Manhattan's Best Toy Stores [Updated 2025]

These toy stores are more than just shops; they’re magical realms brimming with imagination and nostalgia. I’ve scoured the city, visiting 12 of the top spots that truly capture the spirit of play.

As someone who’s spent years navigating the vibrant streets of Manhattan, I know where to find the hidden gems and the iconic favorites that will delight both kids and the young at heart. Trust me when I say that each store on this list has its own unique charm, ready to spark joy and inspiration. So, whether you’re hunting for the latest trend or a classic treasure, get ready to rediscover the thrill of playtime in the heart of the city!

West Side Kids

Highlights
Variety of toys available
Quality items in stock
Curated selection of books
Locally-owned shop preference
Great for birthday gifts

West Side Kids is an enchanting treasure trove that transported me back to my childhood the moment I stepped inside. This charming store brims with an impressive variety of toys, catering to all ages—from plush animals that invite snuggles to intricate puzzles that spark curiosity. I was particularly taken by their curated selection of books, which inspired imaginations and promised countless bedtime adventures.

What truly stood out to me was the emphasis on quality items that reflect the store's dedication to providing exceptional products. Each toy seemed to carry a story, inviting children and adults alike to explore and engage. As I browsed, I couldn't help but admire the warmth of this locally-owned shop, which offers a refreshing alternative to larger chain stores.

Whether you're hunting for the perfect birthday gift or simply wanting to indulge your inner child, West Side Kids is a delightful destination. The welcoming atmosphere, paired with the knowledgeable staff, creates an inviting space that leaves you with a smile. If you find yourself in Manhattan, don’t miss out on this whimsical wonderland—it's a place where magic truly comes alive!

You might also want to check out the best views in NYC.

FAO Schwarz

Visiting FAO Schwarz is like stepping into a whimsical wonderland! The moment I entered, I was greeted by a symphony of delight, with life-sized stuffed animals and magical displays. The interactive experiences—from giant piano keys to personalized toys—make this store a true treasure. I was particularly captivated by the charm of their classic toys and the nostalgia they evoke. The staff, with their infectious enthusiasm, adds to the store’s allure. Whether you're seeking a unique gift or simply indulging your inner child, FAO Schwarz is an unforgettable destination in Manhattan that sparks joy at every corner!

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in NYC.

Toy Tokyo

Stepping into Toy Tokyo is like entering a whimsical wonderland where nostalgia meets modern collectibles. This gem, nestled in the heart of the East Village, boasts an extraordinary selection of vintage toys and unique designer pieces that will delight enthusiasts of all ages. The vibrant atmosphere, adorned with colorful displays, instantly transports you back to childhood. I was especially captivated by their kaiju figures and limited-edition collectibles. The staff is incredibly friendly and knowledgeable, making this an inviting spot to explore. If you're searching for that perfect gift or a slice of nostalgia, Toy Tokyo is an absolute must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best irish pubs in NYC.

Mary Arnold Toys

Mary Arnold Toys is a delightful gem tucked away in the heart of Manhattan. As I entered, the air was filled with the enchanting scent of nostalgia. The store is brimming with a curated selection of whimsical toys that cater to all ages! I was particularly charmed by their unique, eco-friendly options and classic wooden games that spark imagination. The staff exudes genuine passion, happily guiding you through their colorful aisles. This delightful shop isn’t just a store; it’s a treasure trove of joy and inspiration. For anyone seeking the perfect gift, Mary Arnold Toys is an absolute must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.

Grandma's Place

Stepping into Grandma's Place feels like tumbling down the rabbit hole of nostalgia! This charming boutique offers a whimsical selection of toys that ignite the imagination and warm the heart. From classic wooden puzzles to vibrant art supplies, there’s something special for every child—and child-at-heart. The inviting atmosphere, adorned with delightful displays, encourages exploration and discovery. The staff is genuinely friendly, ready to share recommendations and stories about their favorite finds. If you’re on the hunt for something unique and playful, Grandma's Place is a must-visit gem in the heart of Manhattan!

