Long Island's Best Lunch [Updated 2024]

Having tried and tested countless lunch spots across Long Island, I am excited to share with you my top picks. With a total of 12 restaurants reviewed, I have scoured the island to bring you the most delectable and satisfying lunch options available.

Whether you're craving a hearty sandwich, a refreshing salad, or even international cuisines, this guide has got you covered. From cozy cafes to trendy bistros, I have explored every nook and cranny to ensure that only the finest establishments made it onto this exclusive list.

So buckle up, your taste buds are in for a treat as we embark on this flavorful journey through Long Island's best lunch spots.

Maiella

Highlights
Fresh pasta in a cheese wheel
Top notch service
Beautifully decorated
Slow paced dining
Stunning views

From the moment I stepped into Maiella, I was captivated by its beautiful decor and stunning views of the Long Island Sound. The elegant ambiance immediately set the tone for a memorable lunch experience.

The menu at Maiella is a culinary journey, but one highlight that truly stood out was their fresh pasta served in a cheese wheel. Imagine indulging in a plate of perfectly cooked pasta, coated in a creamy sauce, all while being surrounded by the delightful aroma of melted cheese. It was a feast for the senses, and it certainly lived up to the hype.

Not only was the food exceptional, but the service was top-notch as well. The staff at Maiella were attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable about the menu, making sure that every aspect of our dining experience was impeccable.

What I especially appreciated about Maiella was the slow-paced dining experience. It allowed me to fully savor each bite and truly immerse myself in the flavors. It felt like I was transported to a tranquil oasis, where time slowed down and the hustle and bustle of the outside world faded away.

All in all, Maiella embodies the essence of a perfect lunch spot in Long Island. With its fresh pasta in a cheese wheel, top-notch service, and stunning views, it is no wonder why it has become one of the must-visit destinations for lunch in the area. Whether you're looking for a special occasion or simply want to treat yourself to a delicious meal, Maiella is a delightful choice that is sure to leave you with a satisfied smile.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Jackson's Eatery | Bar

Highlights
Accommodating staff
Fast service
Serves breakfast all day
Amazing server

As soon as I entered Jackson's Eatery | Bar, I was greeted by its friendly and accommodating staff. They were attentive, ensuring that my lunch experience would be a memorable one.

The menu at Jackson's is diverse, offering a wide array of options to satisfy any craving. One highlight of this establishment is that they serve breakfast all day. Who doesn't love breakfast for lunch? It's a delightful surprise that sets them apart from other establishments I've visited.

What impressed me the most about Jackson's was the fast service. Despite being busy, the staff worked efficiently, delivering our meals in no time. It was a seamless experience, allowing me to enjoy my lunch without any unnecessary delays.

The standout aspect of my visit was the amazing server. Their knowledge of the menu was exceptional, providing expert recommendations and assisting us in selecting the perfect lunch options. Their enthusiasm for their job was contagious, enhancing our overall dining experience.

In conclusion, Jackson's Eatery | Bar in Long Island is a must-visit for lunch enthusiasts. The accommodating staff, fast service, and the fact that they serve breakfast all day make this place a winner in my book. And let's not forget about the amazing server who made our lunch experience extraordinary. Give it a try, and you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Crabtree's Restaurant

Highlights
Excellent service
Outstanding seafood
Delicious desserts
Friendly bartender
Memorable drinks

Walking into Crabtree's Restaurant, I was immediately greeted with a warm smile and a friendly "hello" from the staff. The service throughout my entire lunch was nothing short of excellent. The attentive and knowledgeable waitstaff made me feel like an honored guest, ensuring that my every need was met.

Now let's talk about the star of the show – the seafood. As a seafood lover, I was blown away by the outstanding quality of the dishes at Crabtree's. Each bite was a flavorful explosion of freshness. From the succulent shrimp cocktail to the perfectly seared scallops, every seafood dish was executed with precision and elegance.

And let's not forget about the desserts. Oh boy, were they delicious! The desserts at Crabtree's were the perfect ending to an already incredible meal. From the rich and decadent chocolate mousse to the light and fluffy lemon tart, each dessert left me craving for more.

I have to give a special shoutout to the friendly bartender who whipped up some of the most memorable drinks I've ever had. Their creativity and skill were evident in each expertly crafted cocktail.

