Long Island's Best Dinner [Updated 2025]

What’s the secret to a perfect dinner on Long Island? Well, after exploring 12 of the hottest spots, I can confidently say it’s all about flavor, atmosphere, and that little something special that keeps you coming back for more. Whether you’re in the mood for a cozy Italian trattoria or a chic seafood haven, I’ve tasted it all and I’m here to spill the beans on my favorites.

Having spent years indulging in the culinary delights that this beautiful island has to offer, I know what to look for in a standout dining experience. Get ready to discover hidden gems and beloved classics that will elevate your next meal into something truly unforgettable!

Crabtree's Restaurant

Highlights
Cozy, homey atmosphere
Lively, respectful staff
Fresh, well-seasoned food
Quick kitchen service
Great outdoor dining option

Crabtree's Restaurant truly captures the essence of a delightful dining experience, embodying both warmth and sophistication in every detail. As I entered, the cozy, homey atmosphere wrapped around me like a favorite sweater. The decor whispers comfort, making it a perfect spot to unwind after a long day.

What struck me next was the lively and respectful staff. Each member greeted guests with genuine smiles, effortlessly blending professionalism with a friendly demeanor. It’s always refreshing to be treated like family, even amid the hustle and bustle.

And then, the food whisked me away on a flavor journey! Each dish was fresh and well-seasoned, showcasing the kitchen's commitment to quality. The menu is thoughtfully curated, presenting an array of delightful choices that cater to various palates. One moment I was savoring a succulent entrée, and the next, I found myself enchanted by their delightful sides.

The quick kitchen service ensured I never felt rushed—just perfectly timed to savor each bite. Plus, the option for outdoor dining added an extra touch of charm, making it an ideal spot to enjoy a meal under the stars.

If you're searching for an unforgettable dinner, I wholeheartedly recommend Crabtree's.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

OHK Bar & Restaurant

Highlights
Excellent food & desserts
Spectacular views and grounds
Nice and friendly staff
Suitable for large events
Clean and spacious facilities

During my recent visit to OHK Bar & Restaurant, I felt as though I had stumbled upon a hidden gem in Long Island. Nestled within picturesque grounds, the scenic views immediately captured my attention, serving as a stunning backdrop for what was to come. The menu is a delightful adventure, showcasing a variety of dishes that are not just expertly prepared but also a treat for the eyes. Each bite was a celebration of flavors that left me yearning for more.

The staff was incredibly friendly and attentive, making the atmosphere warm and inviting. It’s clear they take pride in providing excellent service, which elevates the dining experience. I also appreciated how clean and spacious the restaurant is, making it perfect for large gatherings or intimate dinners alike. My visit would not have been complete without indulging in their exquisite desserts—a fitting finale that sweetened the entire experience.

Overall, OHK Bar & Restaurant is a true standout in Long Island’s dining scene. I walked away delighted, with lingering flavors and a yearning to return. If you’re searching for a dinner that pleases both the palate and the eye, look no further than this treasure!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Lakehouse

Stepping into Lakehouse was like entering a culinary wonderland! The sublime ambiance sets the stage for a delightful evening. I indulged in their renowned seafood, and each bite was a testament to freshness and expert craftsmanship. The pan-seared scallops were perfectly caramelized, dancing with flavor alongside a vibrant pea purée. Of course, I couldn't resist their decadent chocolate torte for dessert—pure bliss! The service was attentive yet unobtrusive, making the evening even more enjoyable. If you’re looking for an unforgettable dinner experience, Lakehouse is a must-visit gem on Long Island. Bon appétit!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

LOLA

Upon stepping into LOLA, I was immediately enveloped by a warm, inviting atmosphere. The menu is a delightful fusion of flavors, each dish showcasing culinary artistry. I savored the grilled octopus, perfectly tender and bursting with Mediterranean flair. The service was impeccable—attentive without being intrusive. I was particularly taken by their signature cocktails, which added a refreshing twist to the evening. Desserts? Don’t skip the chocolate torte, a heavenly finale! Overall, LOLA is a feast for the senses and firmly earns its spot among the best dinner destinations in Long Island. A must-visit for any food lover!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar

Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar left me utterly enchanted! Nestled right on the water, the ambiance strikes a perfect balance between elegance and comfort. I savored their grilled octopus, which was perfectly tender and bursting with flavor. The dry-aged steak stole the show, cooked to perfection with a mouthwatering char. With a cocktail list that showcases creativity, the signature drinks were equally impressive. The staff was attentive yet unobtrusive, making my evening memorable. If you’re looking for a dining experience that tantalizes the senses, Prime is a must-visit on Long Island! 🥂✨

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

The Fifth Season

At The Fifth Season, I was greeted with a delightful fusion of flavors that danced on my palate. The ambiance was intimate yet vibrant, making it the perfect backdrop for a memorable evening. I savored their signature duck confit, which was crispy on the outside and tender within. The seasonal vegetables complemented the dish beautifully, bringing freshness to each bite. Service was attentive without being intrusive, enhancing the overall experience. I left feeling not just satisfied, but inspired. If you're seeking a dinner that celebrates both creativity and taste, look no further than this culinary gem on Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

eatMOSAIC

Nestled in the heart of Long Island, eatMOSAIC is a culinary gem that left me delightfully surprised. From the moment I stepped inside, the vibrant atmosphere piqued my interest, setting the perfect backdrop for an unforgettable evening. I indulged in their exquisite Mediterranean-inspired dishes, particularly the lamb tagine, which was sheer perfection—tender and bursting with flavor. The service was attentive and warm, making me feel right at home. Pair that with a creative cocktail selection, and you have a recipe for an exceptional dinner. For a dining experience that tantalizes the palate, eatMOSAIC is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Tellers: An American Chophouse

At Tellers: An American Chophouse, I was immediately captivated by its upscale yet inviting ambiance. The steaks here are nothing short of legendary; I savored a ribeye that was perfectly marbled and cooked to a sublime medium-rare. The sides—particularly the truffle mac and cheese—are indulgent comforts elevated to art. Don’t miss their extensive wine list, which pairs beautifully with any meal. The attentive staff ensured my evening was as delightful as the cuisine. Overall, Tellers combines a refined atmosphere with exceptional fare, solidifying its status among Long Island's finest dinner spots. A must-visit for meat lovers!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Seasons 52

During my visit to Seasons 52, I was delightfully surprised by the vibrant atmosphere that perfectly complements the fresh, seasonally-inspired menu. Each dish is crafted with locally-sourced ingredients, highlighting the essence of nature’s bounty. The grilled mahi-mahi was nothing short of divine, kissed by charming citrus flavors. And let’s not forget the mini indulgences—the perfect sweet finish! The attentive staff truly elevated the experience with their genuine warmth. If you’re seeking a dinner that balances health-conscious choices with gourmet flair, Seasons 52 is a must-visit on Long Island. It's an experience to savor!

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Blend on the Water

Nestled along the scenic banks, Blend on the Water is a true gem. My evening began with a delightful cocktail that danced on my palate, setting the tone for what was to come. The pan-seared scallops were perfectly cooked, glistening under their charming sauce, while the sundried tomato risotto added a rich, comforting twist. The ambiance was both chic and inviting—ideal for a cozy dinner or a celebratory gathering. Coupled with attentive service and stunning views of the waterfront, dining here is truly an experience that complements the exquisite flavors on your plate. A must-visit for any food lover in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Coco Bistro Kitchen & Lounge

Stepping into Coco Bistro Kitchen & Lounge felt like being welcomed home with open arms! The ambiance is a delightful blend of sophistication and casual charm, perfect for any occasion. I indulged in their signature seafood pasta, which was a divine dance of flavors that left me craving more. The cocktails are equally impressive—don't miss their mango martini, a true delight! With attentive staff and a cozy atmosphere, Coco Bistro is more than just a dining spot; it’s an experience. If you’re seeking a memorable dinner, Coco Bistro is a must-visit treasure on Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best hot chocolate in NYC.

Kyma

At Kyma, the ambiance is as warm as a Greek summer evening. The moment I stepped in, the aroma of grilled octopus danced in the air, beckoning me to indulge. I opted for the lavishly tender lamb chops, which were grilled to perfection, bursting with flavor. The seafood tower was a feast for the eyes, showcasing the freshest catches. Each bite invited me deeper into a culinary journey. The service was attentive yet unobtrusive, enhancing the experience without overwhelming it. If you're longing for a taste of the Mediterranean, Kyma is a gem that shouldn't be missed.

You might also want to check out the best omakase in NYC.