, ShakeTop Milkshakes truly delivers on taste and presentation. Whether you're craving a decadent treat or a whimsical dessert, this place has got you covered. Don't miss out on these shake wonders, my fellow milkshake aficionados!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Long Island.

Shake Shack Madison Square Park

Shake Shack Madison Square Park in NYC is a playground of deliciousness for shake lovers. With their creamy and rich shakes, this place is a total game changer. The milkshakes are so decadent that they transport you to a sweet oasis. It's the perfect spot to satisfy your shake cravings.

You might also want to check out the best asian food in Brooklyn.

Shake Shack Theater District

I must say, Shake Shack Theater District is a delightful spot to indulge in a stellar shake. The menu boasts a sensational selection of flavors, from classics like chocolate and vanilla to more adventurous options like salted caramel pretzel. The shakes are impeccably crafted, with a creamy texture and perfect balance of sweetness. The service is excellent, with friendly staff ready to assist. Overall, it's a must-visit for any shake lover in NYC.

You might also want to check out the best asian food in Manhattan.

Shake Shack Midtown East

Shake Shack Midtown East is a delightful little haven tucked away in the heart of NYC. Their shakes are the epitome of creamy goodness. From classic flavors to inventive combinations, each sip is like a sweet symphony playing on your taste buds. Don't miss the chance to indulge in these scrumptious shakes. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best soul food in Queens.

Shake Shack Herald Square

Shake Shack Herald Square is a must-visit for any shake enthusiast in NYC. This trendy spot combines playful flavors with a professional touch. The shakes are a delightful blend of creamy perfection and inventive toppings. Be sure to try their salted caramel pretzel shake for a mind-blowing experience.

You might also want to check out the best cajun food in NYC.

Shake Shack Astor Place

Shake Shack Astor Place in NYC is a decadent delight for shake enthusiasts. The creamy texture and perfect balance of flavors in their shakes are a true treat for the taste buds. With a playful menu offering classics and innovative options, this spot is a must-visit for any shake lover in the city.

You might also want to check out the best places to read in NYC.

Lilly's Shakes & Crepes

Lilly's Shakes & Crepes is a hidden gem for shake enthusiasts in NYC. Their shakes are decadent and creamy, with flavors ranging from classic chocolate to exotic matcha. The presentation is Instagram-worthy and the staff is delightful. Don't miss out on this shake paradise!

You might also want to check out the best places to write in NYC.

Lily’s Shakes & Crepes

Oh, what a delight it was to step into Lily's Shakes & Crepes in NYC! Their shakes were heavenly and their crepes were divine. A playful yet professional atmosphere, this spot is a must-visit for any shake enthusiast in the city.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.