The Absolute Best Deli in Long Island [Updated 2024]

In this article, I will be sharing my top picks from the 12 delis that I have meticulously reviewed. Long Island, being a haven for deli enthusiasts, is home to some hidden gems that will leave your taste buds craving for more.

From traditional pastrami sandwiches to mouthwatering Reubens, these delis have it all. Whether you are in the mood for a hearty breakfast sandwich or a delectable bagel with lox, this guide will help you navigate through the myriad of options.

So sit back, relax, and get ready to embark on a culinary journey as we explore the best deli in Long Island.

L & M Italian Deli And Catering

Highlights
Phenomenal food
Best caterer
Excellent dishes
Well-priced
Go-to deli

Walking into L & M Italian Deli And Catering, I immediately knew I had found something special. This hidden gem quickly rose to the top of my list as the best deli on Long Island.

Let's talk about the food. Oh, the food! With every bite, I was transported to the streets of Naples. Their menu is a cornucopia of deliciousness. From hearty meatball heroes to delicate prosciutto-wrapped melon, every dish was simply excellent. The flavors were so authentic, it felt like Nonna had personally prepared each dish.

But it doesn't stop there. L & M Italian Deli And Catering also happens to be the best caterer in town. If you have an upcoming event, do yourself a favor and let them take care of your guests. Their attention to detail and presentation will leave you speechless.

And let me tell you about the prices. Well-priced is an understatement. They offer generous portions at reasonable prices without ever sacrificing quality. It's no wonder L & M Italian Deli And Catering has become the go-to deli for locals and visitors alike.

So if you're looking for a phenomenal deli experience in Long Island, look no further than L & M Italian Deli And Catering. Their commitment to flavor, value, and excellence is unmatched. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Manhattan.

Delicacies Gourmet Delicatessen Catering New York

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming staff
Huge food selection
Fast service
Beautiful view of the pond
Incredible and fresh food

Upon entering, I was greeted by the friendly and welcoming staff, who immediately made me feel at home. The deli's interior was spacious and clean, with a cozy atmosphere that made it the perfect place to enjoy a meal. As I perused the menu, I was amazed by the huge food selection. From sandwiches and wraps to salads and hot entrees, there was something to satisfy every craving.

I placed my order and was pleasantly surprised by the fast service. The staff worked diligently, ensuring that each customer was served promptly. As I waited for my food, I took a seat near the window and admired the beautiful view of the pond outside. It provided a serene backdrop that elevated the dining experience.

When my meal arrived, I was blown away by the quality and taste. Every bite was bursting with flavor, a testament to the incredible and fresh ingredients used. The deli truly lived up to its reputation as one of the best in Long Island.

Overall, my visit to Delicacies Gourmet Delicatessen Catering New York was a delightful experience. From the friendly staff to the wide selection of mouthwatering dishes, this deli has it all. If you're in Long Island and looking for a deli that offers amazing food, excellent service, and a pleasant ambiance, make sure to pay them a visit. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Atlantic Avenue Deli & Catering

Highlights
Great service
Tasty sandwiches
Opens early
Good coffee

Upon entering Atlantic Avenue Deli & Catering, I was immediately greeted by friendly staff who provided great service with a genuine smile. This set the tone for a delightful deli experience.

As I perused the menu, I couldn't help but notice the wide array of tasty sandwiches available. From classic favorites like pastrami on rye to unique creations layered with diverse flavors, there was something to please every palate. Each sandwich was made with care, using only the freshest ingredients, and the end result was a delicious masterpiece.

What truly impressed me about Atlantic Avenue Deli & Catering was its commitment to customer convenience. The deli opens early, making it the perfect spot to grab a hearty breakfast or a satisfying lunch before heading to work. Not to mention, the aroma of the good coffee brewing in the background only added to the pleasant atmosphere.

Every aspect of my experience at Atlantic Avenue Deli & Catering was a delightful surprise. The combination of great service, mouthwatering sandwiches, early hours, and delicious coffee truly sets this deli apart from the crowd.

If you find yourself in Long Island and in need of a deli that excels in both taste and customer satisfaction, do yourself a favor and visit Atlantic Avenue Deli & Catering. Trust me, you won't leave disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Apple Gourmet deli lic

Apple Gourmet deli lic in Long Island is a hidden gem that deserves to be on the list of the best delis in town. The experience was a delightful combination of playful and professional. The sandwiches were exquisite, bursting with flavors that danced on my taste buds. Don't miss this place!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Cherry Valley Deli

Cherry Valley Deli in Long Island is a sandwich lover's paradise. With an extensive menu and irresistible creations like the "Godfather" loaded with Italian meats and cheeses, this place knows how to satisfy cravings. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make it a top contender for the best deli in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Kensington Kosher Delicatessen

As soon as I stepped into Kensington Kosher Delicatessen, I knew I was in for a treat. The smell of freshly baked bread wafted through the air, and my mouth started watering before I even laid eyes on the menu. The staff welcomed me with warm smiles, eager to guide me through their extensive selection of delectable delights.

