Long Island to Celebrate a Birthday's Best Restaurants [Updated 2025]

Whether you’re craving a cozy spot for an intimate gathering or a lively venue to party the night away, I’ve reviewed 12 top locations that promise to make your birthday celebration unforgettable. As someone who has tasted the flavors and soaked in the vibes of Long Island’s culinary scene, I know how vital it is to find that perfect place where the food dazzles and the atmosphere sparkles.

Trust me, I’ve scoured every corner, from hidden gems to popular hotspots, to bring you the best of the best. So, if you want to elevate your birthday festivities this year, buckle up—this journey through Long Island’s culinary delights will have your taste buds tingling and your heart racing with excitement!

Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar

Highlights
Beautiful waterfront view
Top-notch steak and food
Attentive and friendly service
Special occasion dining
Great prix fixe menu options

Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar is an absolute gem to consider for a birthday celebration! Nestled right by the water, the beautiful waterfront view sets the perfect scene for an unforgettable evening. As soon as I entered, the ambiance embraced me with warmth and elegance, making it distinctly ideal for special occasions.

The menu offers an impressive selection of sumptuous dishes, but I was particularly enchanted by their top-notch steaks, which practically melt in your mouth. Each bite is seasoned to perfection, elevating the entire dining experience. For those who appreciate variety, they also feature great prix fixe menu options that cater to different tastes, making it easy to indulge without breaking the bank.

What truly sets Prime apart is the attentive and friendly service. Because it’s a special occasion, I felt valued as a guest—something that should never be overlooked when celebrating. The staff went above and beyond to ensure that every detail was perfect. From the delectable food to the splendid service, celebrating a birthday at Prime is not just a meal; it's a memorable experience. If you’re looking to celebrate life’s moments, this is spot on!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

OHK Bar & Restaurant

Highlights
Excellent food and dessert
Spectacular views and grounds
Friendly and nice staff
Great for large affairs
Clean facilities

OHK Bar & Restaurant truly stands out as a remarkable venue for celebrating a birthday on Long Island. As soon as I arrived, I was greeted by the breathtaking views of the surrounding landscape, which perfectly complements the elegant ambiance of the restaurant. The outdoor seating area is especially charming, making it an ideal choice for those wanting to bask in the beauty of nature while enjoying their meal.

The service was nothing short of excellent, with the staff being exceptionally friendly and attentive, ensuring that we felt special throughout our visit. When it came to the menu, I was thoroughly impressed by the diverse selection of dishes. Each plate was crafted with creativity and passion, and the desserts? Oh my! They were absolutely divine, offering a sweet conclusion to our celebration.

Whether you're planning a small gathering or a larger affair, OHK is equipped to accommodate you in style. The clean facilities only add to the comfort of the dining experience. If you're searching for an unforgettable place to celebrate a birthday, look no further than this gem on Long Island! It's a perfect blend of fun, elegance, and delightful cuisine.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Crabtree's Restaurant

Highlights
Cozy, homey atmosphere
Lively and welcoming staff
Fresh and well-seasoned food
Indoor and outdoor dining options
Accommodating and attentive service

Crabtree's Restaurant offers an inviting atmosphere that feels like a warm embrace, making it perfect for celebrating a birthday. As I stepped inside, I was immediately struck by its cozy, homey vibe. The lively ambiance, paired with a welcoming staff, set the stage for a memorable evening.

The centerpiece of any birthday celebration is, of course, the food. At Crabtree's, each dish is a celebration of fresh ingredients and well-seasoned flavors. I indulged in a delightful seafood entree that was not only beautifully presented but also bursting with taste. Sharing delectable mains with friends around the table simply enhanced the overall joy of the occasion.

What I appreciated most was the attentive service; the staff went above and beyond to accommodate my group and made us feel special throughout the meal. Whether dining inside or choosing the charming outdoor seating, the experience felt exclusive yet comfortable.

Crabtree's Restaurant truly elevates the concept of a birthday celebration, making it a top choice on Long Island. With delicious food, delightful service, and an inviting atmosphere, it's clear that memories made here are meant to be cherished and celebrated!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Gatsby's Landing

Highlights
Contemporary tavern atmosphere
Delicious prix fixe lunch
Beautiful outdoor seating
Attentive and friendly service
Housemade dessert offerings

Gatsby's Landing: A Birthday Celebration to Remember

When planning a birthday celebration, Gatsby's Landing in Long Island is a hidden gem that truly shines. As I stepped into this contemporary tavern, I was immediately enveloped by its vibrant yet cozy atmosphere. The décor strikes a perfect balance between modern elegance and casual warmth, setting the stage for a joyful gathering.

Opting for their delicious prix fixe lunch, I was treated to a feast that combined flavor and art. Each dish was thoughtfully crafted, showcasing seasonal ingredients that tantalized the taste buds. The housemade dessert offerings are not to be missed; they provide the perfect sweet ending to a memorable meal.

