Long Island's Best Malls [Updated 2024]

Having grown up on Long Island and spent countless hours exploring the local shopping scene, I am well-equipped to share my insights on the top shopping destinations in this vibrant region. With a whopping 12 malls reviewed, I have left no stone unturned in my quest to discover the shopping havens that truly stand out among the rest.

So, whether you're a local looking for a new retail therapy spot or a visitor seeking the best Long Island mall experience, this guide is your go-to resource. Join me as we delve into the exciting world of Long Island malls and uncover the ultimate shopping destinations that will leave you spellbound!

Americana Manhasset

Highlights
Well managed shopping center
Intelligent security
Good police presence
High Value Shopping Area
Top-notch stores

Let me start by saying that this shopping center is a true gem in Long Island. From the moment I stepped foot into Americana Manhasset, it was evident that this place is managed with utmost care.

One of the first things I noticed was the intelligent security system in place. I felt safe and secure throughout my visit. The presence of well-trained security personnel and the assistance of the friendly and helpful staff made me feel at ease.

The good news for shoppers looking for a safe environment doesn't end there. There is also a commendable police presence that adds an extra layer of protection, making it clear that Americana Manhasset takes the safety and well-being of its visitors seriously.

But let's talk about the real reason why people flock to this shopping center – the shops! Americana Manhasset is a high-value shopping area with a collection of top-notch stores. From luxury boutiques to high-end brands, this mall has something for everyone. The quality and selection of the stores truly impressed me.

Overall, if you're looking for a well-managed shopping center that offers top-notch stores, Americana Manhasset should definitely be on your list. With its intelligent security, good police presence, and high-value shopping area, it sets the bar high for malls in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best views in NYC.

Plaza 48

Highlights
Convenient location
Free parking
Wide variety of stores
Helpful employees
Self check out

As soon as I stepped foot into Plaza 48, I was immediately impressed by its convenient location. Situated in the heart of Long Island, this mall is easily accessible from all directions, making it a breeze to get to and navigate.

One of the major highlights of Plaza 48 is the free parking. I didn't have to worry about hunting for a spot or fussing with parking meters. It definitely added to the overall stress-free shopping experience.

The mall boasts a wide variety of stores, catering to all my shopping needs. From trendy fashion boutiques to household essentials, Plaza 48 has it all. I was delighted to find everything I was looking for in one place, saving me time and energy.

The helpful employees were another standout feature. They were friendly, knowledgeable, and eager to assist me in finding what I needed. Their expertise made my shopping trip a breeze and I appreciated their attentiveness.

I had the opportunity to try out the self-checkout option, which was incredibly convenient. It allowed me to complete my purchases quickly and efficiently, without having to wait in line.

Overall, Plaza 48 proved to be an outstanding mall that exceeded my expectations. Its prime location, ample parking, diverse range of stores, helpful employees, and modern facilities make it a top choice for shoppers in Long Island. I can confidently say that Plaza 48 deserves its spot among the best malls in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in NYC.

Wheatley Plaza

Highlights
Well-maintained
Variety of stores
Good crowd
Good food

Wheatley Plaza is a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Long Island. As I walked through the doors, I was immediately struck by its well-maintained and inviting atmosphere. The clean and polished floors gave off an air of elegance, setting the stage for an exceptional shopping experience.

One of the highlights of Wheatley Plaza is its impressive variety of stores. From high-end boutiques to popular retail chains, there is something for everyone's taste and budget. Whether you're in search of fashion-forward clothing, trendy accessories, or unique home decor, this mall has you covered.

As I strolled through the plaza, I couldn't help but notice the vibrant and bustling crowd. It was refreshing to see so many people enjoying their time, embracing the joy of retail therapy. The lively atmosphere created an infectious energy, making me feel right at home.

But what truly stood out to me was the delectable food options available at Wheatley Plaza. The diverse culinary offerings were a gourmet paradise, tantalizing my taste buds with each savory aroma. From chic cafes to upscale restaurants, the dining options were top-notch and ensured that every craving could be satisfied.

In conclusion, Wheatley Plaza is a true shopping oasis in Long Island, providing a well-maintained and delightful experience. Its wide range of stores, thriving crowd, and mouthwatering food options make it a must-visit destination for any shopaholic. So, if you're looking for a joyful and rewarding shopping spree, be sure to give Wheatley Plaza a go!

You might also want to check out the best realtors in Manhattan Beach CA.

