2025 Ranked: Best Cupcakes in Long Island

As I dove into the sweet world of frosting and fluffy cake, I made it my mission to uncover the top 13 cupcake spots that Long Island has to offer. Trust me, I didn’t just grab a cupcake here and there; I meticulously tasted, savored, and compared flavors, textures, and, of course, that all-important icing swirl.

With years of indulging in local treats and an insatiable sweet tooth, I’ve developed a pretty good sense of what makes a cupcake truly special. Whether you’re a chocolate lover or a fan of fruity delights, I’ve got the inside scoop on where to satisfy your cravings. Let’s embark on this delicious journey together!

Crazy Cakes Cafe

Highlights
Amazing cake
Beautiful decor
Specialty cakes
Delicious cupcakes
Fun atmosphere

Walking into Crazy Cakes Cafe was like stepping into a whimsical world of sugary delight. The first thing that caught my eye was the beautiful decor that adorned the walls, with colorful sprinkles and cupcakes painted everywhere. It set the tone for the fun and vibrant atmosphere that was to come.

I was immediately greeted by the friendly staff who were more than happy to take me through their extensive menu. While Crazy Cakes Cafe is known for their specialty cakes, I couldn't resist sinking my teeth into their delicious cupcakes. Each one looked like a work of art, with perfectly swirled frosting and delicate sprinkles on top.

My taste buds were in for a treat as I indulged in the amazing flavors of their cupcakes. From classics like chocolate and vanilla, to more unique options like red velvet and salted caramel, every bite was a burst of sweetness. The cake was incredibly moist and tender, and the frosting was light and fluffy. It was clear that a lot of care and attention to detail went into crafting each cupcake.

Besides the exquisite taste, Crazy Cakes Cafe truly knows how to create a fun atmosphere. Whether you're a kid or a kid at heart, the cafe provides a space where you can fully embrace your love for all things sweet. It's the perfect place to gather with friends, celebrate special occasions, or simply satisfy your cupcake cravings.

If you're looking for a place that offers not only amazing cake but also a memorable experience, I highly recommend paying a visit to Crazy Cakes Cafe in Long Island. It's like stepping into a modern-day Willy Wonka's chocolate factory, where you'll find some of the best cupcakes the island has to offer.

You might also want to check out the best chicken sandwich in Brooklyn.

SPOTS NYC

Highlights
Magic for baking
Delicious treats
Cozy atmosphere
Excellent service
Fast turn around

When I first walked into SPOTS NYC, I immediately felt a sense of magic in the air. The aroma of freshly baked cupcakes filled the cozy atmosphere, and my taste buds were already anticipating the delicious treats that awaited me.

The selection of cupcakes at SPOTS NYC was truly impressive. From classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate to unique creations like red velvet and salted caramel, there was something for every cupcake lover. Each cupcake was beautifully decorated with intricate designs, making it almost too pretty to eat.

After careful consideration, I decided on the red velvet cupcake. As I took my first bite, I was transported to cupcake heaven. The cake was moist and fluffy, perfectly complemented by the rich cream cheese frosting. It was a divine combination that left me craving for more.

What stood out to me about SPOTS NYC was not only the delicious cupcakes but also the exceptional service. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, taking the time to answer any questions I had about their cupcakes. They also worked quickly and efficiently, ensuring that customers had a fast turn around time.

Overall, my experience at SPOTS NYC was nothing short of delightful. The magic for baking was evident in every bite, and the cozy atmosphere made me feel right at home. If you're looking for the best cupcakes in Long Island, SPOTS NYC is definitely a spot worth visiting.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

The Sweet Peace

Highlights
Kind and caring staff
Delicious and complimented
Beautiful and realistic

Upon entering the bakery, I was immediately greeted by the kind and caring staff who made me feel right at home. They eagerly offered their expertise and guidance as I embarked on the delightful journey of choosing the perfect cupcake.

Now, let's talk about the main event – the cupcakes themselves. Each bite was a delicious explosion of flavors, leaving me wanting more. The cupcakes were moist, perfectly baked, and beautifully decorated. It was clear that a lot of love and passion went into creating these delectable treats. The Sweet Peace truly understands the art of balancing flavors to create a harmonious taste sensation.