Overall, my experience at Crabtree's Restaurant was exceptional. The combination of excellent service, outstanding seafood, and delicious desserts made this lunch one to remember. If you're looking for a truly unforgettable dining experience in Long Island, Crabtree's is an absolute must-visit.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

The Shed Restaurant - Huntington NY

The Shed Restaurant - Huntington NY in Long Island is a playground for your taste buds! This delightful eatery offers a playful yet professional atmosphere and an enticing menu that will satisfy even the most discerning lunch connoisseur. From their scrumptious burgers to their tantalizing salads, The Shed truly knows how to elevate the lunchtime experience. Don't miss their signature dish – the Shed Burger, topped with melty cheese, crispy bacon, and a tangy special sauce. You'll leave feeling satisfied and ready to conquer the rest of your day!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Cafe Ole

Drumroll please! Cafe Ole in Long Island is a hidden gem serving up an explosion of flavors with their irresistible lunch options. From crispy paninis to satisfying salads, their menu is a culinary adventure for your taste buds. Don't miss out on their mouthwatering bruschetta – it's to die for!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Tullulah's

Tullulah's in Long Island is a hidden gem that left my taste buds dancing with joy. From the charming atmosphere to the mouthwatering menu, this place exceeded my expectations. The creative dishes like the braised short rib grilled cheese and the truffle fries were phenomenal. Tullulah's certainly deserves a spot on the list of Long Island's best lunches.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

JACX&CO Food Hall

I had heard a lot of buzz about JACX&CO Food Hall and couldn't wait to see what all the fuss was about. Let me tell you, I was not disappointed. This place is a lunch lover's dream come true. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by a bustling atmosphere and an array of mouthwatering smells. The food options were incredibly diverse, ranging from juicy burgers to tasty tacos and everything in between. I decided to try the Korean BBQ bowl and boy was it a flavor explosion in my mouth. The tender beef, the tangy kimchi, the perfectly cooked rice - every bite was a delight. The best part? The portion sizes were incredibly generous, making it a great bang for your buck. The staff was friendly and attentive, ensuring that my lunch experience was top-notch. What really sets JACX&CO Food Hall apart is the unique and trendy vibe. The sleek and modern decor gave it a cool and hip feel, which made the entire experience even more enjoyable. Whether you're looking for a quick bite on your lunch break or a leisurely meal with friends, JACX&CO Food Hall is the place to be. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Lakehouse

I had the pleasure of dining at the charming Lakehouse in Long Island for my lunch quest. The ambiance was simply delightful, with rustic decor and a beautiful view of the lake. The menu was impressive, offering a wide variety of dishes to satisfy all palates. But what truly stood out was the impeccable service and attention to detail. From the moment I walked in, I felt like a VIP. The friendly staff went above and beyond to ensure I had a memorable dining experience. As for the food, it was a symphony of flavors dancing on my palate. The chef's creativity shone through each dish, from the perfectly grilled salmon to the scrumptious vegetarian risotto. There were even delicious options for those with dietary restrictions, showcasing the chef's dedication to inclusiveness. Whether you're looking for an intimate lunch date or a gathering with friends, Lakehouse is undoubtedly a must-visit. This hidden gem exceeded my expectations in every possible way, making it a strong contender for the title of the best lunch in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Mill Pond House

Mill Pond House in Long Island was a delightful surprise! The playful yet professional atmosphere made for a memorable lunch experience. The crisp salads and flavorful sandwiches were a culinary masterpiece. A must-visit for anyone looking for the best lunch in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

LIMANI

I must admit, the lunch at LIMANI was like tasting a piece of Mediterranean heaven during my stroll in Long Island. The menu? It offered a cornucopia of fresh seafood delights, bursting with vibrant flavors and served with an extra pinch of elegance. When it comes to the best lunch in Long Island, LIMANI truly reels in the competition!

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Thomas's Ham & Eggery Diner

Thomas's Ham & Eggery Diner in Long Island is a playful yet professional lunch spot that exceeded all of my expectations. The friendly staff, cozy atmosphere, and mouthwatering menu options make this place a must-visit for any lunch enthusiast. The eggs were perfectly cooked, the ham was juicy and flavorful, and the diner classics were executed flawlessly. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

Café Henri

I've had the pleasure to indulge in the scrumptious offerings at Café Henri in Long Island. Bold flavors and creative combinations make this eatery stand out. The chicken and avocado sandwich was a tasty triumph, while the fluffy quiche left me wanting more. Their friendly service and charming ambiance sealed the deal. Café Henri is a must-visit for lunch lovers in Long Island.