The Absolute Best Bagels in Brooklyn Heights [Updated 2024]

In this article, I have diligently reviewed and taste-tested a total of 12 bagel spots in the charming neighborhood of Brooklyn Heights. Having grown up in this vibrant area, I hold a deep appreciation for quality bagels and the art of creating the perfect chewy texture and flavorful crust.

From traditional New York-style to innovative flavors, I have explored all the hidden gems and popular favorites that Brooklyn Heights has to offer. Join me on this journey as we uncover the must-try bagel shops that will leave you craving for more.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, this guide will satisfy your bagel cravings and ensure you never settle for anything less than the best.

La Bagel Delight at Court St

Highlights
Delicious bagels
Wide variety of sandwiches
Busy but good quality
Great morning spot

La Bagel Delight at Court St in Brooklyn Heights is a delightful spot to start your day with a scrumptious bagel. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of freshly baked bagels fills the air, instantly making your mouth water. The menu boasts a wide variety of sandwiches, ensuring there's something for everyone's taste buds.

Despite being quite busy, the quality of the bagels at La Bagel Delight never falters. Each bagel is a perfect combination of chewy and slightly crispy, with just the right amount of density. The diverse selection of flavors available includes classics like plain and sesame, as well as more adventurous options like everything, blueberry, and cinnamon raisin.

The bagels at La Bagel Delight truly shine when paired with their cream cheese spreads. Whether you prefer classic plain, savory scallion, or zesty sun-dried tomato, the spreads are whipped to perfection and generously slathered on each bagel.

With friendly staff and speedy service, La Bagel Delight is not just a great morning spot, but any time you're in need of a bagel fix. They offer a cozy seating area for those who wish to indulge in their bagel creation on-site, and quick take-out for those on the go.

In conclusion, if you're on a quest for the best bagels in Brooklyn Heights, La Bagel Delight at Court St is a definite must-visit. Their delicious bagels, wide variety of sandwiches, and bustling atmosphere make for a bagel experience you won't forget.

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Atlantic Bagels Cafe

Highlights
Fresh bagels
Friendly staff
Variety of cream cheese options

Let me start by saying, wow! Atlantic Bagels Cafe is a hidden gem in the heart of Brooklyn Heights. As soon as I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked bagels filled the air, instantly making my mouth water.

One of the highlights of this delightful cafe is their commitment to freshness. Every bite of their bagels was like a taste of heaven. The crust was perfectly crisp, while the inside was soft and chewy, just the way a bagel should be. The variety of flavors was impressive too, from classic plain to savory everything and even unique options like chocolate chip.

The staff at Atlantic Bagels Cafe were not only knowledgeable about their products, but also incredibly friendly. They greeted me with a warm smile and gladly offered recommendations. Their passion for bagels was evident, and they took the time to ensure every customer had a satisfying experience.

But what truly made Atlantic Bagels Cafe stand out from the rest was their wide selection of cream cheese. They had everything from the traditional favorites like plain and scallion, to more adventurous options like jalapeno and bacon cheddar. Each schmear was silky smooth, elevating the bagel experience to new heights.

In conclusion, if you're a bagel enthusiast like myself, Atlantic Bagels Cafe is a must-visit. With their fresh bagels, friendly staff, and vast array of cream cheese options, it's no wonder they're considered one of the best bagel spots in Brooklyn Heights. Don't just take my word for it -- go try one of their incredible bagels yourself and let your taste buds do the talking!

You might also want to check out the best diners in NYC.

La Bagel Delight at Dumbo

Highlights
Quality bagels
Fast service
Good value

La Bagel Delight at Dumbo in Brooklyn Heights is a hidden gem that deserves a spot in the list of the best bagels in the neighborhood. From the moment I entered, I was greeted with the heavenly aroma of freshly baked bagels, instantly tempting my taste buds.

The quality of their bagels is truly exceptional. Each one is perfectly baked to achieve that ideal combination of a chewy interior and a slightly crisp, golden crust. Whether you prefer classic flavors like plain, sesame, or poppy seed, or you're feeling adventurous and want to try their delectable everything or cinnamon raisin options, La Bagel Delight has got you covered. They certainly deliver on their name, ensuring delightful bites with every mouthful.

One thing that particularly impressed me was the fast service. Despite the steady stream of customers, the staff worked with incredible efficiency, ensuring that orders were taken swiftly and bagels were delivered promptly. It's an ideal spot for those who are seeking a quick and satisfying breakfast before a busy day in the city.

