NYC for Thanksgiving's Best Restaurants [Updated 2025]

Trust me, navigating the culinary landscape of New York City during Thanksgiving can feel like an epic quest. With so many options, it's easy to get overwhelmed! But after tasting my way through 12 incredible spots, I’m here to serve you the juicy deets on where to feast this holiday. Each restaurant has its own unique flair, from rustic charm to modern elegance, making them perfect for a memorable celebration.

Why listen to me? Well, I’ve spent years exploring the city’s diverse dining scene, always on the hunt for those hidden gems and beloved classics. So whether you're a local or just visiting, I’ve got the inside scoop to help you find the perfect place to enjoy turkey, stuffing, and all the fixings without the stress of cooking. Let’s dig in!

Carriage House NYC

Highlights
Filipino inspired New American
Friendly yet distracted service
Delicious mains and drinks
Cool dinner experience
Excellent management and bartender

Thanksgiving at Carriage House NYC: A Delightful Culinary Journey

This Thanksgiving, I found myself at Carriage House NYC, an upscale eatery that artfully blends Filipino influences with New American cuisine. Entering the restaurant felt like stepping into a comfortable embrace, with a welcoming atmosphere and thoughtful decor setting the stage for our feast.

The menu is a feast for the senses! I was captivated by the delicious mains that featured an inventive twist on classic Thanksgiving dishes. The succulent turkey, infused with unique spices, danced on my palate, while a vibrant medley of sides incorporated the best of both cultures. Each bite was a delightful surprise, inviting me to savor the flavors and textures; I truly appreciated the culinary creativity.

While the staff was friendly, there were moments of distraction during the meal, but I found it charming rather than off-putting. The excellent management and exceptionally knowledgeable bartender quickly turned any fumble into a fun interaction, adding to the evening’s lighthearted spirit.

In conclusion, Carriage House NYC delivered a Thanksgiving dinner that was both delightful and memorable—an experience I wholeheartedly recommend for anyone looking to celebrate the holiday in a new and exciting way!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Brooklyn.

RH Rooftop Restaurant at RH New York

Perched high above the bustling city, RH Rooftop Restaurant offers a breathtaking ambiance that elevates your Thanksgiving feast to new heights. The menu boasts a traditional turkey dinner with all the trimmings, and each bite is a delightful homage to the holiday. The sweeping views of the skyline framed by a cozy, elegant setting create an unforgettable dining experience. The attentive staff ensures you feel cherished as you savor your meal. Dining here is not just about the food; it's about the memorable moments spent in a stunning atmosphere. This is a perfect spot to celebrate gratitude with style!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

The Modern

The Modern offers a stunning Thanksgiving experience that marries art and culinary excellence. Nestled within the Museum of Modern Art, this restaurant presents a breathtaking view that heightens the festive atmosphere. The Thanksgiving prix fixe menu features a sumptuous roasted turkey, complemented by seasonal sides like truffled mashed potatoes and cranberry chutney, all elevated with a creative twist. Each dish is a masterpiece, thoughtfully crafted to delight your palate. The attentive staff ensures an unforgettable dining experience that feels both sophisticated and warm. If you’re seeking a unique twist on the holiday classic, The Modern is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Queens.

Boucherie West Village

Stepping into Boucherie West Village feels like a warm embrace on Thanksgiving. Their French-inspired feast dazzles with a succulent turkey served alongside rich, buttery gratin and tangy cranberry chutney. The ambiance blends rustic charm with a touch of elegance, making it perfect for holiday gatherings. I particularly loved their seasonal cocktails, which added a festive twist to the meal. The staff was incredibly attentive, ensuring each moment felt special. If you're seeking a delightful escape this Thanksgiving, Boucherie is a must-visit culinary haven that will leave you feeling grateful and satisfied. Truly a gourmet experience amidst the bustle of NYC!

You might also want to check out the best cakes in NYC.

