NYC Elementary's Best Private Schools [Updated 2025]

Each of these twelve schools I’ve reviewed has its own unique charm and educational philosophy that sets it apart. As a parent and an avid researcher, I've navigated the bustling corridors of NYC’s private education scene, soaking up everything from innovative curricula to the vibrant school cultures that make these institutions shine.

You can trust my insights because I’ve spoken with parents, visited countless campuses, and immersed myself in the community. Whether you’re looking for a nurturing environment, a strong academic program, or a place that fosters creativity, I’ve got you covered. Let’s dive into the gems of New York City that are shaping the next generation!

Brearley School

Highlights
OH MY GOSH
Highly praised
Outstanding education
Strong community focus

Brearley School truly captivated me during my recent visit, leaving a lasting impression that I felt compelled to share. This private institution is notorious for its outstanding education and commitment to developing well-rounded individuals. From the moment I stepped onto the campus, there was an undeniable sense of community. The students were not only engaged but also enthusiastic, radiating a spirit of curiosity that filled the hallways.

What struck me most was Brearley’s ability to cultivate a nurturing environment. The faculty members were visibly dedicated, fostering a space where every child feels valued. The curriculum is as rich as it is diverse, providing students with a holistic learning experience that emphasizes both academic excellence and social responsibility.

I was particularly impressed by their innovative programs designed to encourage creativity and critical thinking among students. During my tour, I felt as though I was peeking into a world where education goes beyond the textbooks, extending into the realm of personal growth and leadership skills.

In a city brimming with options, Brearley School stands out not only for its commitment to excellence but also for creating a genuinely supportive tapestry of learners. I highly recommend it if you're seeking the best for your child in NYC Elementary.

You might also want to check out the best private schools in Manhattan.

The King's Academy

The King's Academy is a true gem in the heart of NYC Elementary! From the moment I stepped onto the campus, I was captivated by the vibrant and nurturing atmosphere. The dedicated faculty fosters a love of learning, encouraging students to explore their curiosity in innovative ways. The curriculum seamlessly integrates academics with the arts, making education both engaging and dynamic. I was particularly impressed by the emphasis on character development, preparing young minds for future challenges. If you're searching for a school that balances excellence with heart, The King's Academy should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best private schools in Long Island.

The Lang School

Visiting The Lang School was a delightful adventure! This nurturing environment emphasizes creativity and critical thinking, allowing students to thrive academically and socially. I was particularly charmed by their personalized approach, which caters to the unique needs of every child. The enthusiastic teachers radiate passion, fostering a love for learning that feels almost infectious! Their engaging curriculum, combined with a warm, inclusive atmosphere, makes Lang stand out in the NYC landscape. For families seeking a school that values both academic excellence and emotional well-being, The Lang School is definitely a gem worth exploring!

You might also want to check out the best private schools in Queens.

Villa Maria Academy

Nestled in a vibrant neighborhood, Villa Maria Academy truly stands out as a gem in NYC's elementary education scene. From the moment I stepped inside, the warm and welcoming atmosphere enveloped me like a cozy hug. The dedicated staff infuse a sense of joy and curiosity into each lesson, fostering a love for learning among the young scholars. The variety of extracurricular activities, including art and music, adds an exciting spark to the academic experience. With its strong sense of community and commitment to nurturing both mind and spirit, Villa Maria Academy is undoubtedly a top contender for parents seeking an exceptional education for their children.

You might also want to check out the best private school in NYC.

Incarnation School

At Incarnation School, a delightful balance of traditional values and modern education thrives. The small class sizes foster a nurturing atmosphere where each student feels valued. I was enchanted by the warm community spirit; parents and teachers are genuinely invested in children's growth. The curriculum is rich and diverse, encompassing not just academics but also arts and spirituality. It's not just about grades—it's about cultivating well-rounded individuals. I found the facilities to be inviting and well-maintained, providing a perfect backdrop for exploration and learning. Overall, Incarnation is indeed a gem among NYC's private schools!

You might also want to check out the best private school in Brooklyn.

