Manhattan Barstool's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

With countless late-night slices and lunchtime cravings under my belt, I’ve tasted my way through the vibrant pizza landscape of Manhattan Barstool. I recently dove into two top contenders that have everyone buzzing, and let me tell you, they did not disappoint!

Having spent years perfecting my pizza palate—savoring everything from classic margheritas to outrageous toppings—I can confidently say I've found the gems that truly capture the spirit of our city. So whether you're a local looking for your next favorite spot or just visiting and craving that perfect slice, I’ve got the scoop that will guide you straight to pizza paradise. Trust me; your taste buds will thank you!

John's of Bleecker Street

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Manhattan Barstool, John's of Bleecker Street stands tall. Stepping into this iconic pizzeria is like entering a slice of New York's culinary history—the atmosphere is vibrant, with a delightful buzz that instantly makes you feel at home. I was greeted with quick and friendly service, the kind that makes you feel like a regular the first time you walk through the door.

As for the pizza, let me tell you, it’s nothing short of spectacular. The crust is perfectly crisp yet chewy, managing to hold its own against the generous toppings without wimping out. Each ingredient pops with flavor, showcasing the quality that John's is synonymous with. Whether you opt for classic pepperoni or a quaint Margherita, you’re in for a treat.

Every bite is a delicious reminder of why this spot has gained such acclaim over the years. If you’re wandering around Manhattan Barstool, searching for the quintessential New York pie, look no further than John's of Bleecker Street. It’s a pizza pilgrimage you absolutely need to make! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped into Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria, the warm, inviting aroma of baked dough enveloped me. The coal-fired crust was a revelation—crispy yet chewy, perfectly charred to give that unmistakable flavor. Topped with rich San Marzano tomatoes and creamy mozzarella, each slice was a delightful dance of textures. Their signature Margherita pizza truly shines; it’s elevated simplicity at its best. The vibrant basil adds a fresh note, making each bite a true delight. If you're searching for the perfect slice in Manhattan, Angelo's should undoubtedly be at the top of your list for an unforgettable pizza experience!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.