The Absolute Best Burger in Long Island [Updated 2024]

Having grown up in this vibrant region, I hold a deep appreciation for the culinary delights it has to offer. Long Island has its fair share of exceptional burgers that have won the hearts and taste buds of locals and visitors alike.

With my passion for burgers and determination to uncover the hidden gems, I have meticulously reviewed twelve establishments across the island. From quaint diners to trendy gastropubs, these burger joints have left an unforgettable impression on me.

So, prepare yourself for an enticing journey filled with melting cheese, juicy patties, and the perfect ratio of toppings. Get ready to discover the champion of all Long Island burgers!

Haunted House of Hamburgers

Highlights
Amazing atmosphere
Delicious food
Great service
Perfect Halloween vibe
Make reservations

First and foremost, the atmosphere at Haunted House of Hamburgers is truly amazing. From the moment you step inside, you are transported into a spooky, Halloween-themed world. The eerie lighting, cobweb-draped walls, and haunting music create the perfect ambiance for enjoying a delicious burger.

Speaking of burgers, the food at Haunted House of Hamburgers is simply delicious. Each bite is bursting with flavor and made with the finest ingredients. The menu offers a variety of mouthwatering options, from classic cheeseburgers to creative specialty burgers, there is something for every burger lover.

The service at Haunted House of Hamburgers is top-notch. The staff is attentive and friendly, ensuring that your dining experience is nothing short of spectacular. They are knowledgeable about the menu and are more than happy to make recommendations based on your preferences.

What sets Haunted House of Hamburgers apart from other burger joints is its perfect Halloween vibe. The attention to detail in their decorations is impressive, creating a truly immersive experience. It's the perfect place to satisfy your burger cravings while enjoying the spooky spirit of Halloween.

One thing to note is that Haunted House of Hamburgers is popular, so it's a good idea to make reservations to secure your spot. This way, you won't have to wait in line and can dive straight into the delightful world of haunted burgers.

Overall, Haunted House of Hamburgers in Long Island is a must-visit for all burger enthusiasts. The combination of the amazing atmosphere, delicious food, and great service make it a strong contender for the title of the best burger in Long Island. So, why not embrace your inner monster and give it a try? You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

The Burger Spot

Highlights
Delicious
Filling
Quality
Organic
Juicy

As soon as I stepped foot in this charming little eatery, I knew I was in for a treat. The delightful aroma of sizzling burgers greeted me, making my mouth water in anticipation. The menu had a variety of options, but I decided to go for the classic cheeseburger.

When my burger arrived, I couldn't help but notice how beautifully it was presented. The perfectly grilled patty, nestled between a fresh bun, was a sight to behold. I took my first bite, and oh boy, was it a mouthful of heaven! The flavors exploded in my mouth, and each bite was more satisfying than the last.

The highlights of this burger were evident from the first bite. It was delicious, with a harmonious blend of flavors that left me wanting more. The patty was cooked to perfection, juicy and flavorful, while the toppings added just the right amount of crunch and tang. It was filling too, leaving me completely satisfied with every bite.

What sets The Burger Spot apart from others is its dedication to quality ingredients. The use of organic produce and locally sourced meat really elevates the taste of their burgers. Each bite was a testament to the care and passion put into crafting these culinary delights.

Overall, my experience at The Burger Spot was a delightful one. If you're in Long Island and looking for a top-quality, mouthwatering burger, look no further. The Burger Spot is a must-visit for any burger enthusiast. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

All American Hamburger Drive In

Highlights
Nostalgic atmosphere
Consistently good burgers
Quick service
Affordable prices
Popular local spot

Walking into All American Hamburger Drive In took me on a trip down memory lane. The nostalgic atmosphere was undeniable, with its classic signage and cozy diner-style seating. As I settled in, I couldn't help but notice the mouthwatering smell of sizzling burgers enveloping the restaurant.

I wasted no time in ordering their signature burger, and boy, was it a treat! The patty was perfectly cooked, juicy, and packed with flavor. It was clear that their dedication to quality ingredients and preparation was paying off. Each bite was a delightful explosion of taste and texture.

