Long Island's Best Gelato [Updated 2025]

After indulging in creamy scoops and delightful flavors at 12 of the finest gelato spots around, I can confidently say that Long Island has some of the most mouthwatering treats you’ll ever taste. As a passionate gelato enthusiast and a long-time resident, I’ve taken my taste buds on quite the adventure, sampling everything from classic vanilla to innovative seasonal concoctions.

You can trust my expertise because I’ve savored each scoop with an open heart and a discerning palate. Whether you’re a lifelong Long Islander or just passing through, I promise there’s a gelato waiting to whisk you away on a delicious journey—so grab a spoon and let’s dive into the sweetest spots on the Island!

Caffè Italia

Highlights
Great variety of flavors
Less sweet, more flavorful
First-time visit success
Tiramisu has chocolatey taste
Repeat visit recommended

Caffè Italia is a delightful gem that truly captures the essence of authentic gelato. Upon my first visit, I was immediately taken by the great variety of flavors available—each one seemed more tempting than the last. What sets Caffè Italia apart is their commitment to crafting gelato that is less sweet, allowing the natural flavors to shine.

Among the flavors I sampled, the tiramisu was a standout. This confection didn't just whisper of coffee; it sang with a rich chocolatey taste that had me appreciating every spoonful. Each bite was a gentle reminder of why I love gelato so much!

I can confidently say this is a repeat visit destination. The atmosphere is welcoming, making it easy to linger over a scoop (or two!) while contemplating your next flavor choice. If you find yourself in Long Island and craving gelato that’s packed with flavor and character, Caffè Italia is a must-try. It’s a celebration of taste that will keep you coming back for more! So grab a cone and indulge; you won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Manhattan.

Chillato

Highlights
Kid-friendly party venue
Customizable sweet treats
Welcoming and helpful staff
Affordable prices
Clean and cheerful atmosphere

Chillato in Long Island is a delightful gem that captures the essence of a true gelato haven. From the moment I stepped inside, I was embraced by a clean and cheerful atmosphere that perfectly sets the tone for a treat-filled adventure. The staff greeted me warmly, showcasing their passion for gelato with an infectious enthusiasm.

What truly sets Chillato apart is their ability to cater to every palate. Their customizable sweet treats allow you to mix flavors and toppings, redefining the art of dessert creation. I felt like a kid again, experimenting with combinations that made my taste buds dance. Plus, the prices are incredibly affordable, making it easy to indulge without breaking the bank.

Whether you're planning a kid-friendly party or just stopping by for a scoop, Chillato promises a delightful experience. Throughout my visit, I was impressed by how accommodating and helpful the staff were, making the entire outing even more enjoyable. All in all, Chillato exemplifies the best of what gelato can be, igniting a sweet spark of joy in every scoop. If you're in Long Island, this is one spot you simply can't miss!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Brooklyn.

Bambina Blue Gelato Wonder Room

Highlights
Incredible passion fruit flavor
Cozy and welcoming ambiance
Massive scoop sizes
Extraordinary customer service
Delicious food options

Walking into Bambina Blue Gelato Wonder Room is like stepping into a whimsical dream filled with delectable possibilities. The inviting atmosphere instantly enveloped me, making it the perfect spot to relax and indulge. The moment I laid eyes on their menu, I was captivated by the incredible passion fruit flavor that had my taste buds dancing in anticipation.

Opting for a generous scoop, I was pleasantly surprised by the massive portion sizes that left my heart (and stomach) smiling. The gelato itself was a creamy masterpiece, with the tangy passion fruit offering a delightful tartness that harmonized beautifully with the sweetness—a true testament to their craft.

Beyond the gelato, I was thoroughly impressed by the extraordinary customer service. The staff was not only friendly but genuinely passionate about their creations, guiding me through a tasting adventure that felt tailor-made. They even offered delicious food options, making it easy to pair my gelato with a savory bite.

In short, Bambina Blue Gelato Wonder Room is a remarkable experience that exuberantly showcases the best of gelato on Long Island. Don't miss the chance to delight your senses!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Gelateria Dei Coltelli

Strolling into Gelateria Dei Coltelli felt like stepping into a blissful Italian escape! The inviting aroma of freshly made gelato enveloped me as I approached the counter. I indulged in their pistachio flavor—rich, creamy, and packed with real nuts that danced on my palate. The chocolate sorbet was equally delightful, boasting a deep, decadent flavor without being overly sweet. The staff's passion for their craft shone through, providing friendly service with a smile. If you’re craving a gelato experience that’s both authentic and extraordinary, Gelateria Dei Coltelli is an absolute must-visit. Buon Appetito!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Figo il Gelato Italiano