One of the standout features of Gatsby's Landing is the beautiful outdoor seating. On a sunny day, dining al fresco adds a lovely touch to any celebration. Throughout my visit, I was impressed by the attentive and friendly service from the staff, who ensured that every guest felt special.

In summary, if you're seeking an ideal venue to celebrate a birthday in Long Island, Gatsby's Landing is a fantastic choice. With delectable cuisine, a charming ambiance, and impeccable service, this restaurant guarantees an unforgettable experience for you and your loved ones. Let the festivities begin!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Blend on the Water

Blend on the Water is a hidden gem for birthday celebrations! Nestled by the waterfront, this enchanting venue pairs stunning views with a vibrant atmosphere. The menu offers a delightful fusion of flavors, from indulgent seafood to mouth-watering steaks, ensuring there's something for everyone. I was particularly impressed by the artfully crafted cocktails, perfect for toasting to another fabulous year! The staff was attentive and genuinely enthusiastic, making our evening even more memorable. If you're seeking a place to celebrate in style, Blend on the Water is truly a wonderful choice for creating unforgettable birthday memories.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Lakehouse

I recently celebrated a birthday at Lakehouse, and it was nothing short of magical! Nestled by the water, this charming restaurant offers a delightful ambiance that perfectly complements any celebration. The seasonal menu burst with flavors, showcasing local ingredients that will tantalize your taste buds. I indulged in their exquisite seafood dishes, and each bite was a revelation. The attentive staff made us feel like royalty, ensuring every detail was just right. With stunning views and a cozy atmosphere, Lakehouse is a top choice for a memorable birthday feast that will leave you craving more! Cheers to another fabulous year!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Maiella

Celebrating a birthday at Maiella was a delightful experience! Nestled in the heart of Long Island, this restaurant offers an irresistible blend of authentic Italian cuisine and a vibrant atmosphere. From the moment we stepped in, the warm, welcoming staff made us feel special. The standout dish was the fresh pasta, bursting with flavors that danced on our palates. To top it off, the stunning views of the waterfront added a magical touch to our celebration. If you’re looking for a place to make memories, Maiella is a fantastic choice for a birthday bash! 🎉✨

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Seasons 52

Seasons 52 is a delightful destination for a birthday celebration! The warm ambiance sets the perfect backdrop for an intimate gathering. I was impressed by their seasonal menu, highlighting fresh ingredients in every dish. The grilled asparagus and filet mignon were standouts, each bite bursting with flavor. To top it all off, the mini indulgences dessert options allowed us to savor several sweet creations without the guilt. The attentive staff ensured our experience was seamless, making this spot a fantastic choice for a memorable birthday dinner. If you’re seeking a blend of taste and atmosphere, Seasons 52 is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Coco Bistro Kitchen & Lounge

Coco Bistro Kitchen & Lounge truly encapsulates the spirit of celebration! The moment I stepped in, the vibrant atmosphere wrapped around me like a cozy hug. Their eclectic menu promises a delightful journey, and I particularly adored the tender braised short ribs—a dish that steals the spotlight! The staff exudes charm and warmth, making every moment feel special. For a birthday bash, it's perfect with their fabulous cocktails and a chic interior. It's not just dining; it’s an experience. If you're seeking a spot to mark your special day, Coco Bistro delivers in style and flavor! 🎉✨

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

LOLA

LOLA is a whimsical gem that transforms any birthday celebration into a delightful affair! From the moment I stepped in, the vibrant ambiance and warm staff made me feel special. The seasonal menu boasts mouthwatering dishes, particularly the lobster mac and cheese—an absolute indulgence! Their signature cocktails are playful and potent, perfect for toasting to another year. The thoughtful décor and cozy vibe create a perfect backdrop for laughter and memories. If you're looking for a place where you can celebrate life with flair, LOLA is an ideal choice that will leave you and your guests smiling long after the candles are blown out!

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

LIMANI

Celebrating a birthday at LIMANI was an absolute delight! With its stunning Mediterranean decor and ocean-inspired ambiance, I immediately felt like I was on a mini-vacation. The mouthwatering seafood was impeccably fresh, and the signature cocktails added a festive touch to our celebration. What truly made the evening memorable was the attentive staff, who went above and beyond to ensure our special day was flawless. The vibrant energy and elegant atmosphere make LIMANI a perfect choice for anyone looking to celebrate in style. If you seek a blend of luxury and fun, this spot should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best hot chocolate in NYC.

eatMOSAIC

eatMOSAIC is a delightful gem on Long Island, perfect for celebrating a birthday! The vibrant atmosphere instantly puts you in a festive mood, while the menu is a mouthwatering tapestry of global flavors. I indulged in their signature dishes, each more tantalizing than the last. The fusion of tastes ignited my palate and sparked conversations among friends. Their cocktail selections are equally impressive and add a playful touch to the celebration. The attentive staff made the evening feel special, ensuring every detail was perfect. For a memorable birthday bash filled with flavor, eatMOSAIC is simply a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best omakase in NYC.