The Absolute Best Bagels in Long Island [Updated 2024]

I grew up on these delectable round wonders, watching the skilled bagel makers hand roll the dough and transform it into a satisfying and flavorful treat. Over the years, I have sampled countless bagels across Long Island, exploring every nook and cranny to find the absolute best.

After careful consideration and extensive taste testing, I have narrowed down my list to the top 12 bagel shops that truly know their craft. From traditional plain bagels to unique creations packed with savory fillings, this guide encompasses the epitome of bagel perfection.

Whether you are a local or a visitor, join me on this mouthwatering journey as we uncover the best bagels Long Island has to offer. Get ready to indulge in a glorious carb-filled adventure that will leave you craving for more.

Bagel Hut

Highlights
Toasted Bagel
Whitefish
Nova with Cream Cheese
Smiling Faces
Customer Satisfaction

If you're looking for a bagel that will take your taste buds on a journey to bagel paradise, then Bagel Hut in Long Island is the place for you. As soon as I entered, I was greeted by the welcoming aroma of freshly toasted bagels, hinting at the deliciousness that awaited me.

I couldn't resist starting my bagel adventure with a classic, a toasted bagel. When I took my first bite, I was instantly transported to breakfast heaven. The outer layer had the perfect crunch, while the inside was chewy and oh-so-satisfying. It was the ideal canvas for the array of toppings available.

For the seafood lovers, Bagel Hut offers a mouthwatering variety of options. I indulged in their delectable whitefish bagel. The whitefish was perfectly seasoned and paired beautifully with the toasted bagel. Each bite was a delicate dance of flavors that left me wanting more.

Now, let me tell you about the Nova with cream cheese. This heavenly creation is a must-try for any bagel aficionado. The creamy cream cheese perfectly complemented the smoked Nova, creating a harmonious balance of flavors that tickled my taste buds.

But it wasn't just the bagels that impressed me; it was the welcoming atmosphere and smiling faces that truly made the experience memorable. The staff at Bagel Hut went above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction, making my visit feel like a special occasion.

If you're on a quest for the best bagels in Long Island, make sure Bagel Hut is on your list. With their perfectly toasted bagels, delightful whitefish, and heavenly Nova with cream cheese, you're guaranteed a bagel experience that will leave you with a smile on your face and a craving for more.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

A&S Bagels

Highlights
Fresh bagels
Great customer service
Best prices
Great bagels

As soon as I walked into A&S Bagels, I was immediately greeted with a warm smile and a friendly "good morning." The great customer service began before I even ordered my first bagel.

One thing that really stood out about A&S Bagels was the freshness of their bagels. As I waited in line, I couldn't help but notice the aroma of freshly baked dough wafting through the air. It was clear that these bagels were made with love and care.

When it came time to order, I was pleasantly surprised by the best prices. For a small price, I was able to indulge in a variety of flavors and toppings, all freshly made and ready to satisfy my bagel cravings.

Now, on to the most important part - the taste test. As I took my first bite, I could feel the slight crispiness on the outside and the perfect chewiness on the inside. Each bite was pure bliss. A&S Bagels truly knows how to make a great bagel.

Overall, my experience at A&S Bagels was nothing short of exceptional. The combination of fresh bagels, great customer service, and best prices makes this place a must-visit for any bagel lover in Long Island. I highly recommend checking out A&S Bagels for yourself and experiencing the joy of a truly great bagel.

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

Let There Be Bagels

Highlights
Clean and well-lit
Plump and yummy bagels
Amazing selection
Fresh and delicious
Great for breakfast

Let There Be Bagels is a gem in Long Island's bagel scene. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by a clean and well-lit space that immediately made me feel comfortable.

But let's talk about the real star of the show: the bagels. Oh, my goodness! These bagels were plump and absolutely yummy. Each bite was a heavenly experience that can only come from a bagel baked with love and expertise.

One of the things that impressed me the most about Let There Be Bagels was their amazing selection. Whether you're a traditionalist or an adventurous bagel lover, they have a flavor for everyone. From the classic plain bagel to the more exotic sun-dried tomato or everything bagel, the options seemed endless.

But what truly sets Let There Be Bagels apart is the quality. These bagels are fresh and delicious. You can tell that they were made with care and attention to detail. The texture was perfect - crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside.

Let There Be Bagels is not just a great spot for bagels; it's also perfect for breakfast. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere create a welcoming ambiance to start your day. I highly recommend grabbing your favorite bagel, slathering it with cream cheese or your choice of toppings, and savoring the moment in this bagel heaven.