When my tastebuds wandered into Figo il Gelato Italiano, I was greeted by a symphony of flavors that could make anyone's heart sing. From the first luscious spoonful of their rich pistachio to the divine salted caramel, each gelato is a testament to the art of Italian craftsmanship. The creamy texture feels like a velvety embrace, while the vibrant flavors dance on your palate. The atmosphere is charming, making it the perfect spot for a sweet escape. If you’re on a quest for the best gelato in Long Island, Figo is an unmissable gem that deserves a place on your dessert itinerary! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Dolce Gelato

Nestled in the vibrant heart of Long Island, Dolce Gelato is a delightful escape for dessert lovers. From the moment I stepped inside, the rich aroma of fresh gelato enveloped me like a warm hug. I savored their Pistachio, which was an exquisite blend of nutty goodness and creamy texture. Each bite was a playful dance on my palate, bursting with flavor. The staff was not only knowledgeable but also enthusiastic, ready to help with recommendations. If you’re seeking an authentic gelato experience, Dolce Gelato is an absolute must-visit for both locals and visitors alike! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Anita La Mamma del Gelato

During my delightful visit to Anita La Mamma del Gelato, I felt transported to a charming Italian piazza with each creamy scoop. Their pistachio gelato was a harmonious blend of rich, nutty flavor, while the stracciatella offered delightful flecks of dark chocolate in a luscious base. The texture was both silky and utterly indulgent. The vibrant decor and inviting atmosphere only added to the charm, making it the perfect spot for a sweet escape. If you're on the hunt for gelato that sings with authenticity, Anita is an absolute must-try on Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Sweet Spot Cafe Long Island

Tucked away in a cozy corner of Long Island, Sweet Spot Cafe is a gelato paradise! Upon stepping in, the delightful aroma of freshly made treats engulfed me, instantly sparking joy. I dove into a scoop of their hazelnut gelato, creamy and packed with authentic flavor—pure bliss! The richness of the gelato paired with the friendly staff made for a perfect afternoon escapade. Their selection is impressive, featuring unique flavors that tantalize any palate. If you're seeking a gelato experience that's a cut above the rest, Sweet Spot Cafe is definitely worth a visit. Indulge your sweet tooth here—you won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Cheeks & Bean Gelato Co.

At Cheeks & Bean Gelato Co., I was greeted by an inviting atmosphere and a cheerful staff. The moment I indulged in their creamy gelato, I knew I was in for a treat! Their Salted Caramel flavor danced harmoniously on my palate, balancing sweet and savory with every delightful bite. The texture was nothing short of heavenly—silky and rich. Plus, I couldn't resist the Pistachio; it was like a nutty hug! If you're exploring Long Island, don’t miss this gem. Cheeks & Bean is a true gelato paradise that promises to elevate your dessert game! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Noi Due Gelato

On a sunny afternoon, I discovered Noi Due Gelato, and it was a delightful adventure! Their rich, creamy gelato was a symphony of flavors, notably the pistachio, which had an irresistible nutty essence that transported me straight to Italy. The artisan approach shines through in every scoop, and the friendly staff enhances the experience with their enthusiasm. I couldn’t resist trying the salted caramel, which was a sweet and salty masterpiece. Each bite was pure bliss—definitely a must-visit for any gelato lover on Long Island! Treat yourself and savor the magic at Noi Due Gelato!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Venchi Chocolate and Gelato NOMAD

During my visit to Venchi Chocolate and Gelato NOMAD, I was delighted by an exquisite array of flavors that danced on my palate. The rich, velvety chocolate gelato was a standout, leaving me craving more with its luxurious creaminess. Each scoop was a celebration of authentic Italian craftsmanship, from classic hazelnut to innovative fruit blends. The vibrant, inviting atmosphere made my tasting journey even more enjoyable. If you seek not just gelato but a delightful experience, Venchi delivers a tantalizing adventure that will make your taste buds sing. Don’t miss it! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Arcobaleno Gelateria NYC

On my delightful expedition to Arcobaleno Gelateria NYC, I was swept away by the pint-sized paradise they serve. The moment I stepped in, the vibrant colors and inviting aroma led me straight to a flavor adventure unlike any other. I indulged in the Pistachio, which was rich with nutty depth, and the Stracciatella, a creamy wonder sprinkled with generous chocolate flakes. Each bite was a symphony of textures and flavors, transporting me to the sun-kissed streets of Italy. If you’re on Long Island, don’t just walk—gelato-jump into this sweet haven! 🍦

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.