Long Island's Best High Schools [Updated 2025]

Having personally reviewed over a dozen high schools on Long Island, I am confident in providing you with a comprehensive list of the top educational institutions in the area. With my deep understanding of what makes a high school exceptional, I have carefully examined each school's academic performance, extracurricular offerings, faculty quality, and student satisfaction.

This article is your go-to resource for finding the perfect high school for your child's educational journey. Whether you prioritize a strong college-prep curriculum, a vibrant arts program, or a nurturing environment, I have got you covered.

Get ready to discover the best high schools that Long Island has to offer!

Herricks High School

Highlights
Incredible school spirit
Great extra curricular activities
Sets you up for success

Walking into Herricks High School, I was immediately hit with a surge of energy. The school spirit was contagious, with students sporting their blue and gold colors and rallying together for various events. The incredible school spirit was definitely one of the highlights of Herricks.

Not only does Herricks High School excel in fostering a spirited atmosphere, but they also offer a wide range of extra-curricular activities. Whether you're interested in arts, sports, or community service, there is something for everyone. From a robust theater program to a competitive sports team, students have plenty of opportunities to explore their passions and develop their skills outside of the classroom.

But what truly sets Herricks High School apart is its commitment to setting students up for success. The dedicated faculty and staff go above and beyond to provide a supportive learning environment. They offer a variety of advanced placement courses and have an outstanding college counseling program that helps students navigate the college application process.

This school is more than just a place of education; it's a community that nurtures personal growth and prepares students for the future. Herricks High School provides an education that extends beyond academics, encouraging students to become well-rounded individuals with a sense of pride in their school community.

Overall, my visit to Herricks High School was a delightful experience. Their incredible school spirit, diverse extra-curricular activities, and commitment to student success make it one of the standout schools in Long Island. If you're looking for a school that combines academic excellence with vibrant school culture, Herricks High School is definitely worth considering.

You might also want to check out the best gyms in Brooklyn.

Catholic High Schools of Long Island

Upon stepping into Catholic High Schools of Long Island in Long Island, I was greeted by a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The academics here are top-notch, with dedicated teachers who go above and beyond. The emphasis on character development is commendable, nurturing well-rounded individuals. The sense of community is palpable, fostering a supportive and inclusive environment. Faith-based education is interwoven into the curriculum, promoting spiritual growth. Overall, Catholic High Schools of Long Island is truly a gem in the education landscape of Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best hair salons in Brooklyn.

John L Miller North High School

John L Miller North High School in Long Island exceeded my expectations! The school boasts an impressive range of extracurricular activities and a dedicated staff that truly goes above and beyond. Plus, the state-of-the-art facilities are jaw-dropping! If you're looking for an exceptional high school experience, North High School is the place to be.

You might also want to check out the best school districts in Long Island.

Long Island City High School

Long Island City High School in Long Island was a thrilling experience, like a roller coaster ride of education! The vibrant atmosphere and dedicated teachers made learning a delight. The school's emphasis on individualized education was evident, enhancing students' skills and passions. If you’re seeking a high school that provides a dynamic and engaging environment, Long Island City High School is a top contender in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best barbers in NYC.

William A. Shine Great Neck South High School

Oh boy, was I impressed! From the moment I stepped onto the campus, I could feel the vibrant energy and sense of community. The academic programs are top-notch, with a wide range of options for all interests. The passionate teachers truly invest in their students' success. And let's not forget about the extracurricular activities—they have something for everyone, from sports to clubs to the arts. Great Neck South High School definitely deserves its spot as one of the best high schools in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best public elementary schools in NYC.

Roslyn High School

Roslyn High School in Long Island is a hidden gem. From their stellar academic programs to the vibrant extracurricular activities, this place has it all. The engaging teachers and supportive staff create a welcoming environment that fosters success. Roslyn High School is definitely in a class of its own!

You might also want to check out the best spa in Long Island.

Manhasset Secondary School

Manhasset Secondary School in Long Island was a delightful surprise. From the moment I walked in, I could feel the energetic atmosphere buzzing with intellectual curiosity. The facilities were top-notch, offering modern technology and spacious classrooms. It's clear that the dedicated teachers at Manhasset Secondary School are passionate about inspiring their students. Plus, the extracurricular activities range from impressive sports teams to vibrant arts programs. Overall, Manhasset Secondary School is a hidden gem in the heart of Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best salons in Brooklyn.

Newcomers High School

Newcomers High School in Long Island is a hidden gem for students seeking an extraordinary education. From the moment I stepped in, the vibrant atmosphere was contagious. The dedicated and passionate teachers make learning an exciting adventure, while the diverse student body fosters a strong sense of community. Newcomers High School truly knows how to create a fun and supportive environment. This place is a treasure!

You might also want to check out the best elementary schools in Brooklyn.

John F. Kennedy High School

Let me tell you, John F. Kennedy High School in Long Island is a delightful blend of playfulness and professionalism! From the moment I stepped foot on their vibrant campus, I was greeted with a contagious energy that made me want to sign up for classes myself. The faculty and staff are dedicated and enthusiastic, always going the extra mile for their students. The curriculum is dynamic and offers a plethora of challenging academic opportunities. Moreover, the extracurricular activities are abundant, allowing students to explore their passions and showcase their talents. From their top-notch sports teams to their award-winning arts programs, John F. Kennedy High School provides a well-rounded educational experience. It's no wonder they are considered one of the best high schools in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best public schools in Brooklyn.

Garden City High School

Garden City High School in Long Island is a hidden gem that combines academic excellence with a fun and welcoming atmosphere. The staff and faculty are top-notch, providing a supportive environment for students to thrive. With impressive extracurricular activities and a beautiful campus, this school is definitely one of the best in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best nail salon in Queens.

Bethpage High School

Bethpage High School in Long Island truly exceeded my expectations. From the moment I stepped through the doors, the vibrant and nurturing environment was palpable. The dedicated faculty, state-of-the-art facilities, and diverse extracurricular activities make this institution a standout among the best high schools in Long Island. Bravo, Bethpage!

You might also want to check out the best barbers in Manhattan.

North Shore High School

North Shore High School in Long Island is a hidden gem that delivers the perfect mix of academic excellence and vibrant school spirit. With its top-notch faculty and innovative programs, this school is dedicated to nurturing the potential of every student. Trust me, you'll want to be a part of the North Shore pride!

You might also want to check out the best cosmetology schools in NYC.