Long Island's Best Cookies [Updated 2025]

As I dove into this delicious quest, I visited 12 of the top cookie spots across Long Island, indulging in everything from classic chocolate chip to whimsical creations that push the boundaries of flavor. With countless taste tests and a few sugar highs behind me, I can confidently say that these cookies aren’t just treats; they’re experiences that capture the heart and soul of our island.

Trust me, I’ve sifted through the good, the great, and the mind-blowingly awesome to bring you only the finest. So, whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through, you’re about to discover the sweet spots you absolutely can’t miss!

Chip City

Highlights
Blueberry Cheesecake favorite
Gooey chocolate indulgence
Thick and fluffy texture
Variety of unique flavors
Consistent quality experience

Chip City is truly a cookie lover's paradise right here in Long Island! As soon as I stepped inside, the sweet aroma enveloped me like a warm hug. I dove right in, and their Blueberry Cheesecake cookie quickly became my favorite. The delightful blend of flavors had me dreaming of summer days!

Each bite was a gooey chocolate indulgence that made my taste buds sing. I was astonished by the thick and fluffy texture—it was soft enough to melt in my mouth yet had just the right amount of bite.

What stood out to me was the variety of unique flavors; from classic chocolate chip to adventurous combinations, there's something for everyone. I appreciated the consistent quality experience; every cookie I sampled was fresh and flavorful, just as I hoped.

If you find yourself in Long Island and have a craving for cookies, Chip City should certainly be your destination. These delightful cookies aren’t just treats; they’re a joyful experience that you won’t want to miss! So, grab a friend, order a few (or a dozen), and prepare to smile with every bite.

You might also want to check out the best corned beef sandwich in NYC.

Buttercooky Bakery & Café

Highlights
Delicious decadent pastries
Fluffy chocolate flavor
Wide selection of treats
Friendly staff
Good fruit options

Buttercooky Bakery & Café conveniently stands out in the bustling world of cookie lovers on Long Island. As I stepped inside, the delightful aroma of baked goods greeted me, whispering sweet promises of sugary bliss. Their wide selection of treats instantly caught my eye, but I was particularly drawn to their cookies—each one a tempting masterpiece.

I dove right into a fluffy chocolate cookie, and let me tell you, it was nothing short of decadent. The rich, chocolate flavor enveloped my taste buds, creating a delightful whirlwind of sweetness. What impressed me further were the fruit options, which offered a refreshing contrast that kept my palate engaged. Buttercooky clearly understands the balance between traditional flavors and inventive twists.

Moreover, the friendly staff contributed significantly to my overall experience. They were eager to recommend favorites and share their passion for each treat, enhancing the cozy atmosphere. I found myself chatting with them as I savored my cookie, making it feel less like a transaction and more like a warm gathering.

In the grand tale of Long Island's cookie scene, Buttercooky Bakery & Café undoubtedly holds a sweet chapter. Come for the cookies, stay for the scrumptious experience!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Duchess Cookies

Duchess Cookies is a delightful gem that will whisk you away on a cookie adventure. The moment I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked treats enveloped me like a warm hug. I indulged in their signature “Duchess Deluxe,” which boasts a perfectly chewy center and a crispy edge—pure bliss! Each bite revealed a harmonious blend of rich chocolate and subtle vanilla. What truly sets Duchess apart is their commitment to local ingredients, enhancing every cookie with a touch of Long Island charm. If you’re a cookie lover, you simply cannot miss this place! 🍪✨

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Thin Cookies

Upon stepping into Thin Cookies, I was instantly welcomed by the mouthwatering aroma of baking sweets. Their signature cookies are delightfully thin, yet somehow bursting with flavor. I savored the salted caramel chocolate chip—a delicate balance of sweet and salty that danced on my taste buds. The texture? Perfectly crisp edges with a soft center, making each bite a delight. Their creative flavor combinations, like lavender lemon, ensured I was on a whimsical cookie adventure. Overall, Thin Cookies elevates the humble cookie to an art form that’s simply hard to resist. A must-visit for any cookie enthusiast in Long Island! 🍪✨

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Mama's Custom Cookies

Mama's Custom Cookies is a delightful haven for cookie lovers! From the moment I stepped inside, the sweet aroma instantly transported me to cookie paradise. I indulged in their signature chocolate chip cookies, perfectly chewy with a golden crust—each bite bursting with melted chocolate. The oatmeal raisin option was a surprise, featuring a soft yet hearty texture with just the right amount of cinnamon. What sets Mama's apart is their ability to customize; I even spotted an intriguing lavender honey variety! Overall, Mama’s Custom Cookies is a must-visit destination for anyone craving delicious, creative, and satisfying treats in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

