NYC Barstool's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

Let’s be real—when it comes to pizza in NYC, it’s not just a meal; it’s an experience that dances on your taste buds and warms your soul. Having indulged in countless slices while roaming the streets of this vibrant city, I’ve zeroed in on two standout locations that have captured my heart (and stomach).

Trust me, I’ve put my pizza palate to the test, and I know what makes a slice truly sing. Whether you’re a crispy crust fanatic or a gooey cheese lover, I’ve got the inside scoop on where to find the most mouthwatering pies that will have you dreaming of New York long after your last bite. Let’s dive into the cheesy goodness!

John's of Bleecker Street

John's of Bleecker Street undoubtedly lives up to its reputation as one of the best pizza spots in the city. Walking into this iconic parlor, I was immediately struck by the lively atmosphere, with whispers of pizza magic echoing off the walls adorned with yesteryear's charm. The service was impeccable, as the staff radiated warmth and enthusiasm, making it feel like an old friend was serving up your favorite dish.

Now, let’s dive into the star of the show—the pizza! With its thin crust and no-nonsense approach, each slice is a firm testament to the art of pizza-making. The perfectly crisp base and fresh toppings create a harmonious blend that’s both classic and unforgettable. I devoured a slice, and real bliss washed over me; it was like savoring a piece of pizza history.

What's more enticing is the rich heritage embodied in every bite, a recipe honed over decades that maintains its integrity while remaining a popular choice among locals and tourists alike. If you're in the NYC Barstool area, a visit to John's is a must for anyone who truly appreciates pizza perfection. 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

At Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria, I was greeted by the enticing aroma of coal-fired crust, which immediately set the tone for a delightful pizza journey. The Margherita pie stole the show with its crispy crust, vibrant San Marzano tomatoes, and fresh basil. Each bite was a harmonious dance of flavors, showcasing the beauty of simplicity. The slightly charred edges added a wonderful texture, providing that sought-after crunch. With a warm atmosphere and friendly staff, this gem certainly earns its place among the finest pizzerias in NYC Barstool. I left with a full belly and a smile, eager to return!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.