The Absolute Best Cakes in Long Island [Updated 2024]

After sampling a staggering number of cakes from a variety of bakeries across Long Island, I am delighted to share my findings with you. With a total of twelve establishments thoroughly reviewed, I can confidently proclaim that this guide is the epitome of cake wisdom.

Whether you have a insatiable craving for decadent chocolate, a penchant for delicate fruit flavors, or a love for classic vanilla, this comprehensive list has got you covered. From traditional bakeries to hidden gems, Long Island offers a delightful array of cake options that will leave your taste buds dancing with joy.

Join me on this mouthwatering journey that celebrates the art of cake making.

Sweet Karma Desserts

Highlights
Utterly beautiful
Creative lead
Exceptional detail
Delicious and kind
Above and beyond service

From the moment I stepped inside Sweet Karma Desserts, I was greeted with a display of utterly beautiful cakes that were almost too stunning to eat. The creative lead behind these cakes is truly exceptional, as each creation boasted an incredible level of detail that was simply breathtaking.

As a cake enthusiast, taste is just as important to me as presentation, and Sweet Karma Desserts did not disappoint. The flavors were delightful and the texture was perfectly moist. It was clear that the bakers at Sweet Karma Desserts have mastered their craft.

But it was the customer service that truly set Sweet Karma Desserts apart. The staff was not only knowledgeable about their cakes, but they went above and beyond to ensure that I had a memorable experience. They were kind, patient, and took the time to answer all of my questions.

One of the standout elements of Sweet Karma Desserts is their commitment to going the extra mile for their customers. They happily accommodated my dietary restrictions and provided me with a scrumptious alternative that was just as delicious as their regular offerings.

For anyone looking for the best cakes in Long Island, Sweet Karma Desserts is a must-visit. Their cakes are not only works of art, but they also deliver on flavor and provide exceptional service. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Manhattan.

Catalina's Bake Shop

Highlights
Customized cake
Affordable
Delicious & fresh
Beautiful design
Excellent customer service

From the moment I stepped into Catalina's Bake Shop, I knew I was in for a treat. The display case was filled with an array of beautifully crafted cakes that immediately caught my eye. As I approached the counter, I was greeted by a friendly and knowledgeable staff member who was ready to assist me in finding the perfect cake.

One of the highlights of Catalina's Bake Shop is their option for customized cakes. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, wedding, or any special occasion, Catalina's offers a wide range of designs and flavors to choose from. I was impressed with their attention to detail and their ability to bring any vision to life.

What sets Catalina's apart from other bakeries in Long Island is their commitment to providing affordable yet delicious cakes. It's often difficult to find a bakery that doesn't compromise on taste or quality when it comes to affordability, but Catalina's manages to do just that.

I had the pleasure of trying their signature cake, and I must say, it was a party in my mouth. The cake was delicious and fresh, with each bite bursting with flavor. The cake layers were moist and the frosting was perfectly balanced, not too sweet.

Aside from the taste, the cakes at Catalina's are a work of art. Each creation is meticulously designed with beautiful decorations that are sure to impress your guests. Whether you're looking for a classic design or something more contemporary, Catalina's Bake Shop has got you covered.

Last but not least, the customer service at Catalina's is top-notch. The staff is friendly, attentive, and genuinely passionate about creating the best possible experience for their customers. They listened to my preferences, offered helpful suggestions, and made sure I left the bakery satisfied.

To wrap it up, Catalina's Bake Shop is a true gem in Long Island's cake scene. With their customized options, affordable prices, delicious flavors, beautiful designs, and excellent customer service, it's no wonder they're considered one of the best cake bakeries in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Alpine Pastry Shop

Highlights
Custom cake creations
Delicious and loved by all
Convenient delivery service
Friendly customer service
Unique and beautiful designs

Upon entering Alpine Pastry Shop, I was immediately transported to a world of custom cake creations that seemed almost too beautiful to eat. The display case was filled with an array of tempting flavors and designs, each more unique than the last. As my eyes glided over the scrumptious creations, I couldn't help but feel a sense of anticipation for the cake tasting adventure ahead.