The Cookie Shop

Stepping into The Cookie Shop felt like entering a cookie lover's paradise! Their signature chocolate chip cookies are warm, gooey, and packed with melty chocolate, making every bite a delightful experience. The snickerdoodles, dusted with cinnamon sugar, offer a perfect balance of sweet and spice, evoking a sense of nostalgia. I also had the pleasure of tasting their seasonal specials, which were inventive and delicious. With cozy decor and a friendly atmosphere, this charming spot is a must-visit for anyone seeking the ultimate cookie indulgence in Long Island. Don't miss it—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Cookie Crumz

At Cookie Crumz, every bite is a delightful surprise! Their signature Crumble Chip cookie is a game-changer—soft, gooey, and loaded with chocolate chips that just melt in your mouth. The distinct layering of flavors and textures is truly artful. I also indulged in the Salted Caramel Crunch, where sweet meets savory in the most delicious way possible. Each cookie feels like a warm hug, and the cozy ambiance makes you want to linger a little longer. If you’re seeking a cookie that’s both inventive and comforting, Cookie Crumz is a must-visit gem on Long Island! 🍪✨

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Lavender Cupcakery & Dessert Shoppe

At Lavender Cupcakery & Dessert Shoppe, I was swept away by their delightful Lavender Honey Cookies. These are not merely cookies; they’re little bites of heaven! The subtle floral notes blend perfectly with the sweetness, creating a harmonious flavor profile that's both intriguing and comforting. Baked to perfection, they achieve a wonderful balance of crisp edges and a soft, chewy center. The shop itself is a whimsical experience, with a charming vibe that complements its delectable sweets. If you’re on the hunt for an unforgettable cookie experience, this gem deserves a top spot on your list! 🍪✨

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Best Cookies Shop NYC / New York Bakery Cookies/ The Cookie Outlet

At Best Cookies Shop NYC, I was greeted by an intoxicating aroma of baked goodness. The moment I sunk my teeth into their decadent chocolate chip cookie, I was transported to cookie heaven; the gooey center paired perfectly with a slightly crisp edge. Their oatmeal raisin cookies had a delightful chewiness that reminded me of warm family gatherings. As I indulged in the peanut butter variety, the rich flavor enveloped my palate, making it hard to eat just one. This shop is truly an absolute gem for cookie lovers on Long Island, where every bite is a delicious celebration of flavors!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Sweet Temptation Desserts

The moment I walked into Sweet Temptation Desserts, I was greeted by the divine aroma of freshly baked goods. My taste buds tingled in anticipation as I sampled their signature chocolate chip cookies—a perfect balance of gooey chocolate and buttery crunch. Each bite was a delightful symphony that danced on my palate. Additionally, their oatmeal raisin cookies offered a chewy texture and a hint of cinnamon that was simply irresistible. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, this gem is a must-visit for anyone seeking cookie bliss on Long Island. I left with my heart—and my cookie jar—full!

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Uncle Joey’s Rainbow Explosion

Stepping into Uncle Joey’s Rainbow Explosion was like finding a treasure chest of joy! These cookies are a kaleidoscope of flavors, each bite bursting with vibrant, colorful sprinkles that brighten your day. The chewy texture is perfectly complemented by a hint of nostalgia, recalling childhood delights. I tried their signature cookie, and it was a delicious symphony of soft dough and sweet surprises. What truly sets them apart is the sheer creativity that goes into each batch. If you're on a quest for joyful treats, this place is a must-visit in Long Island. Indulge your sweet tooth—it’s worth it!

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Sensible Edibles Bakery

At Sensible Edibles Bakery, I discovered a delightful cookie haven! Their chocolate chip cookies are nothing short of heavenly—soft, warm, and loaded with gooey chocolate goodness. Each bite feels like a warm hug on a chilly day. The oatmeal raisin cookies offer a surprising twist; they’re perfectly spiced and not overly sweet, allowing the flavors to shine. The bakery exudes a cozy charm, making it a perfect stop for cookie lovers. If you’re on Long Island, do yourself a flavor favor and indulge in these remarkable treats—you won’t regret it! 🍪

You might also want to check out the best hot chocolate in NYC.