The Absolute Best Eggnog in NYC [Updated 2024]

I've sampled and reviewed twelve different establishments across the city to bring you the creamiest, richest, and most satisfying cups of this classic holiday beverage. From cozy cafes to swanky cocktail bars, there is something for everyone on this list.

Whether you prefer your eggnog spiked with a splash of rum or delightfully simple, I've got you covered. Get ready to indulge in velvety mouthfuls of festive flavor as we embark on a journey to discover the top spots in NYC to sip on this beloved holiday tradition.

So grab a mug, get cozy, and let's dive into the quest for the best eggnog in the Big Apple!

il laboratorio del gelato

Highlights
Tons of flavors
Best ice cream shop
Popular flavors sell out quick
Unique flavors
Friendly workers

From the moment I stepped into il laboratorio del gelato, I knew I was in for a treat. The shop was bustling with enthusiastic ice cream lovers, and the air was filled with the sweet scent of freshly made gelato.

One of the highlights of this shop is the incredible range of flavors they offer. They have a mind-boggling selection that goes far beyond your typical vanilla and chocolate. From classics like pistachio and strawberry to more adventurous options like lavender and olive oil, il laboratorio del gelato truly has something for everyone.

But don't be fooled by the wide variety of flavors – they are also known for being the best ice cream shop in all of NYC. Every spoonful of their gelato is like a little piece of heaven. It's rich, creamy, and full of flavor, making it impossible to resist.

However, if you have your heart set on a specific flavor, be sure to get there early because the popular ones sell out quickly. I made the mistake of arriving later in the day and missed out on their famous eggnog gelato, which I had heard so many rave reviews about.

But fear not! The employees at il laboratorio del gelato are friendly and knowledgeable. They will happily guide you through their wondrous selection of gelatos and even offer samples if you find it hard to decide.

So, if you're looking for a place to indulge in some of the best eggnog in NYC, make sure to visit il laboratorio del gelato. It's a delightful and unique ice cream shop that will surely satisfy your eggnog cravings.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Peacefood - Upper West Side

Highlights
Chickpea fries
Key lime pie
Mocha breakfast smoothie
Friendly staff
Delicious dumplings

Walking into Peacefood, I was immediately drawn to the cozy and relaxed ambiance. As I perused the menu, I couldn't help but notice the extensive selection of delectable vegan treats. While my main mission was to sample their eggnog, I couldn't resist trying a few other items from their menu.

First up were the chickpea fries, a unique and flavorful twist on a classic snack. Crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, these fries were the perfect start to my meal.

Next, I indulged in a slice of their famous key lime pie. The tangy lime filling and smooth, creamy texture were a delightful combination.

To balance out the richness, I decided to sip on their mocha breakfast smoothie. Made with a blend of chocolate, coffee, and almond milk, it was the perfect pick-me-up to accompany my meal.

The highlight of my visit, of course, was the eggnog. It was velvety smooth with just the right amount of spice, and the frothy consistency added an extra touch of indulgence. The rich flavor of the nutmeg and cinnamon was perfectly balanced, making it truly the best eggnog I've tasted in NYC.

Not only was the food exceptional, but the staff at Peacefood were incredibly friendly and attentive, adding to the overall enjoyable experience.

In conclusion, Peacefood - Upper West Side offers a wide array of delicious vegan options, but their eggnog truly stole the show. If you're a fan of this holiday classic, I highly recommend making a trip to Peacefood to satisfy your craving.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Onieal's

Highlights
Awesome
Outstanding service
Great food
Charming location

Walking into Onieal's, I was immediately captivated by its charming location and cozy atmosphere. The wooden accents and warm lighting created the perfect ambiance for enjoying a delicious eggnog.

The service at Onieal's was nothing short of outstanding. The attentive staff went above and beyond to ensure my experience was exceptional. They were knowledgeable about their drinks menu and offered helpful recommendations.

But let's get to the star of the show – the eggnog. Drumroll, please! Onieal's eggnog is nothing short of awesome. Creamy, smooth, and perfectly spiced, it transported me to a winter wonderland with each sip. The balance of flavors was simply exquisite, with just the right amount of sweetness and hints of warming spices.

As I savored my eggnog, I couldn't help but be impressed by the overall experience at Onieal's. It's not just about the eggnog here; it's the combination of outstanding service, great food, and a charming location that make it truly exceptional.

If you find yourself in NYC during the holiday season, Onieal's is a must-visit for eggnog enthusiasts. Prepare your taste buds for a delightful journey, and don't forget to savor every moment.

In the ever-evolving world of eggnog, Onieal's stands out as a gem that truly deserves its place in the spotlight. Cheers to an eggcellent experience!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Tommy Bahama Restaurant, Bar & Store

Hey there eggnog enthusiasts! As an expert on all things creamy and holiday-inspired, I just had to check out Tommy Bahama Restaurant, Bar & Store in NYC for their take on this classic festive drink. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The creamy texture was simply divine, and the flavor was a harmonious blend of rich spices and hints of rum. This is definitely one eggnog that will transport you straight to the Caribbean. Don't miss out on this tropical twist on a holiday favorite!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Pete's Tavern

Pete's Tavern in NYC is a delightful spot for eggnog enthusiasts like myself! The cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and creamy concoction make it a must-visit for any eggnog aficionado in search of the perfect blend of flavors. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Goodnight Sonny

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Goodnight Sonny in NYC, on my quest for the best eggnog in town. Let me tell you, this place did not disappoint. From the cozy ambiance to the creamy perfection of their eggnog, it was a delightful experience. Goodnight Sonny definitely deserves a spot on the list of NYC's top-notch eggnog destinations.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Forgtmenot

Forgtmenot in NYC was a delightful surprise in my quest for the best eggnog in the city. The cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and rich, creamy eggnog made it an instant favorite. The hint of nutmeg and cinnamon gave it a warm and comforting flavor. It's a must-visit spot for any eggnog aficionado.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Death & Co

Whoa, let me just tell you, Death & Co knows how to shake up a tantalizing eggnog! The flavors in their concoction are so rich and bold, it's like a party in your mouth. Creamy, luscious, and perfectly spiced, this eggnog is on another level. Trust me, you won't want to miss out on this heavenly delight.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Miracle on 9th St

Miracle on 9th St in NYC is a festive wonderland serving up some seriously remarkable eggnog. Every sip transports you to North Pole nirvana with its creamy richness, hints of nutmeg, and a delicious boozy kick. Trust me, this place is a holiday miracle for all eggnog lovers!

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Rice To Riches

Rice To Riches is an eggnog enthusiast's dream come true! Their creamy concoction is pure bliss. The eggnog itself is velvety and bursting with rich flavors, a perfect blend of sweetness and spice. Every sip transports you to eggnog heaven. Don't miss this one!

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Sundaes and Cones

Sundaes and Cones in NYC, what a delicious adventure! Their eggnog is a smooth and creamy concoction, with just the right amount of spice and a touch of nutmeg. Each sip takes you on a jolly journey, leaving you wanting more!

Tipsy Scoop

Tipsy Scoop, a delightful ice cream parlor in NYC, is an absolute game-changer for eggnog enthusiasts. Their boozed-up concoctions, like the Pumpkin Eggnog and Spiced Bourbon Eggnog, will take you on a merry ride. Creamy, flavorful, and packing a pleasant buzz, Tipsy Scoop's eggnogs are heavenly treats that shouldn't be missed on your quest for the best in the Big Apple!