One thing that impressed me was the attention to detail in the decorations. The cupcakes were not only delicious but also stunning. The designs were intricate and so realistic that it seemed almost a shame to eat them. I found myself torn between admiring their beauty and devouring their scrumptiousness.

Overall, my experience at The Sweet Peace was nothing short of delightful. The kind and caring staff, the delicious and complimented flavors, and the beautiful and realistic decorations all combined to create a cupcake experience that was truly top-notch. If you're a cupcake enthusiast like me, this bakery is a must-visit in Long Island. Stop by The Sweet Peace and let your taste buds be amazed!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Smallcakes Patchogue: Cupcakery & Creamery

Smallcakes Patchogue: Cupcakery & Creamery in Long Island is a delightful spot to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings. With a wide selection of mouthwatering cupcakes and creamy ice cream, they offer a treat for every taste bud. The bakery's attention to detail in their meticulously decorated cupcakes is simply impressive. Don't miss the chance to indulge in these delectable delights - they're worth every calorie!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Nothing Bundt Cakes

Nothing Bundt Cakes in Long Island blew me away with their cupcakes! The flavors were out of this world, and the presentation was stunning. The moist and fluffy cakes were perfectly complemented by the rich and creamy frosting. With a wide variety of flavors to choose from, this place is a cupcake lover's dream. Trust me, Nothing Bundt Cakes knows how to make your taste buds dance!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

N Y Cupcakery

N Y Cupcakery in Long Island is a cupcake lover's haven! With their wide assortment of flavors, from classic vanilla to adventurous bacon maple, there's something for everyone. The cupcakes are moist, fluffy, and topped with creamy, indulgent frosting. Don't miss out on this hidden gem!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Smallcakes Syosset

Smallcakes Syosset in Long Island is a cupcake gem! With each bite, I was transported to a sugary wonderland. The moist and flavorful cupcakes melted in my mouth, leaving me craving more. The staff was friendly, and the cozy atmosphere made me feel right at home. It's safe to say that Smallcakes Syosset is cupcake bliss!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Baked by Melissa

Baked by Melissa in Long Island is a true cupcake extravaganza. With their mini creations, every bite is like a party in your mouth. From classics like red velvet to funky flavors like cookie dough, there's something for every taste bud. Don't forget to snag a few extra to enjoy later - trust me, you'll want them!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Buttercooky Bakery & Café

Buttercooky Bakery & Café in Long Island is a heavenly cupcake destination. The cupcakes are utterly divine, with moist cake and dreamy frosting. The flavors range from classic to innovative, satisfying even the pickiest sweet tooth. Don't miss their irresistible red velvet cupcake - it's pure bliss!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

The Cake Don

The Cake Don in Long Island definitely knows how to whip up some serious cupcake magic. From the moment I walked through the door, the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked treats greeted me. The Cupcakes here are moist, flavorful and topped with swirls of heavenly frosting. Trust me, this place is a cupcake haven!

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Sugarberry Bakery Cafe

Sugarberry Bakery Cafe in Long Island is a sweet haven for cupcake lovers. With their delicate pastel decor and irresistible aroma, I indulged in their decadent cupcakes. The moist cake and creamy frosting were a match made in cupcake heaven. Its whimsical flavor combinations will leave you craving for more.

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Taste Crème

Taste Crème in Long Island was a cupcake wonderland! From their velvety Red Velvet to their captivating Salted Caramel, each bite transported me to a sweet utopia. The cupcakes were moist and delectable, adorned with buttercream so heavenly I could almost hear the angels singing. Don't miss out on this dessert paradise!

You might also want to check out the best hot chocolate in NYC.

Sweet Serindipty

At Sweet Serindipty, each cupcake is a delightful masterpiece bursting with flavor. The Red Velvet is a standout; its rich cream cheese frosting complements the moist cake perfectly. I also savored the Salted Caramel, which delivered a heavenly balance of sweet and savory. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make this spot feel like a home away from home. Each bite feels like a warm hug, and I left with a smile—plus a box of cupcakes to enjoy later! If you’re on the hunt for a sweet treat, this charming bakery should definitely be on your list.

You might also want to check out the best omakase in NYC.