NYC Times Square's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

After indulging in countless slices and experiencing the vibrant culinary scene of Times Square, I’ve honed in on the must-try pizzerias that will make your taste buds dance. I conducted a taste test of 12 top spots, from classic New York-style to innovative Neapolitan, to bring you the ultimate list.

Why trust my pizza palate? Well, I’ve spent years navigating the city’s bustling streets, chatting with local chefs, and sampling everything from late-night slices to gourmet pies. I know what it takes to craft the perfect pizza, and I can’t wait to share these hidden gems that’ll elevate your NYC experience and satisfy your cravings. Let’s dive in and discover some extraordinary flavors!

John's Pizzeria of Times Square

Highlights
Fantastic pizza atmosphere
Quick and friendly service
Spacious for group dining
Perfect crust, flavorful pizza
Convenient tourist stop

John's Pizzeria of Times Square is a gem tucked away in the bustling heart of New York. Stepping inside, I was immediately drawn to the fantastic pizza atmosphere—brick walls adorned with vintage photos create a warm, inviting vibe. The scent of freshly baked pizza wafted through the air, igniting my cravings.

The service was both quick and friendly, a welcome relief amidst the usual tourist rush. I appreciated that the staff took the time to explain the menu, making it easy to choose a pie that would satisfy my hunger. What stood out most about John's was the perfect crust; it struck the right balance between crispy and chewy, harmonizing beautifully with the rich, flavorful toppings.

As I dug in, each bite was a delicious adventure, showcasing traditional recipes that capture the essence of New York-style pizza. Additionally, the restaurant's spacious layout makes it an ideal spot for larger groups—always a plus for a fun night out in the city. For anyone strolling through Times Square, John's Pizzeria is a convenient tourist stop that promises a pizza experience to remember.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Paul’s on Times Square

Highlights
Cozy atmosphere
Great pizza options
Attentive and friendly staff
Located in Hilton Hotel
Nice escape from Times Square crowds

Paul’s on Times Square is a delightful find nestled in the Hilton Hotel, providing a much-needed sanctuary from the bustling crowds of Times Square. Upon entering, the cozy atmosphere immediately enveloped me, offering a contrast to the chaotic energy just outside its doors. The menu boasted an array of enticing options, making it hard to choose just one.

I settled on their classic Margherita pizza, and I was not disappointed. The crust was perfectly crispy, boasting just the right amount of chewiness that made every bite satisfying. The rich tomato sauce harmonized beautifully with the melted fresh mozzarella and fragrant basil, creating a symphony of flavors that danced on my palate.

What truly elevated the experience was the attentive and friendly staff who were eager to share their favorites and ensure I felt at home. It’s this kind of service that transforms a simple meal into a memorable experience.

In a city teeming with pizza joints, Paul’s on Times Square stands out not just for its delicious offerings but also for the warmth and comfort it provides away from the crowded streets. If you’re craving some pizza in Times Square, don’t miss this gem—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Joe's Pizza Broadway

Tucked away amidst the buzz of Times Square, Joe's Pizza Broadway serves a slice of New York tradition that is hard to beat. The crust strikes a perfect balance—crispy yet chewy—while the tomato sauce bursts with fresh, tangy flavor. Topped with just the right amount of gooey mozzarella, each bite is a nostalgic joyride. Despite the frenetic surroundings, the staff’s upbeat demeanor adds to the authenticity. I couldn’t help but savor every delightful slice. If you're in the area, Joe's Pizza is a must-visit for any pizza aficionado craving a quintessential NYC experience! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Carnegie Pizza

The moment I stepped into Carnegie Pizza, the tantalizing aroma enveloped me like a warm hug. I opted for a classic cheese slice, and let me tell you—the crust was perfection! Crispy on the outside, yet delightfully chewy within. Each bite revealed a harmony of rich, tangy sauce and a generous blanket of melty cheese that danced on my palate. The toppings? Fresh and plentiful—a testament to quality. Plus, the vibrant atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for both tourists and locals. If you're in the Times Square area, don't miss out on this gem—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Patzeria Perfect Pizza

