The Absolute Best Brownies in NYC [Updated 2024]

After reviewing a total of 10 delectable brownie creations across the city, I can confidently say that NYC is a haven for all brownie enthusiasts. From the rich and fudgy to the gooey and decadent, these top-notch sweet treats are sure to satiate even the most discerning palates.

In this comprehensive guide, I will walk you through the must-visit brownie hotspots in the concrete jungle, divulging all the mouthwatering details and insider tips you need to embark on your own brownie adventure. So, prepare to indulge in chocolatey nirvana as we uncover the very best brownies NYC has to offer!

Fat Witch Bakery

Highlights
Easy online ordering
Adorable packaging
Fresh and fudgy brownies
Option to freeze or refrigerate
Great gift idea

As soon as I entered Fat Witch Bakery, I could feel the inviting aroma of freshly baked goodies wafting through the air. I was instantly drawn to their easy online ordering system, which made it a breeze to select my favorite brownies and have them delivered right to my doorstep.

One thing that struck me immediately was the adorable packaging. Each brownie was carefully wrapped in a cute little box, making it the perfect treat to bring to a party or to simply enjoy at home.

Now, let's talk about the brownies themselves. Oh my, they were divine! The brownies at Fat Witch Bakery are fresh and fudgy, with each bite offering a rich, chocolatey goodness that I couldn't resist. The texture was just right – not too dense or too cake-like.

What sets Fat Witch Bakery apart is their option to freeze or refrigerate their brownies. This is perfect for those who want to savor the goodness over a longer period of time. It also makes them an ideal gift idea, as you can send these delicious treats to your loved ones.

In conclusion, if you're searching for the best brownies in NYC, look no further than Fat Witch Bakery. With their easy online ordering, adorable packaging, fresh and fudgy brownies, and the option to freeze or refrigerate, they have truly earned their place among the top brownie bakeries. Don't miss out on this delightful experience – your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Schmackary's

Highlights
Worth the wait
Delicious options
Reasonable pricing
Stay fresh
Dirty Peppermint is the best

Let me start by saying that Schmackary's is totally worth the wait! As soon as I stepped inside this charming bakery, I was greeted by the most delicious aroma of baked goods wafting through the air.

The display case was a sight to behold, filled to the brim with a variety of brownies that beckoned to me with their gooey goodness. From classic flavors like fudge and walnut to more adventurous ones like peanut butter banana and caramel pretzel, there was something to satisfy every brownie lover's cravings.

Not only were the options plentiful, but the pricing was also reasonable, making it a delightful treat without breaking the bank.

But what truly sets Schmackary's brownies apart is their freshness. Each bite was like a warm hug, with a perfect balance of fudgy and decadent. It was evident that these brownies were made with love and attention to detail.

If I had to choose just one standout flavor, it would have to be the Dirty Peppermint. Oh, dear readers, this brownie was a game-changer! The rich, chocolatey base was perfectly complemented by the refreshing burst of peppermint, creating a harmonious blend of flavors that danced upon my taste buds.

Overall, my visit to Schmackary's was a delightful experience that left me craving for more. With their delicious options, reasonable prices, and commitment to freshness, I can confidently say that Schmackary's is a top contender for the best brownie in NYC.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Erin McKenna's Bakery NYC

Highlights
Vegan and gluten-free options
Delicious cupcakes and doughnuts
Amazing brownie cakes
Wide variety of desserts
Must-visit bakery in the area

Erin McKenna's Bakery NYC is an absolute treasure for brownie lovers like myself. With their wide variety of vegan and gluten-free options, this bakery has gone the extra mile to ensure that everyone can indulge in their sweet treats.

Upon entering the bakery, I was immediately entranced by the mouth-watering aroma of freshly baked goods. With an expertly displayed array of cupcakes, doughnuts, and other desserts, I couldn't help but feel like a kid in a candy store. However, it was the brownie section that truly stole my heart.

I couldn't resist trying their famous brownie cakes, and boy, was I glad I did. These decadent delights were the perfect marriage of fudgy and moist, with a rich chocolate flavor that danced on my taste buds. The texture was unbelievably velvety, and every bite was accompanied by a heavenly symphony of flavors.

What impressed me the most about Erin McKenna's Bakery NYC was their commitment to quality and taste. Their brownies boasted an intensity that only the finest ingredients can deliver. Each bite was a delightful journey, leaving me craving more.

Whether you're a vegan, gluten-free, or just a lover of delicious brownies, Erin McKenna's Bakery NYC is a must-visit. Their dedication to creating delectable desserts for all dietary needs is truly commendable. Don't miss an opportunity to experience their amazing brownie creations and the delightful atmosphere of this cozy bakery.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery

While hunting for the best brownies in NYC, I stumbled upon the divine Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery. With their fudgy, gooey, and utterly indulgent brownie, they take the cake (or rather, brownie). The rich chocolate flavor coupled with the perfect balance of sweetness left me in a state of pure bliss. Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery has truly earned its reputation as one of NYC's top spots for brownie lovers.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center

Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center in NYC is a brownie lover's paradise! The brownies are moist, fudgy, and utterly decadent. The rich chocolate flavor is perfectly balanced and sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center gets my vote for one of the best brownies in NYC!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

By the Way Bakery

By the Way Bakery in NYC is a hidden gem for brownie lovers. Their brownies are moist, fudgy, and chocolatey in every bite. The gluten-free twist adds an unexpected charm, making them a delight for everyone. Definitely a must-try for brownie aficionados in the city!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery

Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery in NYC is a brownie wonderland that will make your sweet tooth do a happy dance. Their fudgy creations are irresistibly rich and sinfully indulgent. One bite and you'll be transported to brownie heaven. Trust me, it's a must-visit for all brownie enthusiasts in the Big Apple.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

William Greenberg Desserts

William Greenberg Desserts in NYC is a delightful brownie haven. The moment I sunk my teeth into their luscious, fudgy masterpiece, I knew I had found brownie perfection. With its velvety texture and decadent swirls of chocolate, this place definitely tops the charts. Brownie enthusiasts, dive in!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Insomnia Cookies

I must say, Insomnia Cookies knows how to satisfy those late-night sweet cravings. Their brownies are a chocolate lover's dream, with a fudgy texture and a rich cocoa flavor that will transport you to heaven with each bite. The warm and gooey center is a delightful surprise, making each mouthful an indulgent experience. Whether you're craving a midnight treat or need a pick-me-up during the day, Insomnia Cookies has got your brownie cravings covered.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Bibble & Sip

Bibble & Sip in NYC is a whimsical bakery that takes brownies to new heights of deliciousness. With their gooey centers and crispy edges, these brownies are a chocolate lover's dream. The perfectly balanced sweetness and rich flavor make them a top contender for the best brownies in NYC.

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.