If you're on the hunt for the best bagels in Long Island, make sure to visit Let There Be Bagels. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Bricktown Bagels & Cafe

Bricktown Bagels & Cafe in Long Island is a whimsical bagel haven that turned my breakfast into a delightful adventure. Their bagels are freshly baked and have a crispy exterior that seamlessly blends with their soft and pillowy interior. With a wide variety of flavors and toppings, this place delivers bagels that are both flavorful and visually enticing. Don't miss out on their signature everything bagel. Trust me, it's pure bagel bliss.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Bagel Boss

Bagel Boss in Long Island is a bagel paradise! The moment you step inside, the aroma of freshly baked bagels hits you like a warm, carb-filled hug. With a crispy exterior and a chewy yet pillowy-soft interior, their bagels are a pure delight. Don't miss their everything bagel – it's a flavor explosion in every bite! You'll definitely leave Bagel Boss feeling like a bagel connoisseur.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Bagel Boss of Roslyn

Bagel Boss of Roslyn in Long Island sure knows how to dish out some seriously delicious bagels! The moment I sunk my teeth into their perfectly toasted and chewy creation, I knew I had hit bagel nirvana. With a melt-in-your-mouth texture and flavorful toppings, this place is truly a bagel lover's dream come true. Don't just take my word for it, head over to Bagel Boss of Roslyn and let your taste buds be the judge!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Best Bagels

I was delighted with my visit to Best Bagels in Long Island! Their bagels are truly out-of-this-world. From the first bite, you can taste the perfect combination of a crispy exterior and a soft, doughy interior. With a wide range of flavors to choose from, including classic favorites like plain and sesame, as well as more adventurous options like everything and garlic, there's something for everyone. The impeccable service and charming atmosphere only added to the already unforgettable experience. I highly recommend checking out Best Bagels if you're craving a phenomenal bagel in Long Island!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Long Island Bagel Cafe

Long Island Bagel Cafe in Long Island was a delightful bagel experience. The bagels were fresh and packed with flavor. The crispy exterior and soft, chewy interior made each bite a pleasure. The staff was friendly and the variety of toppings was impressive. I highly recommend giving this place a try!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company

My taste buds danced with delight at Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company in Long Island. Their bagels are off the charts delicious. Fresh, chewy, and oh-so-satisfying, I couldn't help but devour their delightful creations. This place truly knows how to make a killer bagel!

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Hand Rolled Bagels

Oh boy, let me tell you, Hand Rolled Bagels in Long Island is a real treat for bagel lovers like me. The moment I stepped foot in the shop, I was hit with the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked bagels. And let me assure you, these bagels do not disappoint. Each one is hand rolled with love and care, resulting in a perfectly chewy and flavorful bite. The menu boasts a wide variety of options, from the classic plain and sesame to unique creations like the Everything bagel stuffed with pastrami and Swiss cheese. I couldn't resist trying a few different ones, and boy, was I glad I did. Each bagel was a delightful explosion of flavors, with a crust that had just the right crunch and a deliciously doughy interior. The real game changer though, was the schmear. Creamy, luscious, and generously slathered onto each bagel, it elevated the taste to a whole new level. Whether you prefer the classic cream cheese or fancy something more adventurous like the honey walnut, Hand Rolled Bagels has got your schmear needs covered. And the staff? Don't even get me started. They're friendly, helpful, and truly passionate about their craft. So next time you find yourself in Long Island, make sure to swing by Hand Rolled Bagels for a bagel-icious experience you won't forget. Trust me, your taste buds will be forever grateful.

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Bagel Boss Hicksville

Bagel Boss Hicksville, located in the heart of Long Island, is a bagel lover's paradise. They offer a wide variety of flavors, from classic everything to the more adventurous jalapeño cheddar. The bagels are always fresh and perfectly toasted, with a satisfying chewiness that is just so delightful. Plus, the staff is friendly and efficient, making for a quick and enjoyable experience. If you're in Long Island and need a bagel fix, this is the place to be. Bagel Boss Hicksville definitely deserves a spot in the article about the best bagels in Long Island!

Pumpernickel Bagel and Delicatessen

Pumpernickel Bagel and Delicatessen in Long Island is a hidden gem! With their perfect balance of crispy crust and chewy center, their bagels are a true delight. The variety of flavors is impressive, and their cream cheese spreads are to die for. Don't miss out on this bagel extravaganza!