Long Island's Best Pies [Updated 2024]

Throughout my years as a Long Island native, I have had the pleasure of savoring countless slices of pie from various establishments across the island. Being a self-proclaimed expert in the art of pie tasting, I embarked on a mouthwatering mission to review and uncover the finest pie destinations in this vibrant region.

After putting my taste buds to the test, I am ecstatic to present to you the culmination of my journey - a curated list of the top four pie havens that will undoubtedly leave you craving more. So fasten your seatbelts, loosen your belts, and prepare to embark on a delectable adventure through the best pies Long Island has to offer!

Sweetie Pies on Main

Highlights
Cozy atmosphere
Delicious coffee
Fall specials
Great blueberry muffins
Adorable coffee dessert shop
Beautiful sitting area

Walking into Sweetie Pies, I was immediately struck by the cozy atmosphere that greeted me. The warm lighting and delightful decorations made me feel right at home. As I took a seat in the beautiful sitting area, I couldn't help but notice the enticing aroma of freshly brewed coffee wafting through the air.

Speaking of coffee, the delicious coffee at Sweetie Pies was a real treat. The rich, smooth flavor was the perfect companion to the delectable pie I was about to savor. And speaking of pies, Sweetie Pies offers a delightful array of fall specials that are sure to please any pie lover.

I decided to try their blueberry pie, and boy was I in for a treat. The golden crust was perfectly flaky, and the filling was bursting with juicy blueberries. I could taste the love and care that went into crafting each slice.

But Sweetie Pies isn't just about pies. They also offer a wide selection of baked goods, including great blueberry muffins. These muffins were moist, flavorful, and simply irresistible. They paired perfectly with a cup of their signature coffee.

Overall, my experience at Sweetie Pies on Main was nothing short of delightful. This adorable coffee dessert shop truly knows how to create pies that are as beautiful to look at as they are to taste. So, if you find yourself in Long Island craving a slice of heaven, be sure to pay Sweetie Pies a visit. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Manhattan.

Whistle Stop Desserts

Highlights
Large selection
Friendly service
Outstanding cakes
Incredible customer service
Delicious baked goods

Whistle Stop Desserts truly surprised me with their expansive pie selection. From classic apple and cherry to unique flavors like salted caramel and strawberry rhubarb, they had something for every pie lover. The friendly service was a warm welcome, making my visit even more enjoyable.

As I took a bite of their freshly baked apple pie, I couldn't help but be taken aback by the burst of flavors that danced on my taste buds. The flaky crust was perfectly complemented by the sweet and tart apple filling - it was simply heavenly. But the surprises didn't end there; their outstanding cakes were a delightful spectacle, some even topped with extravagant decorations.

Not only were the pies and cakes exceptional, but Whistle Stop Desserts topped it off with incredible customer service. The staff seemed genuinely passionate about their creations, and they were more than happy to answer my questions and offer recommendations. It was evident that they truly cared about the satisfaction of their customers.

Whistle Stop Desserts is undoubtedly a must-visit for any pie enthusiast in Long Island. The combination of their large selection, incredible customer service, and the deliciousness of their baked goods make it a standout in the bustling Long Island bakery scene. Whether you're craving a classic or something more adventurous, Whistle Stop Desserts is the perfect destination for your pie cravings.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Shuga Pie Shop

Highlights
Heavenly
Delicious
Variety
Vegan
Sweet

Walking into Shuga Pie Shop feels like stepping into a heavenly bakery. The sweet aroma of freshly baked pies immediately envelopes you, creating an irresistible temptation. The wide variety of pies on display is enough to make any pie lover weak at the knees.

As I perused the selection, my taste buds salivated at the sight of classic favorites like apple and cherry pies, as well as unique creations like salted caramel and peanut butter pie. Shuga Pie Shop truly offers a delicious assortment that caters to every craving.

What sets Shuga Pie Shop apart is its commitment to inclusivity. Not only do they offer traditional pies, but they also have an impressive range of vegan options. I was blown away by how these dairy-free pies retained the same level of indulgence and rich flavors.

Of course, I couldn't resist diving into a few slices, and boy, they did not disappoint. Each bite was a symphony of flavors and textures, leaving me in a state of pure bliss. The crusts were perfectly flaky, and the fillings were incredibly sweet without being overwhelming.

Whether you're a seasoned pie enthusiast or a casual dessert lover, Shuga Pie Shop is a must-visit. You'll find yourself spoiled for choice, indulging in heavenly and variety of pies that will leave your taste buds dancing with joy.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Kensington Pies

At Kensington Pies in Long Island, I discovered a heavenly selection of delectable treats. From classic fruit pies like apple and cherry, to indulgent creations like pecan and chocolate silk, every bite was a slice of pure bliss. The flaky crusts were perfection, and the fillings were bursting with flavor. Kensington Pies truly takes the cake... or should I say pie.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.