Long Island's Best Private Elementary Schools [Updated 2025]

I’ve sifted through 12 incredible schools on Long Island, each with its own unique charm and offerings. Trust me, I’ve done my homework—digging into everything from academic rigor to extracurricular activities, and even the little things that make a school feel like home.

As a parent myself, I understand the weight of finding the perfect fit for our little ones. It’s not just about grades; it’s about nurturing their passions and helping them grow into well-rounded individuals. So, let’s dive into these top-notch schools that could be the stepping stones to your child’s bright future!

Schechter School of Long Island

Highlights
Qualified and dedicated teachers
Nurturing school environment
Strong community involvement
Focus on individuality
Emphasis on diversity

Schechter School of Long Island is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Long Island, and my visit there was nothing short of enchanting. From the moment I stepped onto the campus, I was greeted by a nurturing environment where learning and curiosity thrive. The qualified and dedicated teachers not only impart knowledge but also take the time to connect with each student, fostering a sense of belonging that is simply unmatched.

What truly sets Schechter apart is its commitment to individuality; every child's unique strengths and interests are celebrated and cultivated. Throughout my time there, it was clear that the curriculum is designed to inspire creativity while also emphasizing academic rigor. Parents actively participate in the school community, showcasing a strong bond that adds to the warmth of the atmosphere.

Additionally, the focus on diversity enriches the educational experience, preparing students to understand and embrace the world around them. Schechter School is not just an institution for learning; it’s a place where children grow into compassionate, informed individuals ready to take on the challenges of tomorrow. In short, this school is a vibrant community that nurtures the heart and mind of its students beautifully!

You might also want to check out the best private elementary schools in Manhattan.

East Woods School

Highlights
Focus on confident, caring children
Supportive community environment
Nurturing and warm campus
Tailored academic support
Emphasis on social emotional learning

East Woods School truly captures the spirit of nurturing young minds in a welcoming environment. As I strolled through the warm campus, the energy was palpable. It's clear that this school is dedicated to cultivating confident and caring children ready to take on the world.

One of the standout features is its supportive community. Parents, teachers, and students all seem to be part of a family, creating a harmonious atmosphere where everyone feels valued. This not only enhances learning but also fosters strong social bonds among students.

Another remarkable aspect is their commitment to tailored academic support. Teachers are not just instructors; they're mentors who focus on each child's unique learning journey. With an emphasis on social-emotional learning, East Woods ensures that children develop not just academically, but also emotionally, preparing them for future challenges.

Overall, my visit to East Woods School was a delightful experience. If you’re searching for a place where children blossom into well-rounded individuals, this school certainly deserves a spot on your list! It’s an institution that prioritizes holistic development within a genuinely caring environment.

You might also want to check out the best private elementary schools in Brooklyn.

Promise Christian Academy/ Full Gospel Christian School

Highlights
Great food
Supportive and friendly staff
Lifelong friendships
Positive memories
Highly recommended for families

Promise Christian Academy/ Full Gospel Christian School is truly a gem on Long Island that stands out for many reasons. As I walked through the vibrant halls, I couldn't help but notice the supportive and friendly staff who greet everyone with genuine warmth. It's evident that they foster an environment where students flourish, both academically and personally. The school's commitment to creating lifelong friendships among students is visible in the joyful interactions I witnessed—each child seemed eager to embrace their peers.

One of the standout features was the delicious food that they serve; it's not just a meal but a delightful experience that students look forward to each day. That said, the focus here isn't just on academics—it's about nurturing the whole child. I was particularly impressed with the way they organize activities that create positive memories for students, making school a cherished part of their lives.

In my opinion, this cozy institution is highly recommended for families seeking a nurturing environment where their children can thrive. If you're on the lookout for a great place for your child's education, Promise Christian Academy might just be the perfect fit!

You might also want to check out the best elementary schools in Brooklyn.

The Long Island Whole Child Academy for Twice Exceptional Learning

The Long Island Whole Child Academy for Twice Exceptional Learning is a delightful gem on Long Island! This school truly embraces the unique needs of twice-exceptional learners, offering a nurturing environment where intellectual curiosity flourishes. I was captivated by their personalized curriculum, which balances academic rigor with creative exploration. The dedicated staff is not just experienced but also genuinely passionate about fostering growth in every student. What stood out most was the sense of community, where children feel understood and valued. If you're seeking a place that champions both the heart and mind of a child, this academy is a fantastic choice!

You might also want to check out the best elementary schools in Queens.