At Patzeria Perfect Pizza, every slice is a delightful surprise! The crust is perfectly crispy, providing a wonderfully satisfying bite. I savored the classic Margherita, where the fresh basil danced atop the rich, tangy tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella. The bustling Times Square ambiance enveloped me as I enjoyed a slice that was both comforting and vibrant. With generous portions and quick service, it’s a fantastic stop for pizza lovers on the go. If you're in the area, make sure to grab a slice—your taste buds will thank you for this perfectly indulgent experience! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Square pizza NYC Time Square

Stepping into Square Pizza NYC felt like entering a pizza wonderland! The crust was a delightful balance of crispy and chewy, perfectly supporting generous toppings. I savored each bite of their signature square slices, which were artfully layered with melted cheese and vibrant veggies. The sauce had a subtle sweetness that complemented the robust flavors, making it incredibly addictive. Not to mention the vibrant atmosphere bursting with enthusiastic pizza lovers! If you're hunting for a distinctive slice in the midst of Times Square madness, this spot is absolutely worth a visit! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Don Antonio

Upon stepping into Don Antonio, I was greeted by the warm aroma of freshly baked Neapolitan pies. Their signature Montanara is a delightful twist, featuring a lightly fried crust that adds a playful crunch to each bite. The San Marzano tomatoes and creamy mozzarella create a symphony of flavors that dance on the palate. The atmosphere exudes a cozy charm, perfect for a quick slice or a leisurely meal. For anyone in the bustling Times Square area, if you seek pizza that tantalizes your taste buds, Don Antonio is an unmissable destination!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Little Italy Pizza

Stepping into Little Italy Pizza is like entering a slice of heaven right in the heart of NYC Times Square. The aroma of fresh dough and bubbling cheese greeted me, promising a delightful experience. I opted for their classic Margherita, and it did not disappoint! The crust was crispy yet chewy, perfectly charred, while the rich San Marzano tomatoes and creamy mozzarella danced together in harmony. Each bite transported me to the streets of Naples. With a lively atmosphere and friendly staff, this joint is a must-visit for pizza lovers. Little Italy Pizza — where each slice tells a delicious story! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Vito's Slices and Ices

Vito's Slices and Ices is a delightful gem in the bustling heart of Times Square. The perfectly charred crust cradles a harmonious blend of tangy tomato sauce and rich mozzarella that simply dances on the palate. I savored the classic pepperoni slice, where each bite offered a satisfying crunch followed by a delightful chew. The charming, no-frills atmosphere is inviting, making it the ideal spot for a quick lunch or late-night snack. Don’t skip on the ices—refreshing and the perfect way to cool down after a pizza feast. Vito's is a slice of New York heaven you won't want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Champion Pizza - Times Square

Stepping into Champion Pizza - Times Square felt like a delightful escape from the bustling streets. The vibrant atmosphere and the mouthwatering aroma instantly captured my attention. I ordered a classic slice, and the first bite was an explosion of flavors—the crust was wonderfully crispy yet chewy, the sauce tangy and fresh, and the cheese, oh the cheese! It melted in my mouth like creamy happiness. The generous toppings were perfectly balanced, making each slice a mini masterpiece. For a slice that embodies both tradition and innovation, Champion is undoubtedly a top contender in the Times Square pizza scene! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

BarDough

Stepping into BarDough was like finding a hidden gem amidst the bustling Times Square chaos. Their signature thin-crust pizza bursts with flavor, showcasing a delightful balance between crispy and chewy. I savored the Margherita, adorned with fresh basil and a rich tomato sauce that danced on my palate. The cozy ambience, complemented by friendly staff, made each bite even sweeter. Plus, their creative cocktails provide the perfect pairing. If you're on the hunt for a slice that brings joy amid the city's hustle, BarDough is a must-visit. Go ahead, indulge—your taste buds will thank you! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best hot chocolate in NYC.

Emmy Squared Pizza: Hell's Kitchen, New York

Nestled in the bustling heart of Hell's Kitchen, Emmy Squared offers a delightful twist on the classic NYC pie. Their Detroit-style pizza features a fluffy, caramelized crust that perfectly cradles a rich tomato sauce and gooey cheese. Biting into a slice was pure bliss—each mouthful bursting with flavor, and the crispy edges were simply addictive. The distinctive toppings, like the pepperoni piled high, elevate the experience to new heights. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, this eatery is a must-visit for an unforgettable pizza journey. In a city filled with options, Emmy Squared truly stands out!

You might also want to check out the best omakase in NYC.