What impressed me most about All American Hamburger Drive In was their consistency. This was not a one-time fluke; they genuinely know how to make a fantastic burger every single time. It's evident that they take pride in their craft and strive for excellence.

The service was swift and efficient, ensuring that my delicious burger was promptly delivered. And the best part? All American Hamburger Drive In offers all this gastronomic goodness at highly affordable prices. It's a win-win situation for both your taste buds and your wallet.

As I savored my meal, I couldn't help but notice the bustling crowds. The locals clearly recognize the outstanding quality this place offers. It's no wonder this spot has become a popular choice for burger enthusiasts in Long Island.

If you find yourself in Long Island and craving a top-notch burger, do yourself a favor and head to All American Hamburger Drive In. You'll be treated to a nostalgic experience, stellar service, and, above all, consistently fabulous burgers.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

CaliBun Burgers & Shakes

CaliBun Burgers & Shakes in Long Island is a taste bud explosion! Their burgers are juicy, oozing with flavor, and perfectly cooked to your liking. The wide variety of toppings and melting cheese choices make every bite a delicious adventure. Wash it down with one of their thick and creamy shakes for the ultimate burger experience. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Petey's Burger

Petey's Burger in Long Island is a hidden gem bursting with flavor. The patty was incredibly juicy and grilled to perfection. The brioche bun was fresh and added a delightful buttery touch. Don't forget to upgrade with their mouthwatering toppings. Petey's Burger is a must-try on your Long Island burger quest.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Okuz Burgers

Get ready for a burger fiesta at Okuz Burgers in Long Island! Their gourmet creations will make your taste buds dance in delight. The patties are juicy and flavorful, with a perfect blend of spices. The buns are pillowy and the toppings are stacked to perfection. Stop by and taste the magic for yourself!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Burger Village

Burger Village in Long Island is a playful paradise for burger lovers on the hunt for the finest patties. Their menu boasts an array of mouthwatering options, from classic beef to exotic bison burgers. The juicy patties are accompanied by freshly sourced ingredients that create a remarkable explosion of flavors in every bite. Whether you're a traditionalist or an adventurous foodie, Burger Village is sure to tantalize your taste buds and leave you craving for more.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Burger Shack

Burger Shack in Long Island, let me tell you, it's like finding a treasure chest full of juicy, mouthwatering goodness. The perfect combination of flavors, melting cheese, and a bun so soft you could use it as a pillow. Trust me, you won't be able to resist taking another decadent bite.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Taby's Burger House

Taby's Burger House is a hidden gem in Long Island! Their burgers are the stuff of dreams, beautifully cooked and bursting with flavor. The juicy patty is perfectly complemented by fresh toppings and a toasted bun. Don't miss out on the crispy fries and homemade milkshakes. Taby's Burger House is a must-visit destination for burger enthusiasts in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

P.S. Burgers

P.S. Burgers in Long Island is a carnivorous paradise! The moment I bit into their signature burger, I was transported to juicy heaven. The patty was perfectly seasoned, oozing with flavorful juices that dance on your tongue. The crispiness of the bacon, and the gooeyness of the cheese, elevated this burger to dizzying heights. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make P.S. Burgers a true gem. In my humble opinion, this place is definitely a strong contender for the title of the best burger in Long Island.

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Burger City

Burger City, tucked away in vibrant Long Island, left me delighted and craving for more. The juicy patty, perfectly cooked with a hint of smokiness, tickled my taste buds. The brioche bun, crisp on the outside and fluffy inside, added a delightful touch. With a heavenly combination of mouthwatering toppings and flavorful sauces, Burger City is a serious contender for the title of the best burger in Long Island.

Smashburger

Oh joy, I had the pleasure of visiting Smashburger in Long Island, a little piece of burger heaven! The juicy, handcrafted patties were masterpieces of bold flavors, perfectly complemented by the freshly baked buns. The endless options for customization elevated this joint to legendary status. Bold, delicious, and simply smashing - this burger deserves a crown!