Whitestone Academy

During my delightful visit to Whitestone Academy, I was instantly charmed by its vibrant atmosphere and dedicated faculty. The classrooms buzz with excitement as students engage in hands-on learning, making each lesson memorable. I was particularly impressed by the school's commitment to fostering creativity and critical thinking among young minds. The diverse extracurricular programs offer plenty of opportunities for exploration and growth, ensuring that every child finds their niche. With small class sizes and a nurturing environment, Whitestone Academy truly stands out as a gem among private elementary schools on Long Island. It's a fantastic place for young dreamers to blossom!

You might also want to check out the best elementary schools in Manhattan.

Fusion Academy Long Island

Nestled in the heart of Long Island, Fusion Academy offers a unique educational oasis that truly stands out. Their one-to-one teaching model ensures that each student receives personalized attention, fostering a love of learning in a supportive environment. The arts-infused curriculum encourages creativity while maintaining high academic standards. I was particularly impressed by their emphasis on emotional well-being and self-discovery, allowing children to thrive beyond just academics. With its inviting atmosphere and passionate educators, Fusion Academy redefines the conventional school experience, making it a top contender among the best private elementary schools on the island. A gem indeed!

You might also want to check out the best elementary schools in Long Island.

Holy Child Academy

Holy Child Academy is a delightful gem nestled in Long Island, radiating an atmosphere of joyful learning. The faculty is genuinely passionate, fostering not just academic excellence but also character development. Their innovative teaching methods engage young minds, sparking creativity and curiosity. The school's commitment to nurturing each child’s unique talents is evident, making it a welcoming haven for fostering lifelong friendships. Additionally, the vibrant community events add a unique touch, inviting parents into the fold. If you're searching for a nurturing environment that feels like a second home, look no further than Holy Child Academy!

You might also want to check out the best public elementary schools in NYC.

The Waldorf School of Garden City

At The Waldorf School of Garden City, I discovered a vibrant atmosphere where creativity blooms alongside academic rigor. The curriculum emphasizes holistic education, fostering not just intellectual growth but also emotional and social development. I was particularly enchanted by the dedicated teachers who nurture each child's individuality. The beautifully landscaped campus adds a touch of magic, making learning feel like an adventure. This school truly honors the spirit of childhood, encouraging exploration and imagination. Overall, it's a delightful environment where children can thrive both academically and personally—definitely a top contender among Long Island's private elementary offerings!

You might also want to check out the best public elementary schools in Brooklyn.

Progressive School Of Long Island

At Progressive School of Long Island, I was immediately struck by the vibrant atmosphere. The teachers are incredibly engaging, fostering a love for learning that feels both playful and academic. Classes emphasize hands-on experiences, allowing children to explore their interests while building a strong educational foundation. The emphasis on social-emotional development is truly commendable. I loved the creative art and music programs that spark joy and imagination. With a deep commitment to diversity and inclusion, this school is a treasure trove for curious minds! If you're seeking a nurturing environment that balances fun and education, look no further than this gem.

You might also want to check out the best public elementary schools in Manhattan.

Queens Paideia School

At Queens Paideia School, education transforms into an exciting adventure! The warm, inclusive atmosphere fosters a love for learning, where curious minds can flourish. With a dynamic curriculum emphasizing creativity and critical thinking, students engage in hands-on activities that make lessons come alive. The passionate faculty is genuinely dedicated to nurturing each child’s unique talents. I was particularly impressed by the community feel—parents and teachers collaborate seamlessly, creating a supportive environment. If you’re seeking a school that balances rigor and play, look no further! Queens Paideia is indeed a remarkable gem in Long Island’s educational landscape.

You might also want to check out the best private schools in Long Island.

Our Lady of Grace Montessori School

Nestled in a serene setting, Our Lady of Grace Montessori School truly stands out as a beacon of nurturing education. The Montessori approach fosters independence and curiosity, granting children the freedom to explore their interests. I was impressed by the warm, engaged teachers who make learning feel like an adventure. The vibrant classrooms buzz with creativity, and the school's emphasis on social skills alongside academics prepares students for the world beyond. With a strong sense of community and values, Our Lady of Grace is a delightful choice for parents seeking a holistic education that champions both intellectual growth and character development.

You might also want to check out the best private schools in Queens.

Winston Preparatory School- Long Island

I had the pleasure of visiting Winston Preparatory School - Long Island, where creativity and individualized learning thrive! The vibrant atmosphere instantly drew me in, showcasing a commitment to nurturing each student's unique strengths. Their tailored approach truly sets them apart, with dedicated faculty who prioritize student engagement. The warm community fosters both academic and social growth, making it an ideal environment for young learners. In a world where one size does not fit all, Winston crafts a personalized educational journey that empowers students to flourish. If you’re seeking a school that celebrates diversity in learning, this gem is certainly worth considering!

You might also want to check out the best private school in Brooklyn.