After much deliberation, I finally settled on a slice of their famous red velvet cake. The first bite was pure heaven! The moist and velvety texture melted in my mouth, while the tangy cream cheese frosting balanced the sweetness perfectly. It truly was a slice of bliss!

What impressed me even more was the convenient delivery service offered by Alpine Pastry Shop. They ensured that not only their cakes but also their delectable creations were accessible to everyone in Long Island. I could imagine the joy on the faces of those who have experienced the same cake-induced euphoria as I did.

But what made my experience at Alpine Pastry Shop truly memorable was their friendly customer service. The staff went above and beyond to answer all my questions and help me find the perfect cake for my occasion. Their patience and knowledge truly impressed me.

Alpine Pastry Shop is a must-visit for anyone seeking the best cakes in Long Island. Their delicious creations are loved by all, and their dedication to providing unique and beautiful designs is evident in every bite. So, whether you're celebrating a birthday, anniversary, or simply need a sweet treat, make sure to stop by Alpine Pastry Shop. Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

The Sweet Peace

The Sweet Peace in Long Island is a hidden gem for cake lovers. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by a delightful aroma of freshly baked goods. Their cakes are beautifully decorated and taste even better than they look. Moist, flavorful, and oh-so-decadent, each bite was a little slice of heaven. The staff was friendly and attentive, making sure I found the perfect cake for my occasion. If you're in Long Island and looking for the ultimate cake experience, The Sweet Peace is a must-visit.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Bake Me a Cake! by Angela (made to order custom cakes)

Bake Me a Cake! by Angela is a extraordinary Long Island gem that creates custom cakes that are pure masterpieces. Angela's attention to detail is impeccable and her creativity knows no bounds. Each sweet creation is a delightful surprise and the taste? Divine! Trust me, you won't be able to resist taking a slice (or two).

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Saint Honore Pastry Shop

Located in the heart of Long Island, Saint Honore Pastry Shop is a delightful slice of dessert heaven. From their heavenly Red Velvet to their sinfully decadent Chocolate Mousse Cake, every bite is a sweet symphony of flavors. Their impeccable attention to detail and beautiful presentation make each cake a work of art. Trust me, you won't be able to resist that second slice!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

La Roma Pastry Shop

Oh boy, oh boy! Let me tell you about La Roma Pastry Shop in Long Island - a delightful little spot that serves up some seriously scrumptious cakes! From their velvety smooth textures to their heavenly flavors, these cakes were a party for my taste buds! La Roma Pastry Shop definitely earns a top spot in the best cakes in Long Island article.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

CMNY Cakes

Located in the heart of Long Island, CMNY Cakes is a delightful pastry oasis. With a playful yet professional touch, they craft cakes that make your taste buds dance. From elegant gourmet cakes to whimsical creations, their attention to detail is simply exquisite. Don't miss the chance to indulge in their sugary marvels!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Whistle Stop Desserts

As a cake connoisseur, I simply had to visit Whistle Stop Desserts in Long Island for my quest to find the best cakes in town. And boy, did they deliver! Their cakes are not only visually stunning, but their flavors are an absolute delight. From classic chocolate to exotic fruit combinations, they have something to please every palate. Whistle Stop Desserts truly knows how to whip up a showstopper.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Buttercooky Bakery & Café

Buttercooky Bakery & Café in Long Island is a cake lover's dream come true. Their decadent creations are almost too beautiful to eat. From classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla to unique creations like red velvet cheesecake, every bite is a flavor explosion. The moistness and richness of their cakes are unparalleled and the presentation is picture-perfect. Buttercooky Bakery & Café is definitely a must-visit for cake enthusiasts in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Shero Cakes

Shero Cakes in Long Island is a sweet surprise! From their creative designs to their mouthwatering flavors, every bite feels like a delicious adventure. With their attention to detail and top-notch customer service, it's no wonder Shero Cakes is a rising star in the cake world!

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Dortoni Bakery and Pastry Shoppe

I'm thrilled to say that Dortoni Bakery and Pastry Shoppe takes the cake in Long Island! Their cakes are an absolute delight - moist, flavorful, and beautifully decorated. The shop's ambiance is charming, and the friendly staff adds to the overall experience. A must-visit for cake connoisseurs!