The Absolute Best Birthday Cakes in Brooklyn [Updated 2024]

From classic flavors to innovative designs, I have personally tasted and reviewed a total of 12 birthday cakes in Brooklyn to bring you this comprehensive list. Whether you're looking for a decadent chocolate creation or a whimsical themed cake, this guide will help you find the perfect confection for your special day.

Brooklyn is a hub for culinary excellence, and the birthday cake scene is no exception. Get ready to indulge in delectable treats that will leave you craving for more.

So, let's dive right in and discover the mouthwatering delights that Brooklyn has to offer for your next birthday celebration!

Circo's Pastry Shop

Highlights
Authentic pastries
Cannolis to order
Delicious desserts
Excellent shipping

Walking into Circo's Pastry Shop is like stepping into a delightful pastry wonderland. The smell of freshly baked treats fills the air, and it's impossible not to feel a sense of excitement and anticipation. As I perused their selection of birthday cakes, I couldn't help but be drawn to their beautiful and authentic pastries.

One of the highlights of Circo's Pastry Shop is their ability to customize cakes to order. Whether it's a specific flavor, design, or theme, they can bring your cake dreams to life. I was impressed with the attention to detail and the level of creativity they put into each cake. It's clear that they take great pride in their craft.

The cannolis at Circo's Pastry Shop are something truly special. Made to order, they are filled with a creamy, smooth ricotta filling and topped with a dusting of powdered sugar. The combination of the flaky pastry and the rich filling is simply divine. It's no wonder that Circo's is known for having some of the best cannolis in Brooklyn.

In addition to their amazing cakes and pastries, Circo's Pastry Shop also offers a wide selection of delicious desserts. From classic Italian treats like tiramisu and panna cotta to decadent chocolate mousse cakes, there is something for everyone. Each dessert is made with love and care, resulting in a melt-in-your-mouth experience.

What sets Circo's Pastry Shop apart from other bakeries is their excellent shipping service. Whether you're planning a birthday party for a loved one who lives far away or you simply want to surprise someone with a delicious treat, Circo's can ship their cakes and pastries nationwide. It's a convenient and thoughtful option for those who want to share the joy of a Circo's cake with others.

Overall, Circo's Pastry Shop is a true gem in Brooklyn. With their authentic pastries, customizable cakes, mouthwatering cannolis, and excellent shipping service, they have certainly earned their spot on the list of the best birthday cakes in Brooklyn.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Buttermilk Bakeshop

Highlights
Gorgeous, delicious, gluten free cake
Helped arrange everything from across the country
Calm, cool, and collected throughout
Talented bakers with beautiful work
Custom wedding cakes and amazing tasting

From the moment I stepped into Buttermilk Bakeshop, I was greeted by a delightful aroma of freshly baked goods. I couldn't help but feel excited about what awaited me.

My eyes lit up when I saw the display of gorgeous, delicious, gluten-free cakes. As someone with dietary restrictions, finding a cake that looks and tastes amazing can be a challenge. But Buttermilk Bakeshop exceeded my expectations.

What truly sets Buttermilk Bakeshop apart is their exceptional customer service. Even though I had to arrange everything from across the country, their team was incredibly accommodating. They patiently answered all my questions and made the process seamless.

Throughout the entire experience, the staff remained calm, cool, and collected. Their professionalism and ability to handle any request with ease was truly commendable. It made me feel confident that I had chosen the right place for my birthday cake.

The bakers at Buttermilk Bakeshop are undeniably talented. Their attention to detail and beautiful work is a testament to their skill and passion. Each cake is a work of art, with intricate designs and delicate frosting.

While their focus is primarily on birthday cakes, Buttermilk Bakeshop also specializes in custom wedding cakes. I had the opportunity to taste their flavors, and oh boy, was I blown away! Every bite was bursting with flavor and left me wanting more.

In conclusion, Buttermilk Bakeshop is a must-visit for anyone in search of the best birthday cakes in Brooklyn. Their commitment to quality, attention to detail, and amazing flavors make them stand out from the rest. Don't miss the chance to indulge in their exquisite creations.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

BKLYN Cake

Highlights
Nicest owner
Delicious cupcakes
Pumpkin spice flavor
Wide variety of treats
Oatmeal butterscotch

Upon entering the bakery, I was immediately greeted by the nicest owner, who had a warm smile and a genuine enthusiasm for his amazing creations. I knew I was in for a treat - both literally and figuratively!

The display case was filled with an array of delectable goodies, but my attention was immediately drawn to the delicious cupcakes. From classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla to unique combinations like salted caramel and red velvet, there was something for everyone. I couldn't resist trying the pumpkin spice cupcake, perfectly spiced with a hint of autumn goodness.

But BKLYN Cake doesn't stop at cupcakes. They offer a wide variety of treats to satisfy any sweet tooth. Whether you're in the mood for cookies, macarons, or even a custom birthday cake, they have it all. One standout treat was the oatmeal butterscotch cookie, chewy and buttery with just the right amount of sweetness.

What truly sets BKLYN Cake apart is the attention to detail and quality ingredients used in their creations. Each cake and cupcake is crafted with care, resulting in a flavor explosion in every bite.