You might also want to check out the best escape rooms in NYC.

Boomerang Toys

Boomerang Toys is a delightful gem nestled in Manhattan, bursting with charm and whimsical wonder. As I wandered through the aisles, I was greeted by an array of classic and contemporary toys that evoke a sense of nostalgia. The staff were not only friendly but also incredibly knowledgeable, ready to guide my exploration. From handcrafted wooden puzzles to quirky plush figures, each item seemed to tell a story. The inviting atmosphere and carefully curated selection make it a must-visit destination for anyone who believes in the magic of play. Don’t miss the chance to rediscover your inner child at this enchanting toy store!

You might also want to check out the best shopping in Brooklyn.

Tenacious Toys

Stepping into Tenacious Toys felt like entering a whimsical wonderland! This delightful shop specializes in designer toys and collectibles, making it a haven for both kids and adults alike. The vast array of unique items, from quirky figurines to limited-edition pieces, ignited my imagination. The staff was knowledgeable and passionate, eager to share the stories behind the toys. I particularly loved the indie artist creations that you won't find anywhere else. If you're seeking a store where nostalgia meets creativity, Tenacious Toys is an absolute must-visit in Manhattan's vibrant toy landscape!

You might also want to check out the best law firms in NYC.

Kidding Around

Stepping into Kidding Around is like entering a whimsical wonderland of childhood delight! This charming toy store bursts with imagination, showcasing a delightful assortment of toys that engage both the mind and spirit. From beautifully crafted wooden toys to the latest trendy gadgets, there's something for everyone. The cozy layout invites exploration, while the knowledgeable staff is eager to recommend hidden gems. I particularly loved their unique selection of educational games. It’s a perfect stop for parents and kids alike, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking to spark joy and creativity in a child’s heart.

You might also want to check out the best libraries in NYC.

Tommy's Figz

At Tommy's Figz, every corner bursts with whimsical charm! This delightful haven is a treasure trove of unique toys, from artisanal plushies to vintage-inspired games. I was particularly enchanted by the friendly staff who are as enthusiastic about play as the kids they serve. The store’s layout draws you in, creating an inviting atmosphere where imagination thrives. Each item feels carefully curated, making it a perfect stop for both gift-givers and curious explorers. If you're on the hunt for something special, Tommy's Figz is a must-visit that will leave your heart brimming with joy!

You might also want to check out the best lawyers in NYC.

Toys 4 U

Toys 4 U in Manhattan is a whimsical wonderland for toy enthusiasts of all ages. The moment you step inside, you're greeted by a kaleidoscope of colors and an array of delightful toys that spark the imagination. From classic board games to the latest action figures, there's something for everyone. The staff is not only knowledgeable but also genuinely passionate, eager to help you find that perfect gift. I was especially enchanted by their interactive play zones, where kids can test out toys before they buy. A trip to Toys 4 U is truly a joyful adventure!

You might also want to check out the best lounges in NYC.

Horae Play Arcade & Crafts

Nestled in the heart of Manhattan, Horae Play Arcade & Crafts is a delightful treasure trove for imaginative minds. The vibrant atmosphere buzzes with the energy of children exploring a diverse collection of toys and games. From hands-on crafts to innovative arcade games, every corner ignites creativity. I particularly loved the various craft stations, where little ones can express themselves freely. The staff is incredibly friendly, always ready to assist, enhancing the overall experience. If you’re in search of a place that fuses play and creativity, this whimsical store is an absolute must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best boutiques in NYC.

Toys "Я" Us at Macy's

During my visit to Toys "Я" Us at Macy's, I was immediately immersed in a whimsical wonderland of toys that spark joy for all ages. The vibrant displays and organized aisles make it an inviting space to explore. From the latest action figures to classic board games, there's truly something for everyone. The staff were incredibly helpful, adding warmth to the shopping experience. This location is not just about shopping; it’s about reliving childhood memories. For anyone in search of a memorable toy adventure in the heart of Manhattan, this store is a must-visit! 🌟

You might also want to check out the best parks in Brooklyn.