I couldn't resist starting with their famous pastrami sandwich. The first bite was a revelation. The meat was perfectly tender and brimming with smoky flavor, sandwiched between two slices of soft rye bread. Each mouthful was a harmonious dance of flavors that had me practically swooning with delight.

Not content with just one dish, I decided to explore more of their menu. The matzo ball soup, a classic deli staple, was like a warm hug for my soul. The matzo balls were fluffy and light, floating amidst a flavorful broth that was seasoned to perfection. It was the ideal companion to my main course.

Speaking of main courses, Kensington Kosher Delicatessen offers an array of options to satisfy any craving. Whether you're in the mood for a succulent corned beef sandwich, a hearty knish, or a tangy kosher pickle, this place has got you covered.

What truly sets Kensington Kosher Delicatessen apart is their attention to detail and commitment to quality. Every ingredient used in their dishes is fresh, chosen with care, and it shines through in every bite.

As I finished up my meal, I couldn't help but feel a sense of nostalgia. Kensington Kosher Delicatessen reminds me of the delis of old, where flavor, quality, and hospitality were the cornerstones of a great dining experience.

In conclusion, Kensington Kosher Delicatessen is a treasure among delis in Long Island. If you're looking for a place to indulge in authentic Jewish deli cuisine that will satisfy both your taste buds and your soul, look no further. They deserve the title of being one of the best delis in Long Island, hands down.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Country Plaza Delicatessen

I devoured the most delicious pastrami sandwich at Country Plaza Delicatessen. The meat was tender, melting in my mouth with each bite. The abundance of toppings and the perfectly toasted bread made this sandwich a truly flavor-packed masterpiece. Don't miss out on this gem when searching for the best deli in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Meera Deli

Meera Deli in Long Island, oh my! This place is a hidden gem in the deli landscape. The sandwiches are so satisfying, with ingredients that dance a tango in your mouth. The homemade pickles? Chef's kiss. If you're craving a unique and flavorful deli experience, Meera Deli is not to be missed.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Harbor Deli

I must say, it was love at first bite! The exquisite selection of sandwiches and wraps left me in culinary heaven. The flavor explosion of the ingredients blew my taste buds away. The friendly staff and inviting atmosphere make Harbor Deli a must-visit spot for all deli enthusiasts in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Hinck's

Hinck's in Long Island was like discovering a delicious treasure trove of deli delights. From the moment I walked in, the friendly staff made me feel like family. The smells of freshly baked bread and sizzling meats danced in the air, making my mouth water. The menu was overflowing with options, from classic turkey clubs to creative sandwich combinations that could satisfy any craving. The quality of the ingredients was top-notch, with succulent meats, flavorful cheeses, and fresh produce. The sandwiches were masterpieces, overflowing with layers of goodness, and the warm, crispy bread was the perfect vessel to hold it all together. Hinck's not only nailed the taste department, but their attention to detail in presentation was remarkable. Each sandwich was crafted with care, making it a feast for the eyes as well as the taste buds. The atmosphere was cozy, with nostalgic deli memorabilia adorning the walls, adding to the charm. What impressed me the most was the efficiency and speed of service, even during busy lunch hours. The staff worked like a well-oiled machine, ensuring that customers didn't have to wait long to enjoy their mouthwatering creations. Overall, Hinck's in Long Island is a standout deli that checks all the boxes for what makes a deli great. It's a place where flavor and friendliness come together, leaving you satisfied and longing for your next visit.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Long Island City Family Deli

Long Island City Family Deli in Long Island is a delightful hidden gem! This cozy deli offers a playful yet professional atmosphere that will make you feel right at home. Their diverse menu is filled with a variety of scrumptious options. From their mouthwatering sandwiches to their hearty soups, every bite is a flavor explosion! Don't miss the chance to indulge in their delicious desserts, as they truly take the cake. With fast and friendly service, this deli is a must-visit for any food enthusiast. So grab your appetite and head on down to Long Island City Family Deli for a tasty experience you won't forget!

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Yashi Deli & Grocery

I have to say, Yashi Deli & Grocery in Long Island left me pleasantly surprised. This hidden gem delivers deliciousness in every bite. Their sandwiches are a symphony of flavors, with generous portions and impeccably fresh ingredients. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere only add to the overall charm.