If you're searching for the perfect birthday cake in Brooklyn, look no further than BKLYN Cake. With their delightful treats, friendly owner, and a wide selection of flavors to choose from, it's a bakery that truly stands out from the crowd.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Little Cupcake Bakeshop

Located in the heart of Brooklyn, Little Cupcake Bakeshop is a delightful destination for all cake aficionados. With their whimsical selection of flavors and impeccable designs, they truly are the masters of birthdays. Their cakes are divinely delicious and their attention to detail is impressive. Little Cupcake Bakeshop is a must-visit for anyone looking to make their birthday truly unforgettable.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Betty Bakery

Betty Bakery in Brooklyn is a delightful destination for birthday cake connoisseurs. The charming atmosphere and scrumptious selection of cakes will make you say, "I want more Betty please!" The attention to detail in their designs and the melt-in-your-mouth flavor of their cakes truly sets Betty Bakery apart. Don't miss out on their indulgent chocolate cake - it's a slice of heaven!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Doc's Cake Shop

As soon as I entered Doc's Cake Shop in Brooklyn, I was whisked away to a world of sweet dreams. The aroma of freshly baked goods filled the air, and I couldn't help but be drawn towards the display of beautifully decorated birthday cakes. The attention to detail was impeccable, with each cake looking more tempting than the next. I couldn't resist indulging in a slice (or two) and was treated to a taste sensation that left me wanting more. The cake was moist, the frosting was rich and creamy, and the flavors were perfectly balanced. The staff at Doc's Cake Shop were friendly and helpful, making the whole experience even more enjoyable. Whether you're celebrating a milestone or simply want to satisfy your sweet tooth, Doc's Cake Shop is a slice of heaven in Brooklyn.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

JM Cake Boutique

JM Cake Boutique in Brooklyn is a sweet haven for cake enthusiasts. With impeccable presentation and flawless flavors, their birthday cakes are a delight to the taste buds. From classic designs to unique creations, JM Cake Boutique is a must-visit for any cake lover in Brooklyn.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Bay Ridge Bakery

I can confidently say that Bay Ridge Bakery deserves a spot in the article about the best birthday cakes in Brooklyn. Their cakes are a delightful combination of artistry and flavor. The staff at Bay Ridge Bakery are professionals who truly understand the importance of making birthdays special. The cakes not only look stunning, but they also taste amazing. From the moment you step into the bakery, you're greeted with an array of mouthwatering options. Whether you're looking for a classic design or something more unique, Bay Ridge Bakery has got you covered. The cakes are baked to perfection, with moist layers and decadent fillings. The birthday cake I tried was an absolute showstopper, with a gorgeous design and a flavor that had everyone raving. Plus, the prices are quite reasonable for the quality you get. Trust me, a visit to Bay Ridge Bakery will be a treat that you won't regret.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Ten Cake Studio

In my quest to find the best birthday cakes in Brooklyn, I stumbled upon the delightful Ten Cake Studio. This hidden gem of a bakery combines creativity with flawless execution to deliver cakes that are a feast for both the eyes and the taste buds.

From the moment I walked into the whimsical shop, the sweet aroma enveloped me, instantly whetting my appetite. The display case showcased an array of visually stunning creations that looked almost too good to eat. Almost.

After much drooling and indecision, I settled on a whimsical unicorn-themed cake for my friend's birthday. Not only was it a visual masterpiece, but each bite was a delicious dance of moist cake and luscious frosting, leaving me licking my fork for more.

Ten Cake Studio truly takes the art of cake-making to the next level. With their unparalleled attention to detail, unique designs, and irresistible flavors, it's no wonder they deserve a spot on the list of the best birthday cakes in Brooklyn.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Mia's Brooklyn Bakery

I have to say, Mia's Brooklyn Bakery is a hidden gem when it comes to birthday cakes. The moment I stepped into the bakery, I was greeted with the sweet aroma of freshly baked goods. And let me tell you, their cakes are out of this world! From moist, flavorful layers to stunning designs, Mia's really knows how to make a birthday cake that impresses. Whether you're looking for a classic vanilla or a whimsical unicorn cake, they have it all. Don't even get me started on their buttercream frosting—it's creamy, smooth, and downright addicting. The attention to detail in their decorations is top-notch, making each cake a work of art. Plus, the staff at Mia's Brooklyn Bakery is friendly and accommodating, always willing to help you find the perfect cake for your celebration. Prices are reasonable for the quality and craftsmanship you're getting. All in all, Mia's Brooklyn Bakery is a must-visit for anyone in search of the best birthday cake in Brooklyn. So go ahead and indulge—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Martha's Country Bakery

Martha's Country Bakery in Brooklyn truly takes the cake when it comes to birthday celebrations! Their artisanal creations are not only stunning to behold, but they also taste like heaven. From their moist and flavorful cake layers to their luscious frosting, every bite is a symphony of sweetness. Even the pickiest of cake connoisseurs will be delighted by the variety of flavors and designs available. Whether you're craving a classic chocolate cake or a whimsical unicorn creation, Martha's Country Bakery has got you covered. So, next time you're in Brooklyn and in need of a show-stopping birthday cake, don't hesitate to pay a visit to this pastry paradise. Trust me, it's a cake-tastic experience you won't regret!

Cake Ambiance

Oh, let me tell you, Cake Ambiance knows how to make a birthday cake that you'll remember! The playful designs and flawless execution prove that they are the masters of celebration. Don't hesitate to check them out for your next party!