BASIS Independent Manhattan Lower School

At BASIS Independent Manhattan Lower School, learning unfolds like an exciting adventure! The curriculum is rigorous yet engaging, seamlessly blending core subjects with innovative STEAM projects. I was particularly impressed by the enthusiastic teachers, who foster a warm and supportive environment, making every child feel valued. The vibrant classrooms are filled with creativity, and the emphasis on critical thinking is palpable. Plus, the extra-curricular activities are diverse, inviting students to explore their passions beyond academics. Overall, this school truly exemplifies educational excellence in Manhattan! If you're seeking a place where curiosity and growth thrive, BASIS is definitely worth considering!

You might also want to check out the best private elementary schools in Manhattan.

Calhoun School

Calhoun School is a hidden gem nestled in NYC Elementary! From the moment I stepped onto the campus, I was captivated by its vibrant, inclusive atmosphere. The student-centered approach encourages creativity and critical thinking, making learning a joyous adventure. The faculty are not just educators; they are passionate mentors who truly invest in each child’s growth. With a diverse curriculum and an emphasis on social responsibility, Calhoun prepares students for a brighter, more compassionate future. If you’re seeking a school that sparks joy and curiosity, look no further—Calhoun School will surely leave an indelible mark on your child's educational journey!

You might also want to check out the best private elementary schools in Long Island.

Whitestone Academy

I was absolutely charmed by Whitestone Academy, a hidden gem in NYC Elementary! The vibrant classrooms buzz with creativity and curiosity, making learning an adventure. The dedicated faculty truly inspire students, fostering an environment where curiosity thrives. Whitestone’s emphasis on both academic excellence and emotional well-being sets it apart, creating a balanced approach to education. The campus, adorned with lush greenery, offers a picturesque backdrop for outdoor exploration. Overall, Whitestone Academy embodies the perfect blend of nurturing support and engaging curriculum, making it a fantastic choice for parents seeking an exceptional private school experience in NYC!

You might also want to check out the best private elementary schools in Brooklyn.

Marymount School of New York

On my visit to Marymount School of New York, I was welcomed by a vibrant community that truly fosters a love for learning. The campus buzzes with enthusiasm, and I was particularly impressed by the dedicated faculty who nurture each child's unique potential. Their innovative curriculum blends academic rigor with artistic expression, creating a well-rounded educational experience. The emphasis on collaboration and critical thinking skills truly prepares students for future challenges. Plus, the school's commitment to community service instills values that extend beyond the classroom. Overall, Marymount stands out as a gem in NYC Elementary, deserving of its stellar reputation.

You might also want to check out the best spa in NYC.

Spence School

At Spence School, the atmosphere buzzes with creativity and curiosity. The dedicated faculty fosters a nurturing environment where academic rigor harmonizes with artistic expression. I was particularly impressed by their innovative curriculum that challenges young minds while considering their emotional growth. The beautiful campus offers not just state-of-the-art facilities but also a sense of community that feels warm and inviting. Spence truly emphasizes the importance of empowering young girls, with programs that inspire confidence and leadership. In all, it’s a delightful blend of excellence and warmth that makes Spence a standout choice for elementary education in NYC!

You might also want to check out the best private high schools in NYC.

Speyer Legacy School

Stepping into the Speyer Legacy School felt like entering a world where curiosity reigns supreme. The vibrant atmosphere buzzed with engaged students exploring engaging projects and innovative learning methods. I was particularly impressed by their focus on social-emotional development, fostering not just intellect but character. The teachers, brimming with enthusiasm, create a nurturing environment that encourages risk-taking and resilience. With a commitment to diversity and inclusion, Speyer prepares its students for an ever-changing world. If you’re seeking a place where academic rigor meets playful exploration, look no further than Speyer—it's an inspiring choice for young minds!

You might also want to check out the best elementary schools in NYC.

The Hewitt School

I had the delightful opportunity to explore The Hewitt School, and it truly captured my heart! Nestled on the Upper East Side, this all-girls institution boasts a vibrant community that fosters intellectual curiosity and creativity. The classrooms buzz with engaging discussions, and the faculty's passion is infectious. With a strong emphasis on character development, students are encouraged to embrace their individuality while collaborating in a supportive environment. The extensive arts and athletics programs round out a well-balanced curriculum that nurtures the whole child. Hewitt is more than just a school; it’s a haven for empowered and inspired young women!

You might also want to check out the best charter schools in NYC.