Perhaps one of the best things about La Bagel Delight at Dumbo is the excellent value it offers. The prices are reasonable, especially considering the generous size of their bagels. You truly get more than what you pay for, making it a great choice for anyone on a budget.

In conclusion, La Bagel Delight at Dumbo in Brooklyn Heights is a must-visit establishment for bagel enthusiasts. With their quality bagels, fast service, and unbeatable value, you won't be disappointed. Stop by and treat yourself to a truly delightful bagel experience!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in NYC.

Lassen & Hennigs

Oh boy, oh boy! Lassen & Hennigs in Brooklyn Heights is the bagel holy grail! With their perfectly chewy and oh-so-fresh bagels, every bite is pure bliss. The variety of flavors and toppings will make your taste buds dance with joy. Trust me, these bagels are drool-worthy!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Brooklyn.

Black Seed Bagels Boerum Hill

Black Seed Bagels Boerum Hill in Brooklyn Heights certainly lives up to its hype. With a playful yet professional ambiance, their bagels are simply outstanding. The texture is perfectly chewy and their unique touch of wood-fired crust brings a delightful, smoky flavor. It's a must-visit for any bagel lover in Brooklyn Heights.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Manhattan.

Sunset Bagels Cafe & Grill

Sunset Bagels Cafe & Grill in Brooklyn Heights is a hidden gem for bagel lovers. The variety of flavors and exceptional quality truly sets them apart. The crispiness of the outer crust and chewiness of the inside make for a perfect texture. Don't forget to try their lox and cream cheese bagel for a taste bud explosion. It's definitely a must-visit spot for bagel enthusiasts!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Manhattan.

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe in Brooklyn Heights is a bagel lover's paradise! The bagels are fresh and flavorful, with a perfect crunch on the outside and a soft, chewy center. The variety of spread options is mind-boggling, from creamy lox to dreamy veggie schmears. A must-visit for bagel aficionados!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in NYC.

Montague Street Bagels

Montague Street Bagels in Brooklyn Heights, oh how you make my taste buds sing! With your perfectly chewy texture and wide variety of flavors, I couldn't help but fall in love at first bite. Whether you're a classic lox-and-schmear kind of person or an adventurous everything bagel aficionado, this place has it all. Plus, the friendly staff and cozy atmosphere only add to the charm. Trust me, you don't want to miss out on these mouthwatering treats!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in NYC.

Court Street Bagels

Court Street Bagels, an establishment nestled in the heart of Brooklyn Heights, is a haven for bagel enthusiasts. I embarked on a delicious adventure, immersing my taste buds in their diverse selection. Each bite felt like a symphony of flavors, with the perfect ratio of chewiness to crustiness. The staff, ever friendly and attentive, added a touch of warmth to the experience. If you're in search of an extraordinary bagel, look no further. Court Street Bagels is the answer to your carb-filled dreams.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in NYC.

Ess-a-Bagel Time Out Market New York

Ess-a-Bagel Time Out Market New York in Brooklyn Heights is a bagel lover's paradise. The menu offers a wide variety of bagel options, from classic flavors to creative combinations. The bagels are perfectly chewy on the inside, with a crispy crust that will make your taste buds dance. Don't miss out on their signature spreads, they take the bagel experience to a whole new level. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make this place a must-visit for any bagel enthusiast in Brooklyn Heights.

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in NYC.

Smith Street Bagels

Let me tell you, Smith Street Bagels in Brooklyn Heights is a little slice of carb heaven. Upon entering, I was greeted by the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked bagels. The place had a cozy and inviting ambiance, perfect for enjoying a morning nosh. The bagel selection was impressive, with an array of flavors to satisfy both traditionalists and adventurists alike. I opted for their "Everything" bagel, and let me just say, it was everything and more! The bagel was delightfully chewy, with a perfectly crisp exterior. The seasoning was generously sprinkled, adding a burst of flavor to each bite. The cream cheese schmear was smooth and creamy, making every mouthful even more decadent. The service was prompt and friendly, and the prices were reasonable. I highly recommend Smith Street Bagels to any bagel enthusiast looking for their next fix.

Pio Bagel

My, oh my, what a delightful find! Pio Bagel in Brooklyn Heights is truly a hidden gem. The moment I bit into their pillowy yet chewy bagel, I knew I had stumbled upon something special. Their extensive menu offers a variety of innovative flavors, like the decadent everything bagel stuffed with creamy avocado. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make it the perfect spot for a morning treat. Don't miss out on this must-visit bagel joint in Brooklyn Heights!