Hearth

Hearth offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels like a cozy holiday gathering at home. Their Thanksgiving menu is a delightful twist on tradition, featuring a succulent roasted turkey served with house-made cornbread stuffing and cranberry relish. The seasonal sides—like creamy mashed potatoes and roasted Brussels sprouts—perfectly complement the main dish. Each bite is a celebration of flavors that speaks to the heart of autumn. With its attentive staff and charming decor, Hearth transforms a typical Thanksgiving into a memorable feast. For a nourishing experience, this gem deserves a top spot on your holiday dining list.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

COTE Korean Steakhouse

Nestled in the heart of the city, COTE Korean Steakhouse offers a Thanksgiving feast that marries tradition with a unique twist. The moment you step in, the vibrant atmosphere envelops you, promising a memorable meal. I indulged in their special holiday menu featuring sizzling Korean BBQ alongside turkey-inspired dishes—a delightful fusion! The high-quality cuts of beef, grilled tableside, make for an interactive experience, while the flavorful sides elevate the meal to new heights. Dinner here is not just a meal; it's a celebration of flavor and culture. For an unforgettable holiday, COTE is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Gramercy Tavern

This Thanksgiving, Gramercy Tavern delighted my palate with an exquisite seasonal feast. The ambiance effortlessly combines elegance and warmth, making it the perfect spot for holiday dining. I savored a succulent turkey, perfectly complemented by house-made cranberry sauce and velvety mashed potatoes. The thoughtful array of sides, like roasted Brussels sprouts, added a delightful twist. Don't forget dessert—its pumpkin pie was a heavenly finale! The attentive staff made me feel like family, adding to the overall charm. For a memorable Thanksgiving experience in the heart of NYC, Gramercy Tavern is truly a culinary gem not to be missed!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Manhatta

Nestled high above the bustling streets of Manhattan, Manhatta redefines the Thanksgiving experience. The sweeping views of the skyline set the stage for a feast that is as breathtaking as the scenery. The seasonal menu boasts traditional favorites with a sophisticated twist, featuring a succulent herb-roasted turkey paired with rich sides like truffled mashed potatoes and cider-glazed yams. The cozy ambiance combined with exceptional service made me feel right at home. Ending with a heavenly pumpkin tart was the cherry on top of this unforgettable day. Manhatta truly captures the spirit of togetherness—perfect for celebrating the holiday!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Manhattan.

Le Bernardin

Le Bernardin transforms Thanksgiving into a culinary masterpiece, blending tradition with unparalleled sophistication. The four-course prix fixe menu dazzled my taste buds—each dish was a celebration of seafood, reflecting chef Éric Ripert’s exquisite touch. The butter-poached lobster was particularly memorable, evoking flavors that danced on the palate, while the autumn-themed desserts crowned the meal with elegance. The ambiance is serene, perfect for a festive gathering, yet intimate enough for a romantic dinner. To dine here is to indulge in the poetry of food, making Le Bernardin a top contender for an unforgettable Thanksgiving celebration in NYC.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Long Island City.

The Milling Room

The Milling Room offers a delightful twist on Thanksgiving with its charming ambiance and thoughtful menu. The roast turkey is the star of the show, succulent and paired perfectly with a rich cranberry sauce. Their seasonal sides, like the truffle-infused mashed potatoes, elevate the traditional feast to new heights. The staff exudes warmth, making you feel right at home. End your meal with their pumpkin pie, which is simply divine! In every corner, you’ll find a blend of rustic elegance and gourmet flair, making it one of my top picks for a memorable Thanksgiving in NYC. 🦃✨

You might also want to check out the best italian food in NYC.

Boucherie Union Square

I recently dined at Boucherie Union Square for Thanksgiving, and what a delightful feast it was! Nestled in the heart of NYC, this charming French-inspired bistro offers a rapturous holiday experience. The turkey was beautifully roasted, infused with robust herbs, and served alongside creamy mashed potatoes and savory stuffing that had my taste buds dancing. The warm, inviting ambiance perfectly complemented the rich flavors of the meal. And let’s not forget the decadent pumpkin pie—truly the cherry on top! If you’re seeking a memorable Thanksgiving celebration with a French twist, Boucherie is a culinary gem not to miss!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Market Table

This Thanksgiving at Market Table was nothing short of a culinary delight! The warm, inviting atmosphere set the perfect stage for their seasonally-inspired feast. I savored the roasted turkey, which was succulent and glazed with an aromatic herb butter. The accompanying sides—think creamy mashed potatoes and tangy cranberry relish—were bursting with flavor. Not to mention, the pumpkin pie was a heavenly conclusion! The staff was attentive yet unobtrusive, adding to the cozy vibe. If you’re craving a festive twist on a classic dinner, Market Table is a top-notch choice this holiday season. Cheers to great food and good company!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.