NYC Thanksgiving's Best Pies [Updated 2025]

I’ve tasted my way through countless bakeries and pie shops, and let me tell you, the flavors of Thanksgiving in this city are nothing short of magical. One of my top spots will have your taste buds doing a happy dance, and trust me, I’ve had my fair share of pumpkin spice and pecan pie disasters along the way.

With years of indulging in these delightful creations, I know exactly what makes a pie truly special—the perfect crust, a harmonious blend of spices, and that warm, comforting feeling that makes you feel right at home. So, get ready to discover a slice of NYC’s Thanksgiving spirit that you won’t want to miss!

Petee's Pie Company

At Petee's Pie Company, the aroma of freshly baked pies instantly enveloped me, promising a delightful experience. I indulged in their classic pumpkin pie, which struck a perfect balance of spice and sweetness, while the buttery crust flaked beautifully with each bite. The apple crumble was another standout, loaded with juicy apples and topped with a crunchy streusel that brought nostalgia for holiday gatherings. Petee's commitment to quality shines through, making it a must-visit for any Thanksgiving enthusiast. If you’re in the area, treat yourself to a slice—or two! It's pure pie magic that embodies the spirit of the season.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Brooklyn.