The Point at Garden City Park

The Point at Garden City Park is a delightful mecca of retail therapy in Long Island. From the moment I stepped foot in this shopping wonderland, I was whisked away by its upscale yet casual ambiance. With a plethora of fashion-forward boutiques and irresistible eateries, this mall is certainly a shopaholic's paradise. Don't miss out on its enchanting outdoor gathering spaces, perfect for a quick rest or photo op. The Point truly hits the bullseye when it comes to providing an enjoyable shopping experience.

You might also want to check out the best irish pubs in NYC.

Westbury Plaza

Westbury Plaza in Long Island is a captivating gem that tickles the shopaholic in me. With its vibrant mix of trendy boutiques and popular brand stores, it's a shopper's paradise. The assortment of delectable dining options ensures that you won't go hungry while searching for that perfect outfit. Don't miss out on this retail haven!

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.

Roosevelt Field

Roosevelt Field in Long Island truly blew me away! From the moment I stepped foot inside, I was greeted by an elegant and modern atmosphere. The selection of stores was absolutely mind-boggling, with high-end retailers and trendy boutiques lining every corner. As I explored further, I couldn't help but notice the sprawling layout that was both easy to navigate and visually appealing. The food court was a culinary delight, offering a wide variety of options to satisfy any craving. The entire experience left me feeling like a pampered and stylish shopper. Roosevelt Field definitely earns its place as one of the best malls in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best law firms in NYC.

Green Acres Mall

Green Acres Mall in Long Island is a playful paradise, boasting an impressive selection of stores and dining options. From trendy boutiques to popular chain retailers, there's something for everyone. The lively atmosphere and engaging events make it a must-visit for any serious shopper.

You might also want to check out the best libraries in NYC.

Sunrise Mall

Sunrise Mall in Long Island is a hidden gem bursting with shopping delights. The diverse range of stores caters to every taste and budget, from trendy boutiques to well-known brands. With its vibrant atmosphere and mouthwatering food court, this mall is a must-visit for mall aficionados in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best lawyers in NYC.

New Hyde Park Shopping Mall

The New Hyde Park Shopping Mall in Long Island is a hidden gem! With its vibrant atmosphere and diverse range of shops, this mall is a playground for retail enthusiasts. From fashionable boutiques to gourmet eateries, there's something for everyone. You won't be disappointed by this charming and thriving shopping destination!

You might also want to check out the best parks in Brooklyn.

The Mall at The Source

Oh boy, The Mall at The Source in Long Island is quite the place! With its vibrant atmosphere and wide range of stores, there's no shortage of options for shopaholics like me. This mall is a true shopping paradise, offering everything from trendy fashion boutiques to high-end technology stores. Plus, their food court offers a delectable array of culinary delights, making it the perfect pit stop for refueling. So, why wait? Head over to The Mall at The Source and indulge in some serious retail therapy!

You might also want to check out the best bookstore in NYC.

Walt Whitman Shops

Walt Whitman Shops in Long Island is a shopaholic's dream! With a wide variety of stores, upscale boutiques, and delicious dining options, this mall has it all. The sleek and modern design adds an extra touch of class. A must-visit spot on any shopping spree in Long Island!

The Gallery At Westbury Plaza

Just a quick disclaimer before I dive into the review: I am not a certified critic, but I do fancy myself as a mall connoisseur. So, let's get into it!

The Gallery At Westbury Plaza in Long Island is like stumbling upon a hidden treasure. Tucked away amidst the hustle and bustle of city life, this place is a delightful surprise. From the moment I stepped inside, I couldn't help but be captivated by the charm and elegance of the mall.

With its chic and modern design, The Gallery offers a refreshing shopping experience. The wide array of stores provides a little something for everyone, from high-end fashion boutiques to trendy lifestyle shops. It's a shopping paradise, where you can find that perfect outfit or unique accessory to wow your friends.

What sets The Gallery apart from other malls is the attention to detail. The pristine cleanliness, well-maintained facilities, and friendly staff create an inviting atmosphere. Exploring the different stores felt like embarking on a mini adventure, full of surprises and delights at every turn.

And let's not forget about the abundance of dining options! From delightful cafes to tantalizing restaurants, you'll never go hungry here. Whether you're craving a quick snack, a gourmet meal, or a refreshing drink, The Gallery has got you covered.

Oh, and did I mention the events? The Gallery hosts a range of exciting events throughout the year, making it not just a mall but a vibrant community hub. From fashion shows to live music performances, there's always something going on to entertain and inspire.

So, if you're in Long Island and looking for a mall that checks all the boxes, The Gallery At Westbury Plaza is a definite must-visit. Elegant, diverse, and brimming with style, this hidden gem is a standalone contender on the